Effect of B Element Doping on High-Temperature Tribological Properties of WS2-Based Composite Coatings

Songmin Zhang, Xiaopeng Zhang, Haichao Cai, Zixuan Huang, Yujun Xue, Lulu Pei, Bowei KangLubricants 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces boron (B) doping into WS2 coatings to enhance their high-temperature tribological performance, addressing the oxidative failure of pure WS2 in harsh environments. The resulting B/WS2 composite coatings demonstrate significantly improved wear resistance and reduced friction coefficients, even at temperatures up to 450°C, making them promising for demanding aerospace applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern aerospace applications, particularly in aeroengines and spacecraft, demand materials that can withstand extreme conditions. Rotating components in these systems often operate at elevated temperatures, and during launch, spacecraft can encounter high-temperature and humid atmospheric environments. Traditional solid lubricants like WS2, while excellent at room temperature, suffer from oxidative failure under these conditions. This degradation limits their service life and reliability, creating a need for robust lubricating coatings that maintain their performance at high temperatures. This paper tackles the challenge of improving the high-temperature tribological properties of WS2 coatings by exploring the effects of doping with boron.

Methods

The researchers fabricated B/WS2 composite coatings using a magnetron sputtering deposition system. They employed dual targets: a WS2 target sputtered with radio-frequency power and a B target sputtered with direct current power. High-purity WS2 and B targets were used, and the deposition process involved a Cr interlayer and controlled sputtering parameters.

To evaluate the coatings, a multi-pronged approach was used:

  • Surface Morphology: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to observe the surface topography and wear tracks.
  • Phase Composition and Elemental Distribution: Energy-Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) and X-ray Diffraction (XRD) were employed to identify the crystalline phases and elemental composition of the coatings.
  • Mechanical Properties: Nanoindentation was used to measure the hardness and elastic modulus. The H/E and H³/E² ratios were calculated to assess wear resistance and resistance to plastic deformation.
  • High-Temperature Tribological Testing: A specialized high-temperature friction and wear tester was used to evaluate the coatings under dry friction conditions at ambient temperature, 150°C, 300°C, and 450°C.
  • Wear Scar Analysis: Precision profilometry was used to characterize wear tracks, and SEM/EDS was used to analyze the wear scar morphology and elemental composition of both the coating and the steel ball counterpart.
  • Chemical Analysis: X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) was used to analyze the chemical valence states and bonding within the coatings.
  • Microstructural Analysis: Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) was used to examine wear debris and confirm the presence of specific crystalline structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental fabrication and testing of coatings, not on training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Boron as a Stabilizer: The introduction of boron into WS2 coatings significantly enhances their stability and performance at high temperatures. This is a crucial finding, as it directly addresses the primary limitation of pure WS2.
  • WB4 Formation is Key: The formation of tungsten tetraboride (WB4) during sputtering is identified as a critical factor. WB4 is a hard phase that contributes to grain boundary strengthening, improved densification, and enhanced mechanical properties, which in turn improve wear resistance.
  • Synergistic Lubrication: At elevated temperatures, the formation of tungsten trioxide (WO3) from oxidation plays a role. While WS2 is a good lubricant at room temperature, WO3 acts as a high-temperature solid lubricant, and its spherical particles contribute to reduced friction through a rolling effect. This suggests a dual-lubrication mechanism.
  • Improved Mechanical Properties: Boron doping dramatically increases the microhardness and elastic modulus of the WS2 coatings, making them more resistant to deformation and wear. The H³/E² ratio, a key indicator of plastic deformation resistance, shows a remarkable improvement.
  • Wear Mechanism Shift: Pure WS2 coatings exhibit adhesive wear. However, B/WS2 coatings show a shift towards abrasive wear and spalling at room temperature, and a combination of abrasive and partial adhesive wear at higher temperatures, indicating a more complex and resilient wear behavior.

Key Results

  • Friction Coefficient: The average friction coefficient of pure WS2 was 0.11. With B doping, it reduced to 0.071 at room temperature. At elevated temperatures, it further decreased, reaching an ultralow 0.015 at 150°C, and remained low (0.053) even at 450°C.
  • Wear Rate: The wear rate of pure WS2 was 3.63 × 10⁻⁶ mm³·N⁻¹·m⁻¹. B doping reduced this significantly to 7.63 × 10⁻⁷ mm³·N⁻¹·m⁻¹ at room temperature. The lowest wear rate of 1.89 × 10⁻⁷ mm³·N⁻¹·m⁻¹ was achieved at 150°C. Even at 450°C, the wear rate (8.96 × 10⁻⁷ mm³·N⁻¹·m⁻¹) was lower than that of pure WS2.
  • Microhardness: B doping increased microhardness from 0.83 GPa (pure WS2) to 3.604 GPa. After heating to 450°C, it further increased to 4.17 GPa.
  • Elastic Modulus: Similarly, the elastic modulus increased from 32.9 GPa (pure WS2) to 54.7 GPa, reaching 55.84 GPa after heating to 450°C.
  • H³/E² Ratio: This indicator of plastic deformation resistance saw a dramatic increase from 5.842 × 10⁻⁴ for pure WS2 to 0.015 for B/WS2 at room temperature, and further to 0.0241 at 450°C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Conditions: While the study focuses on high-temperature tribological performance in atmospheric environments, the paper notes that at 450°C, the coating's mechanical properties degrade, leading to larger wear scars and increased transfer film formation. This suggests that while improved, performance at extremely high temperatures might still be a challenge for very long-duration applications.
  • Specific Applications: The study demonstrates excellent performance in laboratory tests. Further research could focus on validating these findings in real-world aerospace applications and under more complex operational conditions (e.g., vacuum, different atmospheres, varying loads).
  • Optimization of B Content: While boron doping proved effective, the paper doesn't explicitly detail an optimization study for the exact boron content or sputtering parameters to achieve the absolute best performance across all temperatures. Future work could explore a wider range of doping concentrations and deposition parameters.
  • Long-Term Durability: The study provides insights into wear mechanisms and performance at different temperatures. Investigating the long-term durability and fatigue life of these B/WS2 coatings under cyclic loading at high temperatures would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

WS2 coating, as a solid lubricating material, plays a significant role in the lubrication of rotating components in spacecraft. During the launch process, however, spacecraft are exposed to high-temperature and humid atmospheric environments, which can lead to oxidative failure in the coating, thereby limiting its engineering applications. By doping with B elements, B/WS2 was successfully prepared as a composite coating. The results demonstrate that the fabricated coating exhibits excellent high-temperature tribological performance in atmospheric environments. The mechanism through which B doping improves the high-temperature friction and wear properties of the WS2 composite coating was revealed through high-temperature friction and wear tests. With the incorporation of B elements, the average friction coefficient of the coating was 0.071, and the wear rate was 7.63 × 10−7 mm3·N−1·m−1, with the wear mechanisms identified as abrasive wear and spalling. Due to high-temperature oxidation, thermal decomposition effects, and the formation of WB4 during sputtering, the wear resistance and anti-plastic deformation capability of the coating were further improved. Compared to room-temperature test conditions, the B/WS2 composite coating at different high temperatures exhibited superior friction coefficients and wear rates. Notably, at 150 °C, the average friction coefficient was as low as 0.015, and the wear forms were abrasive wear and adhesive wear.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025effect,
  author = {Songmin Zhang and Xiaopeng Zhang and Haichao Cai and Zixuan Huang and Yujun Xue and Lulu Pei and Bowei Kang},
  title = {{Effect of B Element Doping on High-Temperature Tribological Properties of WS2-Based Composite Coatings}},
  booktitle = {Lubricants},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/lubricants13080332},
}
Figure