Drivers affecting cloud ERP deployment decisions: an Australian study

Xinyu Zhang

Abstract

Cloud-based Enterprise Resources Planning (Cloud ERP) systems are increasingly central to organizational business processes, providing real-time infrastructure for purchasing, finance, and human resources. Despite its growing adoption, research into Cloud ERP within the Australian context remains limited, particularly regarding the differing perspectives of client companies and consultant firms. This study identifies 79 critical drivers from a systematic review of 31 papers, categorizing them via the Technology-Organisation-Environment (TOE) framework to develop an initial theoretical model. Through a case study approach involving semi-structured interviews and secondary resource analysis, the research develops an empirically validated model featuring 15 key drivers—7 of which are newly identified.

Introduction: The Cloud ERP Landscape in Australia

While Cloud ERP is rapidly replacing traditional on-premise systems globally, academic focus has largely centered on developing nations. There is a distinct lack of empirical data regarding the Australian market. Furthermore, existing studies often adopt a single-sided view. In practice, deployment decisions are shaped by a "tug-of-war" between client companies, who prioritize integration and security, and consultant companies, who emphasize scalability and functionality. This paper bridges this gap by providing a dual-perspective model that accounts for both viewpoints.

Methodology: A Multi-Stage Qualitative Approach

The study employed a multi-stage qualitative methodology to ensure both theoretical grounding and practical relevance:

  1. Systematic Literature Review: Analysis of 31 relevant papers to identify 79 initial drivers.
  2. Model Development: A three-step filtering process narrowed these to 10 core drivers, categorized using the Technology-Organisation-Environment (TOE) framework.
  3. Case Study Analysis:
  4. Primary Data: A 60-minute semi-structured interview with a senior IT leader (Chief Architect/EA Manager) providing insights into large Australian Energy and Transportation organizations.
  5. Secondary Data: Analysis of consultant-side case studies from Annexa regarding their work with Jak Max (Wholesale) and REA Group (Real Estate).
  6. Model Revision: The theoretical model was refined against real-world data to produce a final 15-driver "Revised Model."

Organizational Context: The Case Studies

The research draws on four distinct organizational profiles within the Australian market:

  • Case A (Energy): A large-scale public utility with over 3,700 employees.
  • Case B (Transportation): A state-level public organization governed by government jurisdiction.
  • Case C (Jak Max): A wholesale trade supplier of outdoor power equipment.
  • Case D (REA Group): A major multinational digital advertising company for real estate.

Key Insights: The Perception Gap

A striking finding of this research is the "Great Divergence" between stakeholders: not a single common driver was identified by both clients and consultants. Clients and consultants appear to operate in different conceptual worlds regarding ERP deployment.

  • Clients are preoccupied with organizational hurdles, risks, and negative drivers (barriers).
  • Consultants focus almost exclusively on technical "wins" and positive incentives.

New Drivers in the Australian Context

The study uncovered seven new drivers not previously emphasized in general literature:

  • Political Influence: Particularly relevant for government-linked entities where election cycles or political shifts can delay deployment decisions.
  • Vendor Relationship Management: The complexity of navigating agency-to-agency relationships rather than simple customer-provider ones.
  • System Maturity: Large-scale enterprises are hesitant to adopt "immature" cloud software without a proven, large-scale customer base.
  • Change of Operating Model: The fundamental shift in how the business functions post-cloud.
  • Functionality, Global Expansion, and Issues with Current Systems: Specific operational triggers that necessitate a move to the cloud.

Results: The 15-Driver Validated Model

The research evolved the initial framework into a comprehensive 15-driver model that better reflects the Australian enterprise landscape:

  • 8 Retained Drivers: Security, Scalability, Maintainability, Integration, Accessibility, Cost, Business Agility, and Vendor Reliability.
  • 7 New Drivers: Maturity of ERP systems, Change of Operating Model, Vendor Relationship Management, Political Reason, Functionality, Global Expansion, and Issues with Current System.

Technological factors remain the most influential category in determining cloud migration. Notably, the study challenges the "Cost Saving" narrative; for the Energy utility case, Cloud ERP was cost-equivalent to upgrading on-premise systems. The true driver was Business Agility, highlighting that strategic flexibility often outweighs direct financial savings in large-scale deployments.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study provides a nuanced understanding of Cloud ERP adoption in Australia, highlighting that deployment is not merely a technical upgrade but a complex decision influenced by organizational maturity and political context. The findings underscore the importance of aligning consultant offerings with the risk-averse, organizational-focused concerns of client companies.

Limitations: The primary data relies heavily on a single high-level interviewee, and the focus on large-scale enterprises may not generalize to Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs). Future research should include longitudinal studies to track how these drivers evolve in the post-deployment phase.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cloud-based Enterprise Resources Planning (Cloud ERP) is hosting an ERP system through the cloud environment. Cloud ERP is responsible for organisational business processes such as purchasing, financial, and human resource by providing a real-time infrastructure for the enterprise. With the development of technology, cloud ERP is noticed by more and more enterprises. Currently, limited researches have been conducted for cloud ERP systems in the Australian context. Furthermore, no studies have indicated how different perspectives (client company & consultant company) bring insights into the deployment decisions on cloud ERP. Hence, this research intends to understand drivers affecting cloud ERP deployment decisions from both the client company and the consultant company perspective in an Australian context. This paper identifies 31 relevant literature on cloud ERP adoption; 79 critical drivers affecting cloud ERP deployment decisions were identified from the selected literature, and those drivers are then categorized using the Technology-Organisation-Environment (TOE) framework to develop the initial theoretical model. By conducting a Case Study Approach using a semi-structured interview and secondary resources analysis, findings are then compared to the theoretical model. As a result, an empirically validated model on drivers affecting cloud ERP deployment decisions from both client company and consultant company perspectives has been developed; this model contains 15 drivers and 7 of them are new. The theoretical and practical contributions of the findings are then outlined.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2019drivers,
  author = {Xinyu Zhang},
  title = {{Drivers affecting cloud ERP deployment decisions: an Australian study}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1911.11309},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.11309},
}

Loading related content...

Figure