Effect of Molecular Structure of Quinones and Carbon Electrode Surfaces on the Interfacial Electron Transfer Process

Graziela C. Sedenho, Diana De Porcellinis, Yan Jing, Emily F. Kerr, L.m. Mejía-Mendoza, Álvaro Vázquez‐Mayagoitia, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik, Roy G. Gordon, Frank N. Crespilho, Michael J. AzizACS 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the structure of organic molecules called quinones and the surface of carbon electrodes affect their ability to transfer electrons, a crucial process for energy storage. They found that carbon electrodes with specific defects and oxygen-containing groups significantly boost electron transfer, paving the way for more efficient, catalyst-free organic batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Storing energy from intermittent renewable sources like wind and solar is a major challenge. Redox flow batteries (RFBs) are a promising solution for large-scale energy storage, but their performance hinges on the electroactive materials and electrode surfaces. Quinones are attractive candidates for these batteries due to their abundance and potential for low cost. However, their electrochemical performance isn't just about their molecular structure; the electrode surface plays a critical role. This paper aims to untangle this complex relationship, specifically focusing on how different carbon electrode surfaces influence the electron transfer kinetics of quinone derivatives. Understanding this is key to designing better electrodes for organic RFBs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining experimental and theoretical techniques:

  • Cyclic Voltammetry (CV): This is a standard electrochemical technique used to study the redox behavior of molecules. By analyzing the shape and separation of peaks in the voltammograms, they could assess the reversibility and kinetics of electron transfer.
  • Anodic Stripping Voltammetry: Used to quantify the amount of quinone adsorbed onto the electrode surface.
  • Raman Spectroscopy, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): These surface characterization techniques were used to understand the structural, morphological, and chemical properties of the different carbon electrodes.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations and Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: These computational methods were used to model the interactions between quinone molecules and the electrode surfaces at an atomic level, providing insights into adsorption energies and binding mechanisms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements and computational modeling of specific quinone molecules and carbon electrode surfaces.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface Matters (A Lot!): The electrochemical performance of quinones is highly dependent on the carbon electrode's surface structure. This isn't just about surface area; the presence of specific defects and functional groups is paramount.
  • Defects are Good (for Electron Transfer): Electrodes with a high density of "edge-plane-like" defects, like the High Edge-Density Graphite Electrode (HEDGE), significantly improve electron transfer kinetics compared to smoother surfaces like highly ordered pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) or glassy carbon (GC).
  • Oxygenated Groups are Key: The HEDGE surface, with its higher concentration of oxygen-containing functional groups (C-O and C=O), appears to be crucial for facilitating strong interactions with the quinone molecules.
  • Physisorption Drives Kinetics: The interaction between quinones and the HEDGE surface is primarily driven by weak van der Waals forces (physisorption), not strong chemical bonding. This allows for rapid electron transfer.
  • Molecular Structure Influences Adsorption: The degree of adsorption of quinones on the HEDGE surface varies significantly based on their molecular structure, with molecules featuring sulfonic acid groups and more aromatic rings showing stronger adsorption.

Key Results

  • HEDGE Outperforms: The HEDGE electrode consistently showed more reversible and faster electron transfer kinetics for all four quinone derivatives tested compared to HOPG and GC. This was evidenced by smaller peak-to-peak separations (ΔEp) in cyclic voltammetry, with values as low as 12 mV for BQDS on HEDGE, indicating near-reversible behavior.
  • Surface Excess Varies Widely: The amount of quinone adsorbed on the HEDGE surface varied by more than two orders of magnitude, with ARS showing the highest surface excess and FQ the lowest.
  • Computational Agreement: DFT calculations of adsorption energies (ΔEads) correlated well with the experimentally observed surface excesses, supporting the role of oxygenated functional groups and van der Waals forces in the adsorption process. ARS, with the highest calculated ΔEads, also showed the highest experimental surface excess.
  • Catalyst-Free Potential: The findings suggest that high-performance carbon electrodes for organic batteries can be developed without the need for catalysts, by engineering surfaces with specific defects and oxygen functionalities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Specific Quinones: The study focused on four specific quinone derivatives. Further research could explore a wider range of quinone structures and their interactions with various engineered carbon surfaces.
  • Acidic Conditions: The experiments were conducted in strongly acidic conditions (pH ≈ 0). Investigating performance in neutral or alkaline conditions, which are often preferred for practical applications, would be valuable.
  • Full Cell Performance: While this study provides fundamental insights into interfacial electron transfer, the next logical step would be to evaluate the performance of these engineered electrodes in actual organic redox flow battery cells.
  • Understanding Desorption: While the study observed different desorption profiles for the quinones, a deeper understanding of the factors governing desorption kinetics and their impact on long-term battery cycling would be beneficial.
  • Mechanism of Interaction: While physisorption is identified, further detailed studies could elucidate the precise nature of the interactions between specific functional groups on the quinones and the oxygenated defects on the HEDGE surface.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quinones can undergo thermodynamically reversible proton-coupled electron transfer reactions and are being applied as electroactive compounds in aqueous organic batteries. However, the electrochemical reversibility of these compounds is affected not only by their molecular structure but also by the properties of a carbon-based electrode surface. This study combines experimental and theoretical approaches to understand this dependence. We study the electron transfer kinetics of two synthesized quinone derivatives and two commercially available ones with a glassy carbon, a highly ordered pyrolytic graphite, and a high-edge-density graphite electrode (HEDGE). The electrochemical reversibility is notably improved on the HEDGE, which shows a higher density of defects and presents oxygenated functional groups at its surface. The electron transfer kinetics are controlled by adsorbed species onto the HEDGE. Molecular dynamics simulation and quantum mechanics calculations suggest defects with oxygen-containing functional groups, such as C–O and C═O, on HEDGE surfaces drive the interaction with the functional groups of the molecules, during physisorption from van der Waals forces. The presence of sulfonic acid side groups and a greater number of aromatic rings in the molecular structure may contribute to a higher stabilization of quinone derivatives on HEDGEs. We propose that high-performance carbon-based electrodes can be obtained without catalysts for organic batteries, by the engineering of carbon-based surfaces with edge-like defects and oxygenated functional groups.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sedenho2020effect,
  author = {Graziela C. Sedenho and Diana De Porcellinis and Yan Jing and Emily F. Kerr and L.M. Mejía-Mendoza and Álvaro Vázquez‐Mayagoitia and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik and Roy G. Gordon and Frank N. Crespilho and Michael J. Aziz},
  title = {{Effect of Molecular Structure of Quinones and Carbon Electrode Surfaces on the Interfacial Electron Transfer Process}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1021/acsaem.9b02357},
}
Figure