Dynamic Clustering Algorithms via Small-Variance Analysis of Markov Chain Mixture Models.

Trevor Campbell, Brian Kulis, Jonathan P. HowIEEE TPAMI 2019 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel dynamic clustering algorithms, D-Means and SD-Means, that can track evolving clusters in streaming data. By leveraging a small-variance asymptotic analysis of a Markov Chain Mixture Model, these algorithms offer a computationally efficient way to handle time-varying data, outperforming existing methods in both speed and accuracy across various real-world applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional clustering algorithms often assume a static dataset, making them ill-suited for scenarios where data characteristics change over time. This is a significant limitation in fields like robotics, where sensor data is continuous and dynamic. While Bayesian nonparametrics (BNPs) offer flexible models that can infer the number of clusters, their inference algorithms are often computationally expensive, hindering real-time applications. Existing small-variance asymptotic analyses have focused on static BNP models, leaving a gap in handling temporally evolving latent structures in data. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing efficient clustering algorithms for streaming data with evolving clusters.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the application of small-variance asymptotic analysis to a Markov Chain Mixture Model (MCMM) with a Gaussian likelihood (MCGMM). This technique simplifies complex BNP inference by examining the model's behavior as certain variances approach zero, leading to "hard" (deterministic) assignments.

The authors derive two main algorithms:

  • D-Means: This algorithm is a direct result of the small-variance analysis of the Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) filtering problem for the MCGMM. It's an iterative, coordinate-descent based algorithm that efficiently updates cluster assignments and centers, effectively performing K-Means-like clustering on sequential data batches. It incorporates mechanisms for cluster birth, death, and motion.
  • SD-Means: To address the limitation of D-Means in handling non-linearly separable or non-spherical clusters, SD-Means extends D-Means through kernelization and spectral relaxation. Kernelization maps data into a higher-dimensional space where clusters might become separable, while spectral relaxation provides a more robust global optimization approach. This results in a spectral clustering algorithm for dynamic data.

Datasets

The paper evaluates D-Means and SD-Means on several datasets:

  • Synthetic Moving Gaussians: Data generated with known cluster assignments to allow for accuracy comparisons.
  • Synthetic Moving Rings: Data designed to test the algorithms' ability to handle non-linearly separable clusters.
  • Synthetic Gaussian Processes: Datasets generated from unknown latent functions modeled as GPs, testing robustness to uncertainty.
  • Aircraft ADSB Trajectories: Real-world data from aircraft tracking, used to demonstrate temporal pattern discovery.
  • Video Color Quantization: Video frames treated as sequential batches to assess temporal smoothness in color palettes.
  • Human Segmentation in Point Clouds: LiDAR data from people walking, used to evaluate the clustering of non-spherical shapes and temporal tracking.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging BNP Flexibility and Computational Tractability: The small-variance asymptotic analysis successfully translates the rich modeling capabilities of Bayesian nonparametrics into computationally efficient, "hard" clustering algorithms.
  • Dynamic Clustering for Evolving Data: The MCMM framework and its small-variance analysis provide a principled way to model and track clusters that change over time (birth, death, motion), which is crucial for streaming data.
  • Kernelization and Spectral Methods for Complex Clusters: SD-Means demonstrates that by combining kernel methods with spectral relaxation, clustering algorithms can effectively handle non-spherical and non-linearly separable data, a significant limitation of D-Means.
  • Robustness to Parameter Choices: Both D-Means and SD-Means show a degree of robustness to parameter variations, making them more practical for real-world deployment.

Key Results

  • D-Means: Outperforms contemporary clustering algorithms (Gibbs sampling, variational inference, particle learning) in both label accuracy and computational cost on synthetic moving Gaussian data. For instance, it achieved higher accuracy with significantly less computation time on aircraft trajectory data compared to DP-Means and Gibbs sampling.
  • SD-Means: Successfully clusters non-linearly separable data (moving rings) where D-Means fails. It also shows superior performance in segmenting non-spherical shapes (humans in point clouds) compared to D-Means.
  • Computational Efficiency: D-Means is significantly faster than sampling-based BNP methods. SD-Means, while more computationally intensive than D-Means, offers a favorable trade-off for complex cluster structures.
  • Temporal Consistency: D-Means provides temporally smooth color quantization in videos, reducing flicker compared to K-Means and DP-Means.

Limitations and Future Work

  • D-Means Limitations: D-Means struggles with non-linearly separable and non-spherical clusters due to its inherent assumption of spherical clusters.
  • SD-Means Complexity: While more flexible, SD-Means incurs a higher computational cost than D-Means.
  • Parameter Tuning: While robust, parameter tuning for both algorithms can still be a challenge, though the paper suggests practical strategies.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further exploration of kernel functions for SD-Means could enhance its applicability to even more complex data structures. The authors also mention that D-Means can be used for "any-time" clustering on large datasets by treating random subsets as batches, hinting at its scalability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bayesian nonparametrics are a class of probabilistic models in which the model size is inferred from data. A recently developed methodology in this field is small-variance asymptotic analysis, a mathematical technique for deriving learning algorithms that capture much of the flexibility of Bayesian nonparametric inference algorithms, but are simpler to implement and less computationally expensive. Past work on small-variance analysis of Bayesian nonparametric inference algorithms has exclusively considered batch models trained on a single, static dataset, which are incapable of capturing time evolution in the latent structure of the data. This work presents a small-variance analysis of the maximum a posteriori filtering problem for a temporally varying mixture model with a Markov dependence structure, which captures temporally evolving clusters within a dataset. Two clustering algorithms result from the analysis: D-Means, an iterative clustering algorithm for linearly separable, spherical clusters; and SD-Means, a spectral clustering algorithm derived from a kernelized, relaxed version of the clustering problem. Empirical results from experiments demonstrate the advantages of using D-Means and SD-Means over contemporary clustering algorithms, in terms of both computational cost and clustering accuracy.
BibTeX
@article{campbell2019dynamic,
  author = {Trevor Campbell and Brian Kulis and Jonathan P. How},
  title = {{Dynamic Clustering Algorithms via Small-Variance Analysis of Markov Chain Mixture Models.}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell.},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=BQYbBhBxd6S},
}
Figure