ECONOMIC REPERCUSSIONS WITH THE TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENT IN LETHAL AUTONOMOUS WEAPONS SYSTEM (LAWS)

Ankita Shaw, Khushi Shaw, Shubham Agarwal, Srideep MitraINTERNATIONAL 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Technological advancement in military hardware has historically transformed the nature of warfare. The emergence of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS)—systems that can select and engage targets without further human intervention—represents the next significant shift. While much of the global discourse focuses on the ethical and legal implications of "killer robots," this paper examines the often-overlooked economic consequences. By applying macroeconomic models, we argue that the development and adoption of LAWS trigger a "deterrence chain reaction" that disproportionately harms developing nations, leading to structural unemployment, reduced national income, and a widening gap in global economic equality.

Introduction

Since the mid-20th century, military technology has evolved at an unprecedented pace. Today, the transition from human-operated systems to autonomous ones is viewed by many nations as an inevitable progression. However, for emerging economies, this pursuit of technological parity comes at a staggering cost. The drive to develop LAWS is frequently fueled by the "Deterrence Theory," where nations invest in advanced weaponry not necessarily for use, but to instill fear in potential adversaries. This paper shifts the focus from the battlefield to the balance sheet, analyzing how the transition to capital-intensive autonomous warfare destabilizes domestic economies and undermines the principles of the welfare state.

The Macroeconomic Framework: Stock vs. Flow

A critical insight into the economic impact of LAWS lies in the distinction between "stock" and "flow" variables. Human military personnel represent a flow variable; their wages, pensions, and daily expenditures circulate through the economy, stimulating aggregate demand. In contrast, the capital invested in building and maintaining autonomous robots acts as a stock variable. These are essentially sunk costs that provide a sense of security but generate zero productivity in terms of national output. For a developing nation, diverting funds from human-centric military structures to autonomous systems effectively removes liquidity from the domestic market, leading to a contraction in national income.

Labor Market Disruptions and Structural Unemployment

The transition to LAWS is not merely a military upgrade; it is a fundamental industrial shift. In a traditional military, the armed forces serve as a significant employer. As warfare becomes increasingly capital-intensive, the demand for human labor in the defense sector shifts sharply to the left.

This shift creates "structural unemployment," where a large segment of the workforce—soldiers and administrative officials—becomes redundant. Unlike transitions in other industries, the specialized skills of military personnel are not always easily transferable to the civilian tech sectors required to maintain autonomous systems. The resulting labor market equilibrium settles at a lower wage rate and higher unemployment, further straining the social safety nets of developing nations.

The Prestige Paradox and Opportunity Costs

Emerging nations often prioritize international "recognition" and military prestige over the immediate welfare of their populations. This "Prestige Paradox" is evident in countries like India and Pakistan, where significant portions of the GDP are allocated to advanced military technology despite persistent domestic crises in healthcare, education, and poverty.

The paper highlights a stark disparity in opportunity costs. For example, while a developed nation like the United States may balance a 3.1% military spend with an 8% health spend, an emerging economy allocating over 2% of its GDP to military technology while half its population faces poverty faces a much more severe trade-off. Every dollar spent on the maintenance and storage of LAWS is a dollar not spent on rudimentary infrastructure or human capital development.

The Deterrence Chain Reaction

Much like the nuclear arms race of the 20th century, the development of LAWS by superpowers creates a coercive environment for smaller or less-developed nations. To avoid perceived vulnerability, these nations feel compelled to join the autonomous arms race. This creates a global chain reaction where scarce resources are diverted toward non-productive military assets. This cycle exacerbates global inequality, as higher-income countries can absorb these costs more effectively than lower-income countries, which may find the resulting economic instability arduous to escape.

Conclusion

The pursuit of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems represents a significant threat to global economic stability, particularly for developing nations. By shifting military spending from human labor to autonomous capital, governments risk triggering GDP contraction and long-term structural unemployment. To maintain the integrity of the welfare state, international policy must move beyond ethical debates and begin addressing the transparent management of military expenditures and the profound opportunity costs of autonomous warfare.

Summary updated

Abstract

Advancement in the field of technology has become ineluctably foreordained in every sphere. Over the years the conduct of war has transmuted dramatically only by the means of advancement and development in military technology. The year 1945 witnessed a dramatic invention that changed the entire perception of war. Since then there was no looking back. It won't take many years for the control of weapons to be taken away from the hands of humans. Lethal autonomous weapons system (LAWs) is one such ongoing significant development in the field of military technology. Approved by more than a dozen nations with no prevalence of laws in the international sphere, the countries haven't failed to continue with the development of LAWs. This advancement in military technology creates a divide between the higher income countries and the lower income countries leading to nothing but greater economic inequality. Arguendo, the nation with lack of resources will approve of developing the weapon, it will be merely because of the deterrence theory. Applying the principle of such advancement in the field of military technology will not only have an impact on the transformation of the warfare but also on the economic aspect of the nations developing the same. Economically, public expenditures in developing weapons are rarely transparent; hence, it abbreviates the overall transparency of any government. The question is if building weapons is incompatible with the principle of being a welfare state, why do governments such as those of India and Pakistan seem exuberant in developing weapons when the impact of the costs of developing the sameits maintenance, expansion and storage is unknown-also impairs the domestic ability to redress the rudimentary issues like poverty, unemployment, inequality and health? The intention of the paper is to analyze and examine that the road to such military technological advancement like the development of Lethal Autonomous Weapons System (a weapons system that once after activation, will not require further human Economic Repercussions with the Technological Advancement in Lethal Autonomous Weapons System (LAWS) https://iaeme.com/Home/journal/IJCIET 116 editor
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shaw2020economic,
  author = {Ankita Shaw and Khushi Shaw and Shubham Agarwal and Srideep Mitra},
  title = {{ECONOMIC REPERCUSSIONS WITH THE TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENT IN LETHAL AUTONOMOUS WEAPONS SYSTEM (LAWS)}},
  booktitle = {INTERNATIONAL},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.34218/ijciet.11.4.2020.010},
}
Figure