Effect of Grain Boundary Carbide on High Temperature Creep Behavior of 15Cr-25Ni Steel

Junshan Zhang, Wei‐Shing Chen, Ziben Cao, Ryohei TanakaTetsu-to-Hagane 1989 · DOI

Abstract

In order to clarify the strengthening mechanism due to grain boundary carbide precipitation, creep behavior and dislocation substructure developed during creep of 15Cr-25Ni steels with different carbon content have been studied at 850 and 950°C under stresses of 14.7-79.2 MPa. With the grain boundary carbide precipitation, creep resistance and rupture life increased markedly, showing significant grain boundary precipitation strengthening by carbide. The minimum creep rate of γ single phase steel was independent on grain size, while it increased with increasing grain size in the steels with grain boundary carbide precipitation. With grain boundary carbide precipitation, dislocation density near grain boundary increased, but little difference in dislocation substructure within grains was observed in both steels. This suggests that grain boundary carbide strongly obstructs dislocation annihilation at grain boundaries, and therefore markedly increase the creep resistance. It is also suggested that the minimum creep rate of the steel with the grain boundary precipitation is controlled by recovery process near the grain boundaries instead of recovery at subboundaries which control the creep rate of γ single phase steel.

Introduction

Creep deformation—the slow, permanent deformation of materials under constant stress at high temperatures—is a primary concern for engineers designing power plants and jet engines. While general precipitation strengthening is a well-established technique to improve material performance, the specific role of precipitates localized at grain boundaries (GB) has been less clear. This study investigates how $M_{23}C_6$ carbides, specifically when precipitated at grain boundaries, influence the high-temperature creep resistance and dislocation dynamics of 15Cr-25Ni austenitic steel.

Materials and Experimental Procedure

The researchers compared three variations of 15Cr-25Ni steel with different carbon contents to isolate the effects of carbide distribution:

  • C1: Ultra-low carbon (base metal, single-phase austenite).
  • C2: Medium carbon (carbides precipitated primarily at the grain boundaries).
  • C3: Higher carbon (carbides at both grain boundaries and within the grains).

Samples were solution-treated at 1200°C and subsequently aged at 850°C or 950°C to control the carbide morphology. Creep tests were conducted at these temperatures under stresses ranging from 14.7 to 79.2 MPa. The resulting dislocation substructures were analyzed using Optical and Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM).

Figure 1: Optical micrographs showing the microstructural evolution across the three alloy variants: (a) clean grain boundaries in the single-phase C1 alloy, (b) carbides localized at grain boundaries in C2, and (c) extensive precipitation in both boundaries and matrix in C3.

Key Insights and Strengthening Mechanisms

The Dislocation Blockade

In the single-phase austenite (C1), dislocations move toward the grain boundaries and "annihilate" (disappear), which facilitates continuous deformation. In contrast, the carbides in the C2 alloy act as physical barriers. Dislocations pile up against these grain boundary carbides, significantly increasing local dislocation density and making it harder for the material to recover and continue deforming.

Mechanism Shift

The study reveals a fundamental shift in the creep mechanism. In standard single-phase steel, creep is controlled by recovery at "subboundaries" (dislocation structures within grains). However, when GB carbides are present, the bottleneck for deformation shifts to the recovery process occurring specifically near the grain boundaries. This change is reflected in the stress exponent ($n$), which increased from 5 in the base metal to 7 in the carbide-strengthened steel.

The Grain Size Paradox

Typically, larger grains improve creep resistance by reducing the total grain boundary area available for sliding. However, in the steel with GB carbides, the minimum creep rate actually increased with larger grain sizes. The authors attribute this to higher stress concentrations at the boundaries in larger-grained materials, which accelerates the recovery process near those boundaries.

Results and Conclusions

The strategic precipitation of carbides at grain boundaries yielded massive performance gains:

  • Creep Rate Reduction: The minimum creep rate was reduced by nearly an order of magnitude compared to the base metal.
  • Extended Rupture Life: Rupture life increased by approximately 20 times in the low-stress regime for carbide-strengthened samples.
  • Activation Energy: The activation energy for creep in the carbide-strengthened steel was higher than that for self-diffusion in iron, indicating a new, higher energy barrier to deformation.

In conclusion, grain boundary carbide precipitation is a highly effective method for enhancing the high-temperature performance of 15Cr-25Ni steels. By obstructing dislocation annihilation at boundaries, these precipitates fundamentally alter the material's recovery mechanism, providing a robust pathway for designing more creep-resistant alloys.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to clarify the strengthening mechanism due to grain boundary carbide precipitation, creep behavior and dislocation substructure developed during creep of 15Cr-25Ni steels with different carbon content have been studied at 850 and 950°C under stresses of 14.7-79.2 MPa. With the grain boundary carbide precipitation, creep resistance and rupture life increased markedly, showing significant grain boundary precipitation strengthening by carbide. The minimum creep rate of γ single phase steel was independent on grain size, while it increased with increasing grain size in the steels with grain boundary carbide precipitation. With grain boundary carbide precipitation, dislocation density near grain boundary increased, but little difference in dislocation substructure within grains was observed in both steels. This suggests that grain boundary carbide strongly obstructs dislocation annihilation at grain boundaries, and therefore markedly increase the creep resistance. It is also suggested that the minimum creep rate of the steel with the grain boundary precipitation is controlled by recovery process near the grain boundaries instead of recovery at subboundaries which control the creep rate of γ single phase steel.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang1989effect,
  author = {Junshan Zhang and Wei‐Shing Chen and Ziben CAO and Ryohei Tanaka},
  title = {{Effect of Grain Boundary Carbide on High Temperature Creep Behavior of 15Cr-25Ni Steel}},
  booktitle = {Tetsu-to-Hagane},
  year = {1989},
  doi = {10.2355/tetsutohagane1955.75.3\_545},
}
Figure