Dual-mode recognition of tRNAPro isoacceptors by Toxoplasma gondii Prolyl-tRNA synthetase

Indira Rizqita Ivanesthi, Emi Latifah, Shih-Yang Liu, Yi‐Kuan Tseng, Hung-Chuan Pan, Chien‐Chia WangEMBO 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Toxoplasma gondii's single prolyl-tRNA synthetase (TgProRS), classified as eukaryotic-type (E-type), exhibits remarkable flexibility by efficiently charging both its native cytosolic E-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> and a distinct apicoplast P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup>. This dual functionality, mediated by specific residues in the enzyme's motif 2 loop, challenges the long-held paradigm of ProRS specificity and offers new avenues for developing targeted antiparasitic drugs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) are essential enzymes responsible for attaching the correct amino acid to its corresponding transfer RNA (tRNA), a crucial step for accurate protein synthesis. Each aaRS typically exhibits high specificity for its cognate tRNA, recognizing unique "identity elements" within the tRNA structure. Prolyl-tRNA synthetases (ProRSs) are a class of aaRSs that attach proline to tRNA<sup>Pro</sup>. These enzymes are broadly categorized into E-type (eukaryotic/archaeal) and P-type (prokaryotic) variants, each with distinct structural features and generally specific tRNA recognition patterns.

The parasite Toxoplasma gondii presents an intriguing case: it possesses a single E-type ProRS (TgProRS) but utilizes two different tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptors – one in the cytosol (E-type) and another in the apicoplast (P-type). This raises a fundamental question: how does a single E-type enzyme efficiently and accurately charge two distinct tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> types that are typically recognized by different classes of ProRS? This paper aims to unravel the molecular mechanisms behind TgProRS's dual recognition capability and its implications for parasite survival and drug development.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Enzyme Purification: TgProRS, with its organellar targeting signal (OTS) and proline-editing domain (ProXp-ala) removed, was purified to homogeneity using Ni-NTA chromatography. This allowed for focused study of its catalytic domain.
  • In Vitro Aminoacylation Assays: Purified TgProRS was tested for its ability to charge various in vitro-transcribed tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> substrates, including T. gondii's own cytosolic and apicoplast tRNAs, as well as representative human (E-type) and Thermus thermophilus (P-type) tRNAs. Kinetic parameters (k<sub>cat</sub>, K<sub>M</sub>, k<sub>cat</sub>/K<sub>M</sub>) were determined to quantify aminoacylation efficiency.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: To pinpoint the structural elements responsible for dual recognition, specific amino acid residues within TgProRS's motif 2 loop were mutated to alanine. The kinetic parameters of these mutant enzymes were then assessed for their ability to charge different tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> types.
  • In Vivo Complementation Assays: The functional significance of TgProRS's dual activity was validated using yeast knockout strains lacking their endogenous cytoplasmic (PROS1) and mitochondrial (PROS2) ProRS. The ability of TgProRS (with or without a mitochondrial targeting signal) and its mutants to rescue the growth defects of these yeast strains was evaluated.
  • Inhibition Assays: The sensitivity of TgProRS to known proline analogs, azetidine-2-carboxylic acid (A2C) and halofuginone (HF), was tested when charging either the cytosolic or apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup>. IC<sub>50</sub> values were determined to assess differential inhibition.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Relaxed Specificity is the Norm for TgProRS: Contrary to the expectation of strict specificity for E-type ProRS, TgProRS demonstrates a remarkable ability to efficiently charge both E-type and P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptors. This challenges the established classification and suggests a more fluid evolutionary landscape for aaRS specificity.
  • Distinct Identity Elements for Different tRNAs: While the acceptor stem nucleotides (C72/C73) are dispensable for cytosolic tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging, the G72/A73 nucleotides are crucial for apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> aminoacylation. This highlights that TgProRS employs different recognition strategies for its two tRNA substrates.
  • Motif 2 Loop as the Key to Dual Recognition: The motif 2 loop, a known tRNA recognition element in class II synthetases, harbors a unique KQPT sequence in TgProRS. Mutating specific residues within this loop (K474, Q475, T477) selectively impairs the charging of either E-type or P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup>, demonstrating its critical role in mediating dual specificity.
  • Differential Drug Sensitivity: TgProRS exhibits significantly different sensitivities to the inhibitor halofuginone (HF) depending on which tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptor it is charging. Cytosolic tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging is much more sensitive to HF inhibition than apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging. This differential sensitivity is a crucial finding for developing targeted therapies.

Key Results

  • TgProRS efficiently aminoacylates both T. gondii cytosolic E-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> and apicoplast P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup>, as well as human E-type and T. thermophilus P-type tRNAs, with comparable efficiency.
  • Mutating C72/C73 to G72/A73 in T. gondii tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> only modestly reduced aminoacylation by TgProRS (3.2-fold), while mutating G72/A73 to C72/C73 in T. gondii tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> dramatically decreased efficiency (140-fold).
  • Mutations in TgProRS's motif 2 loop showed differential effects: K474A primarily impaired E-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging (9.5-fold loss), while Q475A and T477A primarily impaired P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging (9- and 52-fold loss, respectively).
  • TgProRS successfully complemented yeast knockout strains lacking either cytoplasmic or mitochondrial ProRS, demonstrating its functional versatility in vivo.
  • TgProRS showed similar IC<sub>50</sub> values for azetidine-2-carboxylic acid (A2C) when charging either tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> type (1.3 mM vs. 1.6 mM). However, it was significantly more sensitive to halofuginone (HF) when charging cytosolic tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> (IC<sub>50</sub> of 5 nM) compared to apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> (IC<sub>50</sub> of 24 nM).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they have identified the key residues in the motif 2 loop responsible for differential recognition, the precise structural basis for this dual recognition remains to be fully elucidated. The available co-crystal structures of TgProRS with inhibitors or tRNA do not fully capture the dynamic interactions. Therefore, determining the crystal structure of TgProRS in complex with its two distinct tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptors is crucial for a complete understanding of the enzyme's mechanism.

Future work could also explore whether this relaxed specificity provides a survival advantage for T. gondii in its host environment. Additionally, investigating whether other parasites with similar compartmentalization and tRNA isoacceptor systems exhibit analogous ProRS dual functionality would be valuable. The differential sensitivity to halofuginone also opens doors for developing more selective and potent antiparasitic drugs that specifically target the parasite's ProRS without significantly affecting human ProRS.

Summary updated

Abstract

Prolyl-tRNA synthetases (ProRSs) exhibit diverse domain architectures and motifs, evolving into prokaryotic (P-type) and eukaryotic/archaeal (E-type) variants. Both types exhibit high specificity for the recognition and aminoacylation of their cognate tRNAs. Interestingly, the parasitic eukaryote Toxoplasma gondii encodes a single E-type ProRS (TgProRS) but utilizes two distinct tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptors: a cytosolic E-type (with C72/C73) and an apicoplast P-type (with G72/A73). Our study demonstrates that TgProRS, despite being classified as an E-type enzyme, efficiently charges both tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> isoacceptors and functionally compensates for yeast cytoplasmic and mitochondrial ProRS activities. Notably, while C72/C73 are dispensable for cytosolic tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging, G72/A73 are crucial for apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> aminoacylation. Furthermore, Mutations in the motif 2 loop selectively affect E- or P-type tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> recognition. While TgProRS exhibits similar susceptibility to azetidine (a proline mimic) when charging both tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> types, cytosolic tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging is five times more sensitive to inhibition by halofuginone (a Pro-A76 mimic) compared to apicoplast tRNA<sup>Pro</sup> charging. These findings underscore TgProRS's dual functionality, showcasing its remarkable evolutionary adaptability and providing valuable insights for developing more selective therapeutic agents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ivanesthi2025dual,
  author = {Indira Rizqita Ivanesthi and Emi Latifah and Shih-Yang Liu and Yi‐Kuan Tseng and Hung-Chuan Pan and Chien‐Chia Wang},
  title = {{Dual-mode recognition of tRNAPro isoacceptors by Toxoplasma gondii Prolyl-tRNA synthetase}},
  booktitle = {EMBO},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s44319-025-00457-x},
}
Figure