Dynamic tipping and cyclic folds, in a one-dimensional non-smooth dynamical system linked to climate models

Chris Budd, Rachel Kuske

Abstract

We study the behaviour at tipping points close to (smoothed) non-smooth fold bifurcations in one-dimensional oscillatory forced systems. The focus is the Stommel-Box, and related climate models, which are piecewise-smooth continuous dynamical systems, modelling thermohaline circulation. These exhibit non-smooth fold bifurcations which arise when a saddle-point and a focus meet at a border collision bifurcation. By using techniques from the theory of non-smooth dynamical systems we are able to provide precise estimates for the general tipping behaviour at the non-smooth fold as parameters vary. These are significantly different from the usual tipping point estimates, showing a much more rapid rate of tipping. We also see very rapid, and non-monotone, changes in the tipping points due to the effect of non-smoothness in the system. All of this has important implications for the prediction of tipping in climate systems.

Introduction

Most studies on climate tipping points assume that the underlying dynamical systems are "smooth" (mathematically differentiable). In these smooth systems, tipping usually occurs at a "saddle-node bifurcation," where a stable state and an unstable state meet and annihilate. We have a solid understanding of how these systems behave under slow environmental drift or seasonal cycles. However, many conceptual climate models, such as those for thermohaline circulation or glacial cycles, are non-smooth. They involve thresholds or "V-shaped" rather than "U-shaped" bifurcation diagrams. This research addresses the lack of a complete analytical understanding of tipping in these non-smooth systems, specifically investigating how seasonal (oscillatory) forcing interacts with a slow climatic drift to trigger tipping.

Methodology

The study focuses on a one-dimensional reduction of the Stommel-Box model, represented by the piecewise-linear differential equation: $$\frac{dx}{dt} = 2|x| - \mu(t) + f(t)$$ where $x$ is the state variable, $\mu(t)$ is a slowly drifting climatic control variable, and $f(t)$ is a periodic seasonal forcing. The authors utilize non-smooth dynamical systems theory, specifically border collision and grazing event analysis, to identify where periodic solutions disappear. Asymptotic analysis is used to construct exact solutions for linear regions and match them at the boundary ($x = 0$), deriving precise tipping estimates. Multi-scale averaging is applied for high-frequency forcing, and numerical validation is performed using MATLAB's fsolve and path-following methods to verify the analytical "cyclic fold."

Results and Discussion

The "Non-Smooth" Speedup and Smoothing Effects

A primary finding is that tipping in non-smooth systems occurs significantly faster than in smooth ones. In smooth systems, the "lag" in tipping relative to the static bifurcation point scales as $O(\epsilon^{2/3})$. In this non-smooth model, it scales as $O(\epsilon \log \epsilon)$, indicating a more urgent response to threshold crossings. Furthermore, the authors found that smoothing the system (parameterized by $\alpha$) actually postpones tipping. This suggests that smooth approximations of naturally non-smooth climate processes may lead to over-optimistic, delayed predictions of tipping events.

Non-Monotonic Tipping and Phase Sensitivity

The relationship between the tipping point ($\mu_{TP}$) and the forcing frequency ($\omega$) is notably "jagged" and non-monotonic. Small changes in seasonal cycle frequency can lead to large, sudden jumps in tipping timing. At lower frequencies, the exact phase of the seasonal cycle when the threshold is approached becomes critical, creating "creases" in the parameter space.

Numerical results showing a sharp transition in the tipping point $\mu_{TP}$ near $\omega \approx 0.32$.

Numerical simulations demonstrate these sharp transitions. For instance, at a drift rate of $\epsilon = 0.1$, the tipping point exhibits a complex structure for $\omega < 2$, which regularizes as frequency increases. Even with slight smoothing, the sharp transition near $\omega \approx 0.32$ remains a robust feature of the system.

The non-monotonic, 'jagged' relationship between tipping point $\mu_{TP}$ and forcing frequency $\omega$.

Conclusion

This study highlights the critical role of non-smoothness in climate modeling. The discovery of rapid, non-monotonic tipping behavior suggests that traditional smooth models may underestimate the risks and unpredictability of climate thresholds. While limited to a one-dimensional model, the core physics captured here provides a foundation for future work in higher-dimensional systems where resonance effects and stochastic noise (weather-like fluctuations) will be explored to further refine tipping point predictions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the behaviour at tipping points close to (smoothed) non-smooth fold bifurcations in one-dimensional oscillatory forced systems with slow parameter drift. The focus is the non-smooth fold in the Stommel 2-box, and related climate models, which are piecewise-smooth continuous dynamical systems, modelling thermohaline circulation. These exhibit non-smooth fold bifurcations which arise when a saddle-point and a focus meet at a border collision bifurcation. By using techniques from the theory of non-smooth dynamical systems we are able to provide precise estimates for the general tipping behaviour close to the non-smooth fold as parameters vary. These are different from the usual tipping point estimates at a saddle–node bifurcation, with advanced tipping apparent in the non-smooth case when compared to the behaviour near smoothed approximations to this fold. We also see rapid, and non-monotone, transitions in the tipping points for oscillatory forced systems close to both non-smooth folds and saddle–node bifurcations due to the effects of both phase changes and non-smoothness. These variations can have implications for the prediction of tipping in climate systems, particularly in close proximity to a non-smooth fold.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{budd2023dynamic,
  author = {Chris Budd and Rachel Kuske},
  title = {{Dynamic tipping and cyclic folds, in a one-dimensional non-smooth dynamical system linked to climate models}},
  booktitle = {Physica},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physd.2023.133949},
}
Figure