Ecological risk assessment for tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate to freshwater organisms

Yu Qiao, Daqing Liu, Chenglian Feng, Na Liu, Jindong Wang, Zhenfei Yan, Yingchen BaiFrontiers in Environmental Science 2022 · DOI

Introduction

As environmental regulations phased out brominated flame retardants (BFRs) due to their persistence and bioaccumulative nature, the industry shifted toward organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs). Among these, tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) has become one of the most prevalent. Used extensively in plastics, electronics, and textiles, TCEP is highly water-soluble and resistant to biodegradation. Consequently, it has been detected in freshwater systems globally, from urban rivers to remote lakes. While TCEP is often viewed as a safer alternative to BFRs, recent research suggests its chronic ecological impact may be more severe than previously understood.

Mapping the Research Landscape

To understand the evolution of TCEP research, a bibliometric analysis was conducted using CiteSpace, analyzing over a century of literature. The analysis revealed a significant shift in focus over the last decade. While early studies focused primarily on environmental occurrence and detection methods, recent hotspots include "toxicity," "gene transcriptional analysis," and "neurotoxicity."

Bibliometric analysis of TCEP research hotspots and keyword frequency.

The data indicates that while we have become proficient at finding TCEP in the environment, the scientific community is now pivoting toward understanding the complex biological mechanisms through which this chemical affects aquatic life.

Methodology

The study employed a meta-analytical approach to synthesize existing toxicological and environmental data. Two primary models were used to quantify ecological risk:

  1. Risk Quotients (RQ): A deterministic approach comparing environmental concentrations to the Predicted No Effect Concentration (PNEC).
  2. Joint Probability Curves (JPCs): A probabilistic method that integrates exposure distributions with species sensitivity distributions to estimate the likelihood of adverse effects across a range of species.

Data was aggregated from major databases, including the USEPA Ecotoxicology Database and the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), focusing on freshwater exposure levels reported between 2011 and 2022.

Ecological Risk Results: Chronic vs. Acute

The most critical finding of this assessment is the disparity between acute and chronic risks. When looking at "survival risk"—the likelihood of TCEP concentrations causing immediate mortality—the risk is classified as "de minimis" or negligible. In most natural environments, TCEP levels do not reach the threshold required to kill fish or invertebrates outright.

However, the picture changes drastically when considering sub-lethal, chronic endpoints.

Joint probability curves illustrating the ecological risk of TCEP across different toxicological endpoints.

As shown in the Joint Probability Curves, reproductive toxicity represents the highest ecological risk at 19.26%, followed by developmental toxicity (11.96%) and neurotoxicity (9.20%). These curves demonstrate that a significant percentage of species in a freshwater ecosystem are likely to experience impaired reproduction or development at current environmental concentrations.

Key Insights and Vulnerabilities

  • Reproductive Failure: TCEP has been shown to up-regulate pathways related to genetic information processing. In species like Daphnia magna, this manifests as reduced spawning and delayed development, which can lead to population collapse over several generations.
  • Urban Hotspots: Risk is highly localized. Surface waters near industrial hubs or densely populated cities (such as Nanjing or Shanghai) exhibit Risk Quotients (RQ) for reproductive toxicity greater than 10, indicating a severe ecological threat.
  • Species Sensitivity: The study identified Carassius auratus (crucian carp) as particularly sensitive to acute exposure, while Daphnia magna serves as a primary indicator for reproductive disruption.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The transition from BFRs to OPFRs like TCEP has introduced a persistent, mobile contaminant into the global water cycle. This assessment highlights that focusing solely on mortality (acute toxicity) underestimates the true ecological threat. The high risk to reproduction and development suggests that TCEP could be quietly degrading freshwater biodiversity.

Future research must expand beyond common model organisms to include a wider variety of native species to refine risk models. Furthermore, environmental managers should consider stricter monitoring and regulation of TCEP, particularly in urban waterways where concentrations frequently exceed safe thresholds for chronic exposure.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the ban on brominated flame retardants (BFRs), organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs) were used as substitutes generally as flame retardants, lubricants, plasticizers, and so on. Tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) is a common OPFR and has been widely detected in different environmental compartments such as the atmosphere, dust, water, sediment, and soil. At elevated levels, TCEP can cause adverse health effects on humans and aquatic life. The present study aimed to use bibliometrics analysis of the important research about TCEP and assess the risk of TCEP to aquatic life through a comprehensive meta-data analysis of available secondary data on its toxic effects and exposure levels. The results showed that toxicity and environmental occurrence and concentration are research hot spots. Meanwhile, given the relatively high detection rates and high concentrations of TCEP in some freshwaters, the ecological risk of TCEP to freshwater organisms should not be ignored. This result of the present study could provide data support and references for the risk assessment and environmental management for such new emerging contaminants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiao2022ecological,
  author = {Yu Qiao and Daqing Liu and Chenglian Feng and Na Liu and Jindong Wang and Zhenfei Yan and Yingchen Bai},
  title = {{Ecological risk assessment for tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate to freshwater organisms}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Environmental Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenvs.2022.963918},
}
Figure