Early life experience sets hard limits on motor learning as evidenced from artificial arm use

Roni O. Maimon-Mor, Hunter R. Schone, David Slater, A. Aldo Faisal, Tamar R. Makin

Abstract

Learning to use an artificial arm depends on fundamental building blocks of body representation and is significantly impacted by early-life experience. This study tested artificial arm motor control in two adult populations with upper-limb deficiency: congenital one-handers (born with a partial arm) and amputees (who lost their biological arm in adulthood). Despite starting prosthetic use as toddlers, one-handers produced increased error noise and directional errors when reaching to visual targets compared to amputees, who performed similarly to controls. However, earlier prosthetic fitting in one-handers correlated with better motor control. These findings suggest that visuomotor integration is highly dependent on either biological or artificial arm experience at a very young age, after which opportunities for sensorimotor plasticity become more limited.

Introduction

The human brain is remarkably plastic, but does this plasticity have an expiration date for fundamental body representations? Researchers have long debated whether the "building blocks" of motor control are hard-wired by genetics or sculpted by early experience. By studying people with upper-limb deficiencies, this study investigates whether the brain can "close the gap" in motor skill through decades of practice, or if the lack of a biological limb during a critical developmental window creates a permanent ceiling on motor performance. Specifically, the research focuses on visuomotor integration—the ability to translate visual information into precise physical movement—using artificial arms as a proxy for novel body parts.

Methods

The study compared three groups: congenital one-handers (n=18, average age ~46, first prosthetic use at ~2.5 years), acquired amputees (n=14, average age ~49, average age at amputation ~32), and two-handed controls (n=19).

To measure motor control, participants used a robotic manipulandum. They held a robotic handle (using their artificial arm or non-dominant hand) and performed reaching tasks toward visual targets on a screen.

Experimental setup using a robotic manipulandum to measure reaching accuracy.

Key metrics included "absolute error" (distance from target), "motor noise" (variability), and "initial directional error." Researchers controlled for individual differences in general motor skill by testing the participants' intact/dominant hands as a baseline.

Results

The analysis revealed a significant performance gap. One-handers produced significantly larger reaching errors compared to both amputees ($p = 0.001$) and controls ($p < 0.001$). Interestingly, amputees performed as well as able-bodied controls, suggesting the brain "recycles" the internal model of the lost biological arm to control the artificial substitute.

Motor performance results showing (C) increased absolute error in one-handers compared to amputees and controls, and (D) the correlation between early prosthetic fitting and improved performance in one-handers.

Timing proved to be a critical factor. For one-handers, the earlier they were fitted with their first prosthetic, the lower their absolute error ($r_s = 0.57, p = 0.01$) and motor noise ($r_s = 0.73$). For amputees, a shorter duration of limb loss before receiving a prosthetic also correlated with better performance ($r_s = 0.71$). Notably, the type of prosthetic hardware (cosmetic, mechanical, or myoelectric) did not significantly impact reaching accuracy.

Discussion

These findings suggest that biological limb experience during infancy is necessary to calibrate the neural systems that reduce motor noise. One-handers, despite lifelong prosthetic use, showed a lack of precision rather than a constant directional bias, implying a struggle to integrate visual and sensory signals into a stable movement plan.

The "recycling" advantage seen in amputees indicates that once neural infrastructure for limb control is established in childhood, it remains available for artificial substitutes. Conversely, for one-handers, the artificial arm may act more as a "tool" competing with the established habit of using their residual limb. This research highlights a critical developmental window for sensorimotor plasticity and raises important questions for the future of augmentative technologies: can we ever truly "embody" new limbs as adults if our brains require early-life templates for high precision?

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The study or artificial arms provides a unique opportunity to address long-standing questions on sensorimotor plasticity and development. Learning to use an artificial arm arguably depends on fundamental building blocks of body representation and would therefore be impacted by early-life experience. We tested artificial arm motor-control in two adult populations with upper-limb deficiency: congenital one-handers – who were born with a partial arm, and amputees – who lost their biological arm in adulthood. Brain plasticity research teaches us that the earlier we train to acquire new skills (or use a new technology) the better we benefit from this practice as adults. Instead, we found that although one-hander started using an artificial arm as toddlers, they produced increased error noise and directional errors when reaching to visual targets, relative to amputees who performed similarly to controls. However, the earlier a one-hander was fitted with an artificial arm the better their motor control was. We suggest that visuomotor integration, underlying the observed deficits, is highly dependent on either biological or artificial arm experience at a very young age. Subsequently, opportunities for sensorimotor plasticity become more limited.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maimonmor2021early,
  author = {Roni O. Maimon-Mor and Hunter R. Schone and David Slater and A. Aldo Faisal and Tamar R. Makin},
  title = {{Early life experience sets hard limits on motor learning as evidenced from artificial arm use}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.66320},
}
Figure