Effect of ambient temperature on the jet characteristics of a swirl oxygen lance with mixed injection of CO 2 + O 2

Chao Feng, Kai Dong, Rong Zhu, Tao Lin, Jianfeng Dong, Tao Xia, Xin RenHigh 2022 · DOI

Abstract

$O_2$ mixed with $CO_2$ gas has been successfully applied in converter smelting; however, up to now, there have been few studies regarding the jet characteristics of the mixed injection of the swirl oxygen lance nozzle and the influence of different ambient temperature conditions on jet characteristics compared with common nozzles. In this study, Fluent software was used to simulate the jet characteristics of a four-hole common nozzle and a four-hole swirl nozzle under four different ambient temperature conditions to inject 95% $O_2$ + 5% $CO_2$ and analyze the influence of different ambient temperatures on nozzle-jet characteristics. The results show that with an increase in the ambient temperature, the jet-axis velocity and nozzle centerline speed increase. Under the same distance condition, the distance between the maximum radial velocity point of the jet and the centerline of the nozzle becomes larger, with a velocity greater than that of the swirl nozzle. However, the influence of the ambient temperature on the offset of the jet centerline is small. With an increase in the ambient temperature and distance, the jet-axis temperature increases and the temperature of the nozzle centerline decreases. The research results can provide a theoretical reference for the optimal design of a $CO_2 + O_2$ swirl oxygen lance nozzle.

Introduction

In the high-stakes environment of converter steelmaking, the oxygen lance is the primary tool for driving the chemical reactions that transform molten iron into steel. While traditional lances use pure oxygen, modern techniques explore mixtures of $O_2$ and $CO_2$ to improve metallurgical outcomes like dephosphorization. A critical challenge is understanding how the extreme and varying ambient temperatures inside a steel converter—ranging from room temperature to nearly 2000 K—affect the performance of specialized "swirl" nozzles compared to standard designs. This paper investigates these dynamics to provide engineers with the data needed to optimize lance designs for real-world smelting cycles.

Methodology

The researchers employed a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) approach using ANSYS Fluent to model the jet characteristics of both a four-hole common nozzle and a four-hole swirl nozzle with a 10° swirl angle. The standard $k-\epsilon$ turbulence model was used to simulate gas flow at four ambient temperatures: 300 K, 1573 K, 1773 K, and 1973 K.

Numerical mesh and computational domain for the common (a) and swirl (b) nozzles used in the CFD simulations.

The computational domain utilized structured meshes, with 627,000 grid points for the common nozzle and 695,000 for the swirl nozzle. To ensure the simulation's accuracy, the authors validated the model against a physical "cold-state" jet detection system, achieving an average error of only 3.25% between physical measurements and digital results.

Results and Discussion

Temperature-Velocity Correlation

A key insight from the study is that as ambient temperature rises, the jet's axial velocity actually increases. This counter-intuitive boost happens because higher temperatures reduce the density of the surrounding gas. With less dense gas to displace, the jet experiences reduced resistance (entrainment) and maintains its momentum over a longer distance.

Swirl vs. Common Nozzle Dynamics

While the common nozzle produces a longer "potential core" (the high-velocity center of the jet) for deeper penetration, the swirl nozzle excels in radial expansion.

Comparison of the internal geometry and nozzle configurations for common (a) and swirl (b) designs.

In swirl nozzles, individual jets tend to coalesce much earlier than in common nozzles, creating a unified, rotating flow field. This enhanced radial mixing is crucial for stirring the slag-metal interface, even though it trades off some axial speed. Furthermore, the study found that the velocity along the nozzle's centerline increases after approximately 0.12 meters from the tip due to the entrainment effect, where multiple jets create a low-pressure zone that pulls gas toward the center. Thermal analysis also showed that as the jet travels further into the hot converter, its internal temperature gradually rises as it mixes with the ambient atmosphere.

Conclusion

Ambient temperature is a critical factor in oxygen lance performance, significantly enhancing jet velocity at higher temperatures. While swirl nozzles have lower axial speeds than common nozzles, their superior radial mixing and stirring capabilities make them highly effective for the complex environment of a steel converter. Future research should incorporate multiphase flow and chemical reactions at the impact point to provide an even more comprehensive view of the smelting process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract O 2 mixed with CO 2 gas has been successfully applied in converter smelting; however, up to now, there have been few studies regarding the jet characteristics of the mixed injection of the swirl oxygen lance nozzle and the influence of different ambient temperature conditions on jet characteristics compared with common nozzles. In this study, Fluent software was used to simulate the jet characteristics of a four-hole common nozzle and a four-hole swirl nozzle under four different ambient temperature conditions to inject 95% O 2 + 5% CO 2 and analyze the influence of different ambient temperatures on nozzle-jet characteristics. The results show that with an increase in the ambient temperature, the jet-axis velocity and nozzle centerline speed increase. Under the same distance condition, the distance between the maximum radial velocity point of the jet and the centerline of the nozzle becomes larger, with a velocity greater than that of the swirl nozzle. However, the influence of the ambient temperature on the offset of the jet centerline is small. With an increase in the ambient temperature and distance, the jet-axis temperature increases and the temperature of the nozzle centerline decreases. The research results can provide a theoretical reference for the optimal design of a CO 2 + O 2 swirl oxygen lance nozzle.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2022effect,
  author = {Chao Feng and Kai Dong and Rong Zhu and Tao Lin and Jianfeng Dong and Tao Xia and Xin Ren},
  title = {{Effect of ambient temperature on the jet characteristics of a swirl oxygen lance with mixed injection of CO <sub>2</sub> + O <sub>2</sub>}},
  booktitle = {High},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1515/htmp-2022-0239},
}
Figure