Abstract
This tidal stream energy industry has to date been comprised of small demonstrator projects made up of one to a four turbines. However, there are currently plans to expand to commercially sized projects with tens of turbines or more. As the industry moves to large-scale arrays for the first time, there has been a push to develop tools to optimise the array design and help bring down the costs. This review investigates different methods of modelling the economic performance of tidal-stream arrays, for use within these optimisation tools. The different cost reduction pathways are discussed from costs falling as the global installed capacity increases, due to greater experience, improved power curves through larger-diameter higher-rated turbines, to economic efficiencies that can be found by moving to large-scale arrays. A literature review is conducted to establish the most appropriate input values for use in economic models. This includes finding a best case, worst case and typical values for costs and other related parameters. The information collated in this review can provide a useful steering for the many optimisation tools that have been developed, especially when cost information is commercially sensitive and a realistic parameter range is difficult to obtain.
Introduction
The tidal stream energy sector is currently at a critical juncture, transitioning from a "nascent" stage characterized by small-scale demonstrators to a mature phase of commercial-scale arrays. While renewable technologies like wind and solar have benefited from decades of scaling and subsidies, tidal stream projects have largely been confined to clusters of one to four turbines. To achieve commercial viability, the industry must scale to arrays containing dozens of units.
A significant hurdle in this transition is the lack of transparent, realistic economic data. Most financial metrics are commercially sensitive, leaving researchers and engineers to optimize array designs without accurate figures for capital expenditure (CAPEX), operational costs (OPEX), or discount rates. This paper addresses this gap by synthesizing available data into a standardized framework of "optimistic, typical, and pessimistic" parameter ranges.
Methodology and Data Synthesis
The authors developed a linear cost model to analyze how expenditures scale with array size. This model bifurcates costs into two primary categories:
- Fixed Costs ($CA_f, O_f$): Infrastructure costs independent of turbine count, such as subsea substations and export cables.
- Turbine-Dependent Costs ($CA_t, O_t$): Costs that scale per unit, including the turbines themselves, foundations, and routine maintenance.
Data for this synthesis was drawn from several key sources, including the Offshore Renewable Energy Catapult (OREC), IEA Technology benchmarks, and industry reports from Orbital Marine Power and MeyGen. By applying ratios from the more mature offshore wind industry, the authors established a robust baseline for tidal energy scaling trends.
Economic Drivers and Array Optimization
A central theme of the review is the distinction between different cost-reduction pathways. Economies of Scale are achieved by increasing the physical size and power rating of individual turbines. In contrast, Economies of Volume result from building a larger number of units, which enables bulk discounts and standardized installation procedures.
As illustrated in the figure above, the relationship between expenditure and the number of turbines is not strictly linear when economies of volume are considered. Similarly, the "Break-even Power" required per turbine decreases as the array grows, reflecting the increased efficiency of larger projects. The authors argue that optimization tools should prioritize financial metrics like Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) or Net Present Value (NPV) over raw power output. Optimizing solely for power often leads to an excessive number of turbines where "blockage effects" reduce flow efficiency, resulting in diminishing financial returns.
Key Findings and Cost Parameters
The review provides a comprehensive set of cost model inputs to guide future modeling:
- CAPEX: Typical fixed CAPEX is estimated at £9.2m, while turbine-dependent CAPEX is approximately £3.3m per unit.
- OPEX: Annual operational costs are modeled as £0.32m (fixed) plus £0.15m per turbine.
- Financial Sensitivity: The model highlights the extreme sensitivity of LCOE to the discount rate. A reduction from 12% to 6% can lower the predicted LCOE by nearly 27%, emphasizing the importance of "de-risking" the industry for investors.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While this review provides a vital baseline, it identifies areas for further refinement. Current models often simplify environmental impacts and site-specific geographic costs (e.g., varying water depths and distances to shore). Future optimization tools must integrate these high-fidelity factors to balance profitability with ecological constraints. By providing these validated parameter ranges, the paper offers a roadmap for making tidal energy a competitive component of the global renewable energy mix.
Summary updated