Effect of Carbon on High Temperature Creep Property of a Ni-20Cr Alloy

Junshan Zhang, Masao Takeyama, Takashi Matsuo, Makoto Kikuchi, Ryohei TanakaTetsu-to-Hagane 1987 · DOI

Abstract

Changes in the creep resistance and dislocation substructure with addition of carbon have been studied in the temperature range between 900-1050°C, by using high purity Ni-20Cr alloys containing carbon up to 0.032wt%. The creep resistance of the alloy increased at the temperatures less than 1000°C, with increasing of carbon content dissolved in γ-matrix. Such a strengthening effect was presumed to be caused by solid solution of carbon, and was associated with increase in dislocation density within subgrains. At 1050°C, the formation of subgrains or the dynamic recrystallization took place in the alloy with 0.032wt% carbon and these microstructural changes brought the decrease in the creep resistance of the alloy. The precipitation of carbide ($M_7C_3$) at the grain boundaries significantly increased the creep resistance, and this phenomenon was very similar to the grain boundary precipitation strengthening effect by α2-W phase in Ni-Cr-W alloys.

Introduction

In high-temperature applications like jet engines and power plants, nickel-based superalloys must withstand "creep"—the slow, permanent deformation under constant stress and heat. While carbon is a common additive, its specific role at extreme temperatures (900–1050°C) has historically been a subject of debate. Some research suggested that dissolved carbon might accelerate atomic diffusion and weaken the alloy. This study clarifies the dual role of carbon as both a solid-solution strengthener and a source of grain-boundary precipitates in Ni-20Cr alloys.

Experimental Methods

Four high-purity Ni-20Cr alloys were prepared with carbon levels ranging from <0.001 wt% (C0) to 0.032 wt% (C3). Grain sizes were standardized to approximately 200 μm through specific heat treatments. Creep tests were performed between 900°C and 1050°C under various stress levels (1.5 to 4.5 kgf/mm²). Microstructural analysis utilized optical microscopy, Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) for dislocation studies, and X-ray diffraction for carbide identification.

Results and Discussion

The Temperature-Dependent Role of Carbon

The study found that carbon's influence on creep resistance is highly sensitive to temperature. At 900°C, 950°C, and 1000°C, increasing carbon content consistently reduced the minimum creep rate and extended the time to rupture. This improvement is attributed to solid solution strengthening, where dissolved carbon increases dislocation density within subgrains, creating a "traffic jam" of defects that hinders deformation.

Figure 1: Minimum creep rate versus carbon content across different temperatures and stress levels.

However, a performance "flip" occurs at 1050°C. At this extreme temperature, the highest carbon alloy (C3) exhibited a higher creep rate and shorter rupture life compared to the medium carbon alloy (C2). This degradation is linked to dynamic recrystallization—the formation of new, strain-free grains that facilitates material flow under stress.

Figure 2: Time to rupture versus carbon content, illustrating the performance peak at 1000°C and subsequent decline at 1050°C for high carbon alloys.

Strengthening Mechanisms

Two primary mechanisms were identified as the drivers of improved creep resistance:

  1. Solid Solution Strengthening: Even when fully dissolved in the nickel matrix (γ-phase), carbon increases the density of dislocations. This makes it harder for the crystal lattice to deform under load.
  2. Grain Boundary Armor: Carbon precipitates as $M_7C_3$ carbides at grain boundaries. These hard particles act as physical barriers to grain boundary sliding, a mechanism remarkably similar to the strengthening effect seen with heavier elements like Tungsten.

Conclusion

Carbon is a potent strengthener for Ni-20Cr alloys up to 1000°C, primarily through solid solution effects and grain boundary carbide precipitation. However, at 1050°C, high carbon content can become detrimental by promoting dynamic recrystallization. Future work should explore higher carbon ranges and the long-term stability of these carbides in more complex commercial superalloy chemistries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Changes in the creep resistance and dislocation substructure with addition of carbon have been studied in the temperature range between 900-1050°C, by using high purity Ni-20Cr alloys containing carbon up to 0.032wt%.The creep resistance of the alloy increased at the temperatures less than 1 000°C, with increasing of carbon content dissolved in γ-matrix. Such a strengthening effect was presumed to be caused by solid solution of carbon, and was associated with increase in dislocation density within subgrains. At 1050°C, the formation of subgrains or the dynamic recrystallization took place in the alloy with 0.032wt% carbon and these microstructural changes brought the decrease in the creep resistance of the alloy. The precipitation of carbide (M7C3) at the grain boundaries significantly increased the creep resistance, and this phenomenon was very similar to the grain boundary precipitation strengthening effect by α2-W phase in Ni-Cr-W alloys.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang1987effect,
  author = {Junshan Zhang and Masao Takeyama and Takashi Matsuo and Makoto Kikuchi and Ryohei Tanaka},
  title = {{Effect of Carbon on High Temperature Creep Property of a Ni-20Cr Alloy}},
  booktitle = {Tetsu-to-Hagane},
  year = {1987},
  doi = {10.2355/tetsutohagane1955.73.1\_183},
}
Figure