Dynamic Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) and Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) in 5G Wireless Networks

Mina Baghani, Saeedeh Parsaeefard, Mahsa Derakhshani, Walid Saad

Abstract As 5G wireless networks evolve, the demand for flexible and efficient spectrum utilization has led to a debate between traditional Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) and the emerging Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA). This paper proposes a novel framework that leverages the software-defined architecture of 5G radio access units to dynamically select the optimal access technology—OMA or NOMA—for each subcarrier. By introducing a utility function that accounts for both data rate and the computational costs of successive interference cancellation (SIC), the authors formulate a joint resource allocation problem. Using a two-step iterative algorithm involving linear integer programming and difference-of-convex-functions (DC) programming, the study demonstrates that a hybrid, dynamic approach significantly outperforms single-technology solutions in both utility and network reliability.

Introduction

In the landscape of 5G wireless communication, the method by which multiple users share limited spectral resources is a critical design choice. Historically, Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA), such as OFDMA, has been the standard, providing users with dedicated subcarriers to avoid interference. However, Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) has gained traction for its ability to serve multiple users on the same subcarrier by stacking signals at different power levels. While NOMA offers higher theoretical capacity, it introduces significant computational complexity and the risk of error propagation during the decoding process.

This research addresses the fundamental trade-off between these two methods. Rather than treating NOMA as a universal replacement for OMA, the authors propose a dynamic system that evaluates the benefits of NOMA against its inherent costs in real-time, selecting the most efficient technology for each specific channel condition.

The Problem: The Hidden Costs of NOMA

Most existing literature treats NOMA as a "free lunch," focusing solely on its capacity gains. In practice, NOMA requires Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the receiver. This process is not only computationally expensive but also sensitive to the signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR). If the channel gains of paired users are too similar, the marginal capacity gain of NOMA does not justify the complexity and the increased Bit Error Rate (BER) risk.

The authors identify a gap in current 5G strategies: the lack of a mechanism that considers the "cost" of interference cancellation. They argue that NOMA is most effective when there is a high disparity between user channel gains (e.g., pairing a center-cell user with a cell-edge user). When conditions are less than ideal, OMA remains the more efficient choice.

Proposed Methodology

To solve this, the paper introduces a joint resource allocation problem that optimizes technology selection, subcarrier assignment, and power allocation simultaneously.

1. The Rate-Cost Utility Function

The core innovation is a novel utility function defined as: Utility = Rate - Cost

The "Cost" component is a mathematical representation of the SIC complexity and the additional power required to maintain a target BER under non-orthogonal conditions. This allows the system to naturally gravitate toward OMA when the gains of NOMA are negligible.

2. Two-Step Iterative Optimization

Because the resulting optimization problem is non-convex and mathematically complex, the authors employ a Successive Convex Approximation (SCA) approach, splitting the problem into two iterative steps:

  • Step 1: Access Technology Selection: With power levels fixed, the system solves for the optimal technology and subcarrier assignment using linear integer programming.
  • Step 2: Power Allocation: With assignments fixed, the system optimizes power levels using Difference-of-Convex (DC) programming.

The researchers also derived a closed-form solution for the power allocation step, which they describe as a "pseudo water-filling" logic. In this model, the NOMA processing cost acts as a penalty on the power budget, ensuring that power is only diverted to NOMA when the utility return is high.

Simulation and Results

The framework was tested using Monte Carlo simulations of a 5G cell with 20 users and 10 subcarriers, assuming Rayleigh fading and standard urban path-loss models. The results highlight three key advantages of the dynamic approach:

  • Increased Utility: In power-constrained environments, the dynamic selection method achieved a 20% higher utility compared to a pure NOMA system. This is because the system avoids the "complexity penalty" of NOMA when OMA can provide similar rates at lower costs.
  • Reduced Outage Probability: The hybrid system proved more robust in meeting Quality of Service (QoS) requirements. When minimum rate requirements were high, the dynamic approach halved the outage probability compared to single-technology OMA or NOMA setups.
  • Sensitivity to Hardware Limits: As the simulated cost of SIC processing increased (representing hardware limitations), the system gracefully transitioned more subcarriers to OMA. In contrast, a NOMA-only system's performance plummeted under the same conditions.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that the future of 5G multiple access is not a binary choice between OMA and NOMA. By implementing a software-defined, dynamic selection mechanism, network operators can maximize spectral efficiency while minimizing computational overhead. While the study assumes perfect Channel State Information (CSI) and limits NOMA to two-user pairing, it provides a robust mathematical foundation for more intelligent, adaptive 5G resource management. Future work may explore the impact of imperfect CSI and the potential for multi-user NOMA clusters within this dynamic framework.

Reference: Baghani, M., Parsaeefard, S., Derakhshani, M., & Saad, W. (2018). Dynamic Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) and Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) in 5G Wireless Networks. arXiv:1811.11090v1.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, facilitated via the flexible software defined structure of the radio access units in 5G, we propose a novel dynamic multiple access technology selection among orthogonal multiple access (OMA) and non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) techniques for each subcarrier. For this setup, we formulate a joint resource allocation problem where a new set of access technology selection parameters along with power and subcarrier are allocated for each user based on each user's channel state information. Here, we define a novel utility function taking into account the rate and costs of access technologies. This cost reflects both the complexity of performing successive interference cancellation and the complexity incurred to guarantee a desired bit error rate. This utility function can inherently demonstrate the trade-off between OMA and NOMA. Due to non-convexity of our proposed resource allocation problem, we resort to successive convex approximation where a two-step iterative algorithm is applied in which a problem of the first step, called access technology selection, is transformed into a linear integer programming problem, and the nonconvex problem of the second step, referred to power allocation problem, is solved via the difference-of-convex-functions (DC) programming. Moreover, the closed-form solution for power allocation in the second step is derived. For diverse network performance criteria such as rate, simulation results show that the proposed new dynamic access technology selection outperforms single-technology OMA or NOMA multiple access solutions.
BibTeX
@article{baghani2019dynamic,
  author = {Mina Baghani and Saeedeh Parsaeefard and Mahsa Derakhshani and Walid Saad},
  title = {{Dynamic Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) and Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) in 5G Wireless Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=eeudDCgvXt},
}
Figure