Dynamic Response Study of Piezoresistive Ti3C2-MXene Sensor for Structural Impacts

Shreyas Srivatsa, Paul Sieber, Céline Hofer, André Robert, Siddhesh Raorane, Marianna Marciszko-Wiackowska, Krzysztof Grabowski, M. M. Nayak, Eleni N. Chatzi, Tadeusz Uhl

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel piezoresistive sensor using Ti3C2-MXene nanomaterials for detecting structural impacts. This new sensor demonstrates an exceptionally fast response time, significantly outperforming traditional piezoelectric sensors, making it a promising candidate for real-time structural health monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Structural health monitoring (SHM) is crucial for ensuring the safety and longevity of engineering structures. A key aspect of SHM is detecting sudden events like impacts, which can range from bird strikes on aircraft to collisions in vehicles. Existing impact sensors need to capture these events with high temporal resolution to provide accurate data for analysis and potential intervention. However, many current sensors have response times that are too slow to fully capture the nuances of rapid impact events, potentially leading to a loss of critical information. This paper addresses the need for faster, more sensitive impact sensors by exploring the potential of Ti3C2-MXene, a promising 2D nanomaterial, for this application.

Methods

The study involved several key steps:

  • Ti3C2-MXene Synthesis: The researchers synthesized Ti3C2-MXene using a water-based and acid-based chemical etching process, followed by a mild intensive layer delamination (MILD) method to create a colloidal solution.
  • Sensor Fabrication: The Ti3C2-MXene colloidal solution was filtered to form a film, which was then cut into rectangular samples. Silver epoxy was used to attach wires, creating a two-terminal sensor. This sensor was integrated into a Wheatstone bridge circuit to convert resistance changes into voltage signals. A commercial piezoceramic sensor was used for comparison.
  • Experimental Setup: A custom-built, portable, and cost-effective table-top experimental setup was designed. This setup featured an inclined rail from which stainless steel balls of varying masses and radii were released to impact a vertically mounted cantilever aluminum plate. An electromagnet controlled the ball release, ensuring repeatable impacts.
  • Data Acquisition and Analysis: The output signals from both the Ti3C2-MXene and piezoceramic sensors were recorded using a Digilent Analog Discovery 2 data acquisition system. Matlab and Origin software were used for data processing, analysis of response times, peak voltages, and calibration curves.
  • Theoretical Modeling: A theoretical framework was developed to estimate the average impact force exerted by the balls on the cantilever plate, considering the dynamics of the ball on the ramp and the ball-plate collision as an elastic event.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention using pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on experimental data generated from the custom-built impact test setup. The "dataset" can be considered the collection of sensor responses recorded during the controlled impact experiments using various balls.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exceptional Speed: The most striking finding is the incredibly fast response time of the Ti3C2-MXene sensor, measured in microseconds. This is a significant leap forward compared to many existing impact sensing technologies.
  • MXene's Piezoresistive Potential: The study confirms that Ti3C2-MXene, when fabricated into a sensor, exhibits a piezoresistive effect that is sensitive to mechanical impacts.
  • Direct Comparison: By directly comparing the Ti3C2-MXene sensor with a commercial piezoelectric sensor under identical impact conditions, the researchers provide a clear, quantitative demonstration of the MXene sensor's advantages.
  • Scalability of Impact: The experiments show a clear correlation between the mass/force of the impacting ball and the sensor's output voltage, indicating the sensor's ability to detect and quantify impact severity.
  • Cost-Effectiveness and Portability: The development of a portable and cost-effective experimental setup highlights the potential for practical, on-site SHM applications.

Key Results

  • Response Time: The average response time for the Ti3C2-MXene sensor was found to be 1.28 ± 0.24 µs, while the commercial piezoceramic sensor had an average response time of 31.19 ± 24.61 µs. This means the MXene sensor is approximately an order of magnitude faster.
  • Sensitivity: The Ti3C2-MXene sensor demonstrated a sensitivity of 1.3 mV/N, which is lower than the commercial piezoceramic sensor (42.7 mV/N). However, this is attributed to the lack of signal amplification for the MXene sensor in this study.
  • Impact Force Correlation: The peak response voltage of the Ti3C2-MXene sensor increased with increasing impact force, as evidenced by the calibration plot.
  • Material Characterization: XRD analysis confirmed the successful synthesis of Ti3C2-MXene, showing characteristic peak shifts and broadening indicative of successful aluminum etching and delamination.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensitivity: The paper acknowledges that the sensitivity of the Ti3C2-MXene sensor is lower than that of commercial piezoceramic sensors. This is partly due to the unamplified output signal.
  • Signal Processing: Optimization of sensor characteristics and post-processing of sensor signals are needed for commercial applications.
  • Long-Term Performance: The long-term performance, aging, reliability, and robustness of these Ti3C2-MXene sensors for on-field SHM applications need to be thoroughly investigated.
  • Analytical Model: The current analytical/mathematical model for impact force estimation is preliminary and does not capture the complete mechanics of the system. Future work should involve numerical methods for more accurate impact force estimation and experimental validation of the model.
  • Commercialization: Further research is needed to optimize the material properties and sensor design for widespread adoption in SHM.

The authors suggest that this work provides a strong foundation for establishing Ti3C2-MXene as a viable material for next-generation impact sensors in structural health monitoring.

Summary updated

Abstract

MXenes are a new family of two-dimensional (2D) nanomaterials. They are inorganic compounds of metal carbides/nitrides/carbonitrides. Titanium carbide MXene (Ti 3 C 2 -MXene) was the first 2D nanomaterial reported in the MXene family in 2011. Owing to the good physical properties of Ti 3 C 2 -MXenes (e.g., conductivity, hydrophilicity, film-forming ability, elasticity) various applications in wearable sensors, energy harvesters, supercapacitors, electronic devices, etc., have been demonstrated. This paper presents the development of a piezoresistive Ti 3 C 2 -MXene sensor followed by experimental investigations of its dynamic response behavior when subjected to structural impacts. For the experimental investigations, an inclined ball impact test setup is constructed. Stainless steel balls of different masses and radii are used to apply repeatable impacts on a vertical cantilever plate. The Ti 3 C 2 -MXene sensor is attached to this cantilever plate along with a commercial piezoceramic sensor, and their responses for the structural impacts are compared. It is observed from the experiments that the average response times of the Ti 3 C 2 -MXene sensor and piezoceramic sensor are 1.28 ± 0.24 μ s and 31.19 ± 24.61 μ s, respectively. The fast response time of the Ti 3 C 2 -MXene sensor makes it a promising candidate for monitoring structural impacts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{srivatsa2023dynamic,
  author = {Shreyas Srivatsa and Paul Sieber and Céline Hofer and André Robert and Siddhesh Raorane and Marianna Marciszko-Wiackowska and Krzysztof Grabowski and M. M. Nayak and Eleni N. Chatzi and Tadeusz Uhl},
  title = {{Dynamic Response Study of Piezoresistive Ti3C2-MXene Sensor for Structural Impacts}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=D7wmpufzS9},
}

Loading related content...

Figure