Edge Truncation Effect Suppression of Ultrawideband Phased Arrays for Radar Application

Chuchu Fan, Qu Shi-Wei, Shiwen Yang, Jun HuIEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters 2025

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a multi-layered strategy to fix the "edge truncation effect" that plagues finite-size ultrawideband phased arrays. By combining extended physical loading—specifically a T-shaped metal strip with a resistor—and frequency-segmented phase optimization, they achieved a 5:1 operating bandwidth (1.2–6 GHz) with stable performance even at wide scan angles of ±60°.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tightly Coupled Dipole Arrays (TCDAs) are a favorite in the radar world because they offer massive bandwidth and low profiles. However, there is a catch: they are usually designed using "infinite array" simulations, where every antenna element is surrounded by identical neighbors.

In the real world, arrays are finite. The elements at the edges don't have neighbors on one side, leading to the Edge Truncation Effect (ETE). This imbalance causes a sharp deterioration in impedance matching, leading to high energy reflection (measured as a high Voltage Standing Wave Ratio, or VSWR). For high-power radar, these reflections aren't just a performance hit—they can actually destroy the sensitive Transmit/Receive (T/R) modules feeding the antenna. Previous solutions often wasted space with "dummy" elements or reduced power efficiency through amplitude tapering. This paper seeks a low-cost, high-efficiency alternative.

Methods

The authors propose a three-part solution to "smooth out" the electromagnetic transition at the array's edge:

  1. Extended Overlapping Patches: They extended the capacitive patches at the edges to create a "traveling wave" structure, guiding electromagnetic waves outward rather than reflecting them back into the array.
  2. Resistive T-Shaped Loading: They added a novel T-shaped metal strip connected to a 100 $\Omega$ resistor at the array edges. The T-shape is clever: the currents on the horizontal arms are equal in amplitude but opposite in phase, which cancels out unwanted cross-polarized radiation. The resistor absorbs the residual energy that would otherwise cause reflections.
  3. Excitation Phase Optimization: Beyond physical hardware, they tweaked the software. By optimizing the phase difference between the edge elements and their neighbors—specifically dividing the 1.2–6 GHz band into three distinct segments—they further suppressed VSWR spikes during wide-angle scanning.

The design was validated using a $2 \times 16$ linear array prototype featuring Marchand baluns for impedance transformation and Wide-Angle Impedance Matching (WAIM) layers.

Datasets

As this is an experimental hardware paper, it does not use standard software datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Full-wave electromagnetic simulations: Used to compare four different models (Model I: no treatment, to Model IV: the full proposed solution).
  • Physical Prototype Measurements: A fabricated $2 \times 16$ TCDLA prototype was measured in an anechoic chamber to verify VSWR, gain, and radiation patterns.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Traveling Wave" Philosophy: Rather than trying to force the edge elements to act like center elements, the authors treated the edge as a transition zone that guides and then absorbs energy.
  • Symmetry for Purity: The use of the T-shaped strip is a highlight. It provides the necessary path for current to improve low-frequency matching without introducing "polluted" cross-polarized signals, thanks to its inherent phase cancellation.
  • Frequency-Dependent Phase Tuning: The realization that a single phase-shift rule doesn't work across a 5:1 bandwidth led to a segmented approach. By treating 1.2–2.4 GHz, 2.4–4.0 GHz, and 4.0–6.0 GHz differently, they maintained a VSWR < 3.5 across the entire range.

Key Results

  • Bandwidth: Achieved a 5:1 bandwidth ratio (1.2 GHz to 6 GHz).
  • Scanning Performance: Maintained an active VSWR of less than 3.5 while scanning up to ±60° in the E-plane. For context, unoptimized edge elements (Model I) saw VSWR values spike above 5.0.
  • Efficiency: Despite adding resistors (which usually lower efficiency), the total radiation efficiency remained above 82% across the entire operating band.
  • Experimental Validation: The physical prototype closely matched simulation results, with cross-polarization levels remaining below -15 dB.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assembly Sensitivity: The authors noted small discrepancies between simulation and measurement, which they attributed to assembly errors. This suggests the design may require high precision during manufacturing.
  • VSWR Peak: While a VSWR of 3.5 is a significant improvement for an edge element in such a wideband/wide-scan scenario, some ultra-sensitive systems might require even lower peaks (e.g., < 2.0 or 3.0), which remains a challenge for finite arrays.
  • Dimensionality: This study focused on a $2 \times 16$ linear array. Extending these ETE suppression techniques to large-scale 2D planar arrays would be the logical next step for practical radar applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

This letter presents a novel, effective method to suppress the edge truncation effect of ultrawideband tightly coupled dipole linear arrays. To restrain the edge truncation effect within an ultrawideband operating band, a new type of T-shaped metal strip with a resistor is further loaded on the array edges apart from extending the length of the overlapping patches. Besides, the excitation phase of the elements at the array edges is optimized. Full-wave simulation results show that the active standing wave standing ratio of the 2 x 16 tightly coupled dipole linear arrays using the proposed method is significantly optimized to less than 3.5 within a 5:1 [(1.2 to 6) GHz] bandwidth, while scanning up to +/-60° in the E-plane. The effectiveness of the proposed method is experimentally verified by a 2 x 16 linear array prototype.
BibTeX
@article{fan2025edge,
  author = {Chuchu Fan and Qu Shi-Wei and Shiwen Yang and Jun Hu},
  title = {{Edge Truncation Effect Suppression of Ultrawideband Phased Arrays for Radar Application}},
  journal = {IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters},
  year = {2025},
}
Figure