EEG Based Classification of Long-Term Stress Using Psychological Labeling

Sanay Muhammad Umar Saeed, Syed Muhammad Anwar, Humaira Khalid, Muhammad Majid, Ulas Bagci

TL;DR

This paper explores using EEG signals to classify long-term stress without inducing it, a crucial step towards personalized stress management. They found that alpha asymmetry, when labeled by a psychology expert, significantly improves classification accuracy, suggesting it could be a valuable bio-marker for stress.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stress, particularly chronic stress, has significant negative impacts on mental and physical health, often leading to conditions like depression and cardiovascular diseases. Early detection of long-term stress is vital for prevention and management. While conventional methods like questionnaires (e.g., Perceived Stress Scale - PSS) and hormone analysis exist, they can be subjective or influenced by various factors. Electroencephalography (EEG) offers a promising objective measure for stress detection due to its cost-effectiveness and ability to capture brain activity. However, most existing EEG-based stress studies focus on short-term, induced stress. This paper addresses the gap in classifying long-term, naturally occurring stress using resting-state EEG, aiming to develop a non-intrusive and objective method for identifying individuals experiencing chronic stress.

Methods

The researchers employed a supervised machine learning approach to classify participants into "stress" and "control" groups.

  • Data Acquisition: Resting-state EEG data was collected from 33 participants using a five-channel EMOTIV Insight headset for three minutes in a closed-eye condition. This condition was chosen to minimize eye-blink artifacts and align with previous studies on long-term stress.
  • Labeling: Two labeling methods were used:
  • PSS-10 Questionnaire: Participants completed the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS-10), a standard questionnaire for chronic stress. A threshold was calculated based on the mean and standard deviation of PSS scores to categorize participants.
  • Expert Evaluation (Hybrid Labeling): A psychology expert conducted interviews with participants, considering both their PSS scores and reported symptoms (physical, emotional, behavioral, and cognitive). This expert-assigned label was considered the "ground truth."
  • Feature Extraction: EEG signals were pre-processed to remove noise. Power spectral densities were extracted for various frequency bands (delta, theta, alpha, beta, gamma). Crucially, they computed frontal and temporal alpha and beta asymmetries, and alpha asymmetry from four channels. This resulted in 45 features.
  • Feature Selection: A two-sided Student's t-test was used to identify statistically significant features that differentiate between the stress and control groups.
  • Classification: Five machine learning classifiers were evaluated: Support Vector Machine (SVM), Naive Bayes (NB), K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN), Logistic Regression (LR), and Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP).
  • Validation: A 10-fold cross-validation technique was employed to ensure robust performance and avoid overfitting, especially given the limited dataset size.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of EEG recordings from 33 healthy participants. No new benchmark dataset was introduced; instead, the researchers collected and labeled their own data for the specific purpose of classifying long-term stress.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Expert Labeling is Key: The most significant finding is that using a psychology expert's evaluation for labeling stress and control groups dramatically improved classification accuracy compared to relying solely on the PSS questionnaire. This highlights the nuanced nature of stress and the value of clinical expertise in interpreting subjective and objective data.
  • Alpha Asymmetry as a Bio-Marker: Alpha asymmetry emerged as a particularly strong feature for stress classification, especially when labeled by an expert. The study suggests it could serve as a potential bio-marker for recognizing chronic stress.
  • Resting-State EEG Suffices: The research demonstrates that classifying long-term stress is possible using resting-state EEG without the need for artificial stress-inducing tasks. This is crucial for developing practical, real-world applications for stress monitoring.
  • Machine Learning Suitability: Conventional machine learning classifiers, particularly SVM and LR, proved effective for this task, outperforming more complex deep learning models which were deemed unsuitable due to data limitations.

Key Results

  • Highest Accuracy: The Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier achieved the highest classification accuracy of 85.20% when using alpha asymmetry as a feature and expert-based labeling.
  • Feature Importance: Alpha asymmetry was identified as a statistically significant feature for stress classification, particularly when expert labels were used.
  • Labeling Impact: Expert evaluation-based labeling improved classification accuracy significantly compared to PSS-based labeling.
  • Classifier Performance: SVM and Logistic Regression (LR) were the top-performing classifiers, showing similar high accuracy rates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Size: The study acknowledges the limitation of a small dataset (33 participants). This restricted the use of more complex deep learning models and suggests that larger datasets would be beneficial for future research.
  • Generalizability: While promising, the findings are based on a specific participant group. Further validation with a more diverse population is needed to ensure generalizability.
  • Feature Set: The study explored a set of 45 features. Future work could investigate a broader range of features, including those from other signal processing techniques or multimodal data.
  • Deep Learning Potential: With larger datasets, the authors suggest that deep learning strategies could be explored for potentially improved stress classification methods.
  • Hybrid Labeling Refinement: Further research could explore more sophisticated hybrid labeling approaches that optimally combine subjective and objective measures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stress research is a rapidly emerging area in the field of electroencephalography (EEG) signal processing. The use of EEG as an objective measure for cost effective and personalized stress management becomes important in situations like the nonavailability of mental health facilities. In this study, long-term stress was classified with machine learning algorithms using resting state EEG signal recordings. The labeling for the stress and control groups was performed using two currently accepted clinical practices: (i) the perceived stress scale score and (ii) expert evaluation. The frequency domain features were extracted from five-channel EEG recordings in addition to the frontal and temporal alpha and beta asymmetries. The alpha asymmetry was computed from four channels and used as a feature. Feature selection was also performed to identify statistically significant features for both stress and control groups (via t-test). We found that support vector machine was best suited to classify long-term human stress when used with alpha asymmetry as a feature. It was observed that the expert evaluation-based labeling method had improved the classification accuracy by up to 85.20%. Based on these results, it is concluded that alpha asymmetry may be used as a potential bio-marker for stress classification, when labels are assigned using expert evaluation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{saeed2020eeg,
  author = {Sanay Muhammad Umar Saeed and Syed Muhammad Anwar and Humaira Khalid and Muhammad Majid and Ulas Bagci},
  title = {{EEG Based Classification of Long-Term Stress Using Psychological Labeling}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=1K-JAOu0CjN},
}
Figure