Dynamic Incentive Allocation for City-Scale Deep Decarbonization

Anupama Sitaraman, Adam Lechowicz, Noman Bashir, Xutong Liu, Mohammad Hajiesmaili, Prashant J. Shenoy

Abstract

Residential buildings contribute significantly to global energy consumption and carbon emissions. While financial incentives aim to accelerate the transition to clean energy technologies, current "one-size-fits-all" approaches are often inefficient and inequitable. This paper presents a data-driven optimization framework that leverages contextual multi-armed bandits to learn household-specific responses to financial offers. By shifting the objective from maximizing adoption rates to maximizing carbon reduction, the proposed model achieves up to 32% greater emissions reductions than status quo policies while ensuring socioeconomic equity.

Introduction

Residential heating and energy use account for approximately 22% of global energy consumption. Decarbonizing this sector requires a massive shift toward electrification, specifically the adoption of heat pumps and solar panels. However, existing incentive programs, such as federal tax credits, suffer from two primary flaws: inefficiency and inequity. They often reward "free-riders" who would have adopted the technology regardless, or they fail to provide sufficient support for low-income households facing high upfront costs. This research addresses these gaps by proposing a dynamic, personalized incentive allocation strategy.

Problem Statement

Current policies typically aim to maximize the total number of installations. However, this does not necessarily correlate with the greatest carbon reduction. For instance, a large, inefficient home switching from oil heating to a heat pump yields significantly more carbon savings than a small, efficient home making the same switch. Furthermore, the financial "tipping point" for adoption varies widely across households due to differing energy needs and investment horizons.

Cumulative distribution of net benefits for households across different investment horizons. The vertical line represents the break-even point where adoption becomes financially viable without external incentives.

As shown in the figure above, the vast majority of households face a negative net benefit over a 5-year period, highlighting the necessity of targeted financial intervention to trigger adoption.

Methodology

The researchers frame incentive allocation as a two-stage optimization problem.

Stage 1: Learning the Human Factor

To understand how much incentive is required for a specific household to adopt new technology, the framework utilizes Contextual Multi-Armed Bandits, specifically a Contextual Lower Confidence Bound (CLCB) algorithm. By "surveying" a subset of the population with varying offers, the model learns the relationship between household context (e.g., median income, energy usage) and the likelihood of adoption. The "reward" in this bandit setting is the carbon reduction achieved per dollar of incentive spent.

Stage 2: Optimization and Rollout

Once the response functions are learned, the city-wide rollout is modeled as a Knapsack Problem. The objective is to select a set of households for incentives that maximizes total carbon reduction within a fixed budget.

Equity Constraints

To ensure fairness, the model incorporates equity constraints. These can be "Strict" or "Relaxed," mandating that a specific portion of the budget (e.g., 25% for low-income, 50% for middle-income) is reserved for disadvantaged groups.

Data and Evaluation

The framework was evaluated using a comprehensive dataset:

  • Energy Usage: 5-minute electricity and 1-hour natural gas data for over 3,000 housing units in a Northeastern U.S. city.
  • Grid Intensity: Regional carbon intensity data from Electricity Maps.
  • Socioeconomics: U.S. Census data for income classification.
  • Solar Potential: Building-specific estimates generated via the Solar-TK toolkit.

Results and Discussion

The proposed framework demonstrates significant improvements over traditional fixed-incentive models:

  • Enhanced Carbon Reduction: The bandit-led approach achieved up to 32.23% higher carbon reductions than status quo policies.
  • Learning Efficiency: The model reaches near-optimal performance after surveying only approximately 700 households, making it feasible for city-scale implementation.
  • Equitable Outcomes: Under strict equity constraints, the system successfully met socioeconomic distribution targets while still capturing ~79% of the theoretical maximum carbon savings. This indicates that equity and environmental goals are not mutually exclusive.
  • Contextual Sensitivity: The model's effectiveness is highly dependent on local grid conditions. In regions with cleaner grids, the carbon benefit of electrification is substantially higher, a factor the dynamic model successfully exploits.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research demonstrates that personalized, data-driven incentive allocation can drastically improve the efficiency of decarbonization efforts. By focusing on carbon reduction rather than simple adoption rates and accounting for socioeconomic disparities, cities can achieve deeper emissions cuts more fairly. Future work will look to incorporate "irrational" human behavioral factors, expand the scope to include electric vehicles, and explore the impact of dynamic time-of-use energy pricing on adoption.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sitaraman2025dynamic,
  author = {Anupama Sitaraman and Adam Lechowicz and Noman Bashir and Xutong Liu and Mohammad Hajiesmaili and Prashant J. Shenoy},
  title = {{Dynamic Incentive Allocation for City-Scale Deep Decarbonization}},
  journal = {ACM J. Comput. Sustain. Soc.},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1145/3736650},
}
Figure