Abstract
In this study, concentrations of Cd, Cr, Mn, Pb, and Zn were determined by flame atomic absorption spectrophotometer (FAAS) in edible muscle tissues of a total of 25 fish samples belonging to five fish species viz., Hypophthalmichthys nobilis (Bighead), Wallago attu (Buhari), Catla catla (Catla), Clarias batrachus (Mugree), and Labeo rohita (Rohu) marketed in Kathmandu, Nepal and evaluated potential health risks for adults using USEPA deterministic approaches. The average metal accumulation in all fish species followed the order of Zn (27.89) > Mn (5.36) > Pb (2.37) > Cr (1.12) > Cd (0.44) mg/kg, exceeding the FAO/WHO guidelines except for Zn. Likewise, the sum of average metal concentrations (∑5HM) followed the descending order of C. catla (49.61) > C. batrachus (44.49) > W. attu (34.51) > H. nobilis (32.10) > L. rohita (25.18) mg/kg. The correlation matrix showed significant correlations among some HMs indicating their common sources of origin in the examined fish species. The estimated daily intakes (EDIs) of HMs were lower than the maximum tolerable daily intake (MTDI). The target hazard quotients (THQs) of a single element in all fish species were less than 1.0 while the total target hazard quotients (TTHQs) in C. batrachus, C. catla, and H. nobilis exceeded the safe limit of 1.0 suggesting a potential non-carcinogenic risk. Moreover, the target cancer risks (TRs) of Cd and Cr were higher than the acceptable risk limit (10⁻⁴) in all fish species suggesting that their consumption might pose a lifetime cancer risk for adults. Therefore, the study recommends regular monitoring of HMs in commercial fish to ensure the safety of consumer health.
Introduction
As urbanization and industrial activities expand in Nepal, aquatic ecosystems are increasingly exposed to heavy metals from agricultural runoff, industrial waste, and municipal sewage. Fish are effective bio-accumulators; they absorb these persistent, non-biodegradable pollutants through their gills and diet, eventually passing them to humans. While fish consumption is encouraged for heart and brain health, there is a critical lack of data regarding the chemical safety of fish sold in major Nepalese markets. This paper fills that gap by quantifying metal concentrations and calculating the specific health risks—both carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic—for the population of Kathmandu.
Methods
The researchers collected 25 samples across five species: Bighead (H. nobilis), Buhari (W. attu), Catla (C. catla), Mugree (C. batrachus), and Rohu (L. rohita). Edible muscle tissues were oven-dried, pulverized, and subjected to acid digestion using a mixture of nitric acid ($HNO_3$) and hydrogen peroxide ($H_2O_2$). Metal concentrations (Cd, Cr, Mn, Pb, and Zn) were determined using a Flame Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer (FAAS). The team used USEPA deterministic approaches to calculate the Estimated Daily Intake (EDI), Target Hazard Quotient (THQ) for non-carcinogenic risk, and Target Cancer Risk (TR).
Results and Discussion
The average metal accumulation followed the order: Zn (27.89) > Mn (5.36) > Pb (2.37) > Cr (1.12) > Cd (0.44) mg/kg. Concentrations of Cd, Cr, Mn, and Pb all exceeded FAO/WHO recommended limits, while Zinc remained within safe thresholds as it is an essential micronutrient regulated by fish metabolism.
A crucial finding was the "cocktail effect": while the THQ for individual metals was often below 1.0, the Total Target Hazard Quotient (TTHQ)—the sum of risks from all metals—exceeded 1.0 for three species (C. batrachus, C. catla, and H. nobilis). TTHQ values reached as high as 2.12 for C. batrachus, indicating significant potential for non-carcinogenic health issues.
Benthic (bottom-dwelling) species like C. batrachus showed higher metal concentrations, likely due to proximity to contaminated sediments. Significant positive correlations between Cd, Cr, Pb, and Zn suggest common anthropogenic sources, such as industrial effluents or phosphate fertilizers. Furthermore, the Target Cancer Risk (TR) for Cadmium and Chromium exceeded the acceptable limit ($10^{-4}$) in all fish species, suggesting long-term consumption poses a lifetime cancer risk.
Conclusion
This study focused exclusively on muscle tissue, the primary part consumed by humans. However, other organs like the liver and kidneys often accumulate higher concentrations and could provide a more complete environmental picture. Future research should involve larger-scale, longitudinal monitoring to account for seasonal variations. The findings underscore the urgent need for the Nepalese government to implement regular monitoring of commercial fish to protect public health.
Summary updated