Effect of deprotonation on absorption and emission spectra of Ru(ii)-bpy complexes functionalized with carboxyl groups

Ekaterina Badaeva, Victor V. Albert, Svetlana Kilina, Alexey Y. Koposov, Milan Sýkora, Sergei TretiakPhysical 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how adding and removing acidic carboxyl groups on ruthenium-bipyridine complexes affects their light absorption and emission. They found that adding carboxyl groups shifts light absorption to lower energies (red-shift), while removing them shifts it to higher energies (blue-shift). This work is crucial for designing better light-harvesting materials for solar energy applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ruthenium(II)-polypyridine complexes are vital components in various technologies, particularly in solar energy conversion devices like Grätzel cells. To optimize these devices, researchers often modify these complexes by attaching functional groups, such as carboxylic acids, to their ligands. These carboxylic acid groups serve as anchors to bind the complex to surfaces like TiO2. However, the protonation state of these carboxylic acid groups (protonated -COOH vs. deprotonated -COO⁻) significantly impacts the complex's electronic structure and, consequently, its optical properties (how it absorbs and emits light). Understanding and predicting these changes is essential for designing more efficient and tailored materials. This paper aims to systematically study the effect of these carboxyl groups, both in their protonated and deprotonated forms, on the absorption and emission spectra of specific Ru(II)-bipyridine complexes.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of experimental and theoretical methods:

  • Experimental Techniques:
    • Absorption Spectroscopy: Measured how much light the complexes absorb at different wavelengths.
  • Emission Spectroscopy (Photoluminescence): Measured the light emitted by the complexes after excitation.
  • Titration: Used acids (HPF6) and bases (NaOH) to precisely control the protonation state of the carboxyl groups in solution and observe the spectral changes.
  • Theoretical Methods:
    • Density Functional Theory (DFT): Used to model the ground-state electronic structure (molecular orbital energy levels) of the complexes.
  • Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TDDFT): Used to calculate excited-state properties, including vertical excitation energies (for absorption spectra) and transition energies for fluorescence and phosphorescence.
  • Natural Transition Orbitals (NTOs): A key analysis tool to visualize and understand the nature of electronic transitions (where electrons move from and to) during light absorption and emission. This helps identify whether transitions are metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) or ligand-centered.
  • Solvation Models (PCM): To account for the effect of the solvent (acetonitrile) on the electronic structure and optical properties, particularly important for deprotonated species. They compared different PCM implementations (GAUSSIAN03 vs. GAUSSIAN09) to assess their impact.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of specific Ru(II)-bipyridine complexes and their spectral properties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Carboxyl Group's Dual Role: The presence of carboxyl groups significantly influences the electronic structure. Protonated groups (-COOH) act as electron-withdrawing groups, stabilizing the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMOs) localized on the functionalized ligands. This leads to a red-shift in absorption and emission.
  • Deprotonation's Dramatic Effect: Deprotonation to the carboxylate form (-COO⁻) dramatically alters the electronic landscape. The negatively charged carboxylate groups destabilize the LUMOs, leading to a blue-shift in the absorption and emission spectra. This effect is attributed to a combination of increased electron density and changes in solvatochromism (how solvent affects spectral properties).
  • Solvation is Crucial: The solvation model used in theoretical calculations significantly impacts the predicted electronic structure, especially for the deprotonated complexes. Advanced solvation models are necessary for accurate predictions.
  • MLCT Dominance: Both absorption and emission in these complexes are primarily driven by Metal-to-Ligand Charge Transfer (MLCT) transitions. The nature of the occupied (hole) and unoccupied (electron) orbitals involved in these transitions dictates the spectral shifts.
  • Triplet State Complexity: The lowest triplet excited state can be either weakly optically allowed (³MLCT) or optically forbidden (³d-d). The precise nature and energy of this state are highly sensitive to the initial guess used in TDDFT calculations, highlighting the complexity of excited-state potential energy surfaces. This sensitivity is crucial for understanding phosphorescence.

Key Results

  • Red-shift upon Functionalization: Introduction of carboxyl groups (protonated) shifts the MLCT absorption and emission bands to lower energies compared to the unsubstituted complex.
  • Blue-shift upon Deprotonation: Deprotonation of the carboxyl groups results in a blue-shift in both absorption and phosphorescence spectra, consistent across all studied complexes. This shift is more pronounced in complexes with multiple carboxylate groups.
  • Theoretical Reproducibility: TDDFT calculations, when incorporating appropriate solvation models, successfully reproduce the experimental trends in absorption and emission spectra, with a typical systematic blue-shift of ~0.25 eV for absorption.
  • NTO Analysis Clarity: Natural Transition Orbitals (NTOs) provided clear insights into the electronic transitions, confirming MLCT character and revealing the localization of electron and hole orbitals, which explains the observed spectral shifts.
  • Dipole Moment Changes: Deprotonation leads to significant changes in static dipole moments, with deprotonated complexes exhibiting larger ground-state dipole moments than their excited states, contributing to negative solvatochromism and the observed blue-shift.

Limitations and Future Work

  • TDDFT Blue-shift: A systematic blue-shift of ~0.25 eV in calculated absorption energies compared to experimental data is noted, attributed to inherent limitations of TDDFT, lack of vibrational effects, and potential incompleteness of counter-ion description.
  • Triplet State Sensitivity: The strong dependence of the calculated lowest triplet excited state on the initial wavefunction guess highlights the complexity of excited-state potential energy surfaces and suggests that experimental conditions (solvent, pH, etc.) can significantly influence emission properties.
  • Vibrational Overtones: The presence of shoulders in experimental spectra, not fully captured by theoretical calculations, is attributed to vibrational overtones and potentially spin-spin/spin-orbit couplings, which were not included in the theoretical models.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings are valuable for optimizing Ru(II)-polypyridine complexes in photo-electrochemical cells and catalyst agents. Further investigations into the complexity of triplet excited states and their dependence on experimental conditions are implied. The study also lays the groundwork for more accurate theoretical predictions of excited-state properties in similar systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Changes in the ground and excited state electronic structure of the [Ru(bpy)(3)](2+) (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) complex induced by functionalization of bpy ligands with carboxyl and methyl groups in their protonated and deprotonated forms are studied experimentally using absorption and emission spectroscopy and theoretically using density functional theory (DFT) and time dependent DFT (TDDFT). The introduction of the carboxyl groups shifts the metal-to-ligand-charge-transfer (MLCT) absorption and emission bands to lower energies in functionalized complexes. Our calculations show that this red-shift is due to the stabilization of the lowest unoccupied orbitals localized on the substituted ligands, while the energies of the highest occupied orbitals localized on the Ru-center are not significantly affected. Consistent with previously observed trends in optical spectra of related Ru(II) complexes, deprotonation of the carboxyl groups results in a blue shift in the absorption and phosphorescence spectra. The effect originates from interplay of positive and negative solvatochromism in the protonated and deprotonated complexes, respectively. This results in more delocalized character of the electron transition orbitals in the deprotonated species and a strong destabilization of the three lowest unoccupied orbitals localized on the substituted and unsubstituted ligands, all of which contribute to the lowest-energy optical transitions. We also found that owing to the complexity of the excited state potential energy surfaces, the calculated lowest triplet excited state can be either weakly optically allowed (3)MLCT or optically forbidden Ru (3)d-d transition depending on the initial wavefunction guess used in TDDFT calculations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{badaeva2010effect,
  author = {Ekaterina Badaeva and Victor V. Albert and Svetlana Kilina and Alexey Y. Koposov and Milan Sýkora and Sergei Tretiak},
  title = {{Effect of deprotonation on absorption and emission spectra of Ru(ii)-bpy complexes functionalized with carboxyl groups}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1039/b924910a},
}
Figure