Effect of Forestland Property Rights and Village Off-Farm Environment on Off-Farm Employment in Southern China

Yang Yang, Hua Li, Zhen Liu, Cheng Long, Assem Abu Hatab, Jing LanSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how forestland property rights and the local village economy influence rural Chinese households' decisions to seek off-farm employment. It finds that stronger rights to transfer and harvest forestland encourage off-farm work, but this effect is moderated by the village's overall reliance on off-farm income.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's rapid industrialization and urbanization have led to a massive shift of rural labor to non-agricultural sectors. While this migration boosts the economy, it also creates labor shortages in rural areas, particularly in collective forest regions. China's Collective Forest Tenure Reform (CFTR) aims to clarify property rights to optimize labor allocation. However, it's unclear how these reforms, specifically forestland property rights, interact with the local village economic environment to influence off-farm employment decisions. This paper seeks to fill this gap by examining how different forestland property rights (use, transfer, mortgage, harvesting) and the village's off-farm income ratio affect both the decision to seek off-farm work and the extent of off-farm labor supply.

Methods

The researchers employed a double-hurdle model to analyze the two-stage decision-making process of off-farm employment: first, the decision to participate, and second, the degree of labor supply. This model combines a probit model for the participation decision and a truncated regression model for the labor supply, allowing for different factors to influence each stage. They used survey data from 742 rural households in Zhejiang and Jiangxi provinces, two key regions for China's CFTR. Forestland property rights were measured by farmers' perceived recognition of various rights (use, transfer, mortgage, harvesting), and the village off-farm environment was captured by the proportion of off-farm income in the village.

Datasets

The study utilized survey data collected in 2017 from 742 rural households in Zhejiang and Jiangxi provinces, China. This data covers household demographics, labor allocation, forestland characteristics, and perceptions of forestland property rights.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transfer and Harvesting Rights Matter: Stronger rights to transfer and harvest forestland are key drivers for rural households to seek off-farm employment. This suggests that when farmers feel more secure and autonomous in managing their forest assets, they are more willing to explore non-agricultural income sources.
  • Village Economy as a Moderator: The local village context, specifically its reliance on off-farm income, significantly alters the impact of forestland property rights. As a village becomes more dependent on off-farm earnings, the influence of certain property rights shifts.
  • Transfer Rights Lose Steam, Harvesting Rights Gain Traction: In villages with a high proportion of off-farm income, the positive effect of forestland transfer rights on off-farm employment weakens. Conversely, forestland harvesting rights become more influential, suggesting that secure income from forest resources becomes more critical when off-farm opportunities are abundant.
  • Mortgage Rights Underperform: Despite being a component of property rights, forestland mortgage rights did not show a significant impact on off-farm employment decisions. This might be due to low awareness or limited uptake of forestland mortgage schemes among rural households.

Key Results

  • Participation: Forestland transfer rights significantly and positively influence the decision to participate in off-farm labor. Harvesting rights also show a positive, though less significant, effect.
  • Labor Supply: Both transfer rights and harvesting rights significantly and positively impact the degree of off-farm labor supply. The village off-farm income ratio also positively affects labor supply, indicating that as villages rely more on off-farm income, households supply more labor.
  • Interaction Effects: The village off-farm income ratio moderates the impact of property rights. Specifically, it weakens the positive effect of transfer rights on both participation and supply, while strengthening the positive effect of harvesting rights on labor supply.
  • Control Variables: Factors like male labor proportion, age, education level, presence of elderly family members, and having a village cadre in the family also significantly influence off-farm employment decisions and labor supply. Larger forest areas tend to decrease off-farm labor supply.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's findings are based on survey data from specific provinces in China and may not be universally generalizable. They also note that the popularity of forestland mortgage rights is low, limiting their observed impact. Future work could explore the effectiveness of different policy interventions to promote forestland mortgage schemes and investigate the impact of property rights in other regions or countries with similar land tenure systems. The study also suggests further promotion of the CFTR, improvement of forestland circulation mechanisms, and refinement of forest harvest quota systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reasonably promoting the off-farm employment of rural surplus labor in China’s collective forest areas is an important way to increase forest resources and increase farmers’ income. China’s new round of collective forest tenure reform (CFTR) aims to optimize forest area labor allocation by strengthening forestland property rights. Therefore, in different village off-farm environments, it is necessary to explore how forestland property rights affect off-farm employment in forest areas. Based on survey data from 742 households in Zhejiang and Jiangxi provinces, this paper examines this effect using the double-hurdle model. The results indicate that forestland transfer rights promote decision-making about, and the supply of, off-farm labor, while forest harvesting rights significantly increase the supply of off-farm labor. The villages’ off-farm income ratio also affected the supply of off-farm labor. Moreover, under the regulation of the village off-farm income ratio, the positive incentives of forestland transfer rights on decision-making about, and the supply of, off-farm labor gradually weakened, but the incentive effect of forest harvesting rights on the supply of off-farm labor gradually increased. It is proposed that the CFTR should be further promoted, the forestland circulation mechanism and regulating forest harvest quota system should be improved, and implementation of forestry property mortgages should be strengthened.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2020effect,
  author = {Yang Yang and Hua Li and Zhen Liu and Cheng Long and Assem Abu Hatab and Jing Lan},
  title = {{Effect of Forestland Property Rights and Village Off-Farm Environment on Off-Farm Employment in Southern China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12072605},
}
Figure