EEG-Based Sleep Staging Analysis with Functional Connectivity

Guang Lin, Hui Huang, Jianhai Zhang, Li Zhu, Jiajia Tang, Guang Lin 0002, Wanzeng Kong, Xu Lei, Lei Zhu

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to sleep staging by analyzing brain functional connectivity using EEG data. By examining how different brain regions communicate across various frequency bands, the study achieves high classification accuracy, outperforming existing methods and offering insights into the underlying brain mechanisms of sleep.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate sleep staging is crucial for diagnosing sleep disorders and understanding overall health, as poor sleep quality is linked to numerous chronic diseases. Traditional sleep staging relies on manual visual inspection of EEG signals by experts, which is time-consuming, inefficient, and prone to subjective errors, with inter-expert agreement often around 83%. While automated methods exist, they often focus on local features from single EEG channels, neglecting the global brain network interactions that are vital for understanding complex brain states like sleep. This paper aims to bridge this gap by leveraging functional connectivity to capture these global brain dynamics for more robust and insightful sleep staging.

Methods

The study employs a multi-stage approach:

  1. Data Preprocessing: EEG data is cleaned using Common Average Reference (CAR) and Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to remove artifacts. The cleaned EEG is then band-pass filtered into six frequency bands: delta (0.5–4 Hz), theta (4–8 Hz), alpha (8–13 Hz), beta1 (13–22 Hz), beta2 (22–30 Hz), and gamma (30–40 Hz).
  2. Functional Connectivity Calculation: Phase-Locked Value (PLV) is used to quantify the phase synchronization between pairs of EEG channels within each frequency band. This creates a functional connectivity network for each sleep stage.
  3. Band Evaluation: A bi-serial correlation coefficient ($r^2$) is calculated to assess the discriminative power of PLV features from each frequency band for distinguishing between sleep stages (REM, N2, N3). This helps identify which frequency bands are most informative.
  4. Fusion Strategies: Three strategies are used to combine information from different frequency bands:
  5. Feature-level fusion: PLV features from all six bands are concatenated before classification.
  6. Decision-level fusion (stacking): Individual classifiers are trained for each band, and a meta-classifier learns to combine their predictions.
  7. Hybrid fusion: A combination of feature-level and decision-level approaches, involving selecting optimal band combinations based on evaluation results.
  8. Classification: A Support Vector Machine (SVM) with a Gaussian kernel is used for classification, employing an "one-against-one" strategy for multi-class problems.

Datasets

The study utilizes the public CAP Sleep Database. This database contains polysomnographic recordings from 16 healthy subjects, with the researchers selecting four subjects (n3, n5, n10, n11) who had 12 EEG channels recorded. The data was sampled at 512 Hz, and each recording lasted approximately 9 hours. The sleep stages analyzed were REM, N2, and N3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low-frequency bands (delta, alpha) show increased connectivity during deeper sleep (N3), while high-frequency bands (beta2, gamma) show decreased connectivity. This suggests a shift in brain communication patterns as sleep deepens, with more synchronized activity in slower oscillations and less in faster ones.
  • Alpha band exhibits superior discriminative ability for sleep staging. This is supported by its high percentage of informative features and good classification performance, highlighting its importance in differentiating sleep states.
  • Functional connectivity provides a global view of brain activity, complementing local EEG features. By analyzing interactions between brain regions, this method captures a more comprehensive picture of sleep dynamics than single-channel approaches.
  • Feature-level fusion of all six frequency bands yields the best classification performance. This indicates that integrating information across the entire spectrum of brain activity is more effective than relying on individual bands or limited combinations.

Key Results

  • Classification Accuracy: The feature-level fusion of all six frequency bands achieved the highest classification accuracy: 96.91% for intra-subject and 96.14% for inter-subjects. This significantly outperforms decision-level and hybrid fusion methods.
  • Band Performance: The alpha band consistently showed strong performance in both feature evaluation and single-band classification, outperforming most other bands.
  • Discriminative Power: The bi-serial correlation coefficient ($r^2$) analysis revealed that the alpha band had the highest discriminative ratio, particularly for distinguishing between N2 and N3 stages.
  • Comparison to State-of-the-Art: The proposed PLV-based functional connectivity method achieved better accuracy than several existing state-of-the-art sleep staging methods, as detailed in Table 4.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focused on three sleep stages (REM, N2, N3), excluding N1.
  • While the dataset is public, the selection of only four subjects with 12 channels might limit generalizability.
  • The paper notes an inconsistency where the beta1 band showed good discriminative ratios but lower classification accuracy, potentially due to issues in distinguishing N2 and N3.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors plan to develop an online brain-computer interface for automatic sleep staging monitoring.
  • They aim to integrate this approach with graph convolution networks for further advancements.
  • Exploring the inclusion of N1 stage and expanding to larger, more diverse datasets would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sleep staging is important in sleep research since it is the basis for sleep evaluation and disease diagnosis. Related works have acquired many desirable outcomes. However, most of current studies focus on time-domain or frequency-domain measures as classification features using single or very few channels, which only obtain the local features but ignore the global information exchanging between different brain regions. Meanwhile, brain functional connectivity is considered to be closely related to brain activity and can be used to study the interaction relationship between brain areas. To explore the electroencephalography (EEG)-based brain mechanisms of sleep stages through functional connectivity, especially from different frequency bands, we applied phase-locked value (PLV) to build the functional connectivity network and analyze the brain interaction during sleep stages for different frequency bands. Then, we performed the feature-level, decision-level and hybrid fusion methods to discuss the performance of different frequency bands for sleep stages. The results show that (1) PLV increases in the lower frequency band (delta and alpha bands) and vice versa during different stages of non-rapid eye movement (NREM); (2) alpha band shows a better discriminative ability for sleeping stages; (3) the classification accuracy of feature-level fusion (six frequency bands) reaches 96.91% and 96.14% for intra-subject and inter-subjects respectively, which outperforms decision-level and hybrid fusion methods.
BibTeX
@article{lin2021eeg,
  author = {Guang Lin and Hui Huang and Jianhai Zhang and Li Zhu and Jiajia Tang and Guang Lin and Wanzeng Kong and Xu Lei and Lei Zhu},
  title = {{EEG-Based Sleep Staging Analysis with Functional Connectivity}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21061988},
}
Figure