Downlink resource allocation for the high-speed train and local users in OFDMA systems

Chuang Zhang, Pingyi Fan, Ke Xiong

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently allocating wireless resources in an OFDMA system serving both high-speed train passengers (mobile users) and stationary local users. By employing a novel two-time-scale resource allocation strategy and deriving an explicit expression for inter-carrier interference (ICI) caused by the train's Doppler spread, the authors propose an Optimal Power and Subcarrier Allocation (OPSA) policy that significantly outperforms traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional wireless resource allocation schemes often assume users are relatively stationary. However, the increasing prevalence of high-speed transportation systems, like trains, introduces a new challenge: serving users with vastly different mobility characteristics within the same cellular network. Passengers on a high-speed train experience rapid channel variations due to Doppler spread, leading to inter-carrier interference (ICI) that degrades performance. Meanwhile, local users have stable channel conditions. This paper addresses the problem of fairly and efficiently allocating limited wireless resources (power and subcarriers) from a base station (BS) to these two distinct user groups simultaneously, maximizing the train passengers' capacity while ensuring a minimum service level for local users.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach lies in a two-time-scale resource allocation strategy. This means resources are managed at two different speeds:

  • Longer Time-Scale (Scheduling Period): The BS divides the total available power and subcarriers between the high-speed train (represented by a mobile relay, MR) and all local users. This allocation is based on average channel conditions, as the train's instantaneous CSI is not available to the BS.
  • Shorter Time-Scale (Slot): Within each scheduling period, the resources allocated to local users are further dynamically allocated based on their instantaneous CSI.

A key technical contribution is the derivation of a closed-form expression for the Inter-Carrier Interference (ICI) experienced by the MR. This is achieved by modeling the train's channel using a two-path Doppler spread model and treating the ICI as additive Gaussian noise. This explicit ICI expression allows for a more accurate optimization.

The problem is then formulated as a capacity optimization problem for the MR, subject to a sum capacity constraint for local users. Through mathematical transformations and convexity analysis, the authors prove the existence and uniqueness of an optimal solution and propose an efficient algorithm, Optimal Power and Subcarrier Allocation (OPSA), to find it.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated data based on the described network model and parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two-Time-Scale Allocation is Crucial: The significant difference in mobility between train passengers and local users necessitates a resource allocation strategy that operates at different speeds to adapt to their respective channel dynamics.
  • ICI is a Major Bottleneck for Mobile Users: The Doppler spread from high-speed movement introduces ICI, which significantly impacts the capacity of the mobile relay. Accurately modeling and accounting for this ICI is vital for effective resource allocation.
  • OPSA Outperforms Simpler Strategies: The proposed OPSA policy demonstrates superior performance compared to constant power and subcarrier allocation (CPSA) policies, especially in varying channel conditions.
  • ICI Cancellation Isn't Always Worth the Complexity: By comparing capacity bounds with and without ICI, the paper reveals that the benefit of complex ICI cancellation techniques is only significant in specific scenarios where the capacity gap is large. In many cases, the performance gain might not justify the implementation overhead.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully formulates and solves a complex resource allocation problem for a mixed-mobility OFDMA system.
  • The proposed OPSA policy is shown through simulations to achieve near-optimal performance for the mobile relay (train passengers).
  • Fig. 3 demonstrates that OPSA significantly outperforms CPSA policies (power-limited, bandwidth-limited, and intermediate) across different time intervals as the train moves through the cell. For instance, OPSA consistently provides higher capacity than CPSA-PL and CPSA-BL.
  • Fig. 4 illustrates that the normalized capacity gap (representing potential ICI cancellation gains) is time-varying, highlighting that ICI cancellation is most beneficial when the gap is substantial.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified ICI Model: While the two-path Doppler spread model allows for a closed-form ICI expression, it's a simplification of real-world scenarios. More complex Doppler spread models could be explored.
  • Assumptions on CSI: The paper assumes average CSI is available for the MR at the longer time-scale and perfect CSI for local users at the shorter time-scale. Real-world CSI acquisition can be imperfect.
  • Single Cell Scenario: The analysis is limited to a single cell. Extending the resource allocation to a multi-cell environment with inter-cell interference would be a valuable future direction.
  • Specific Train Architecture: The paper uses a two-hop architecture with a mobile relay. Investigating other train communication architectures could be explored.
  • Fairness Considerations: While the paper aims to balance MR capacity with local user constraints, further research into explicit fairness metrics between the two groups could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider providing services for passengers in a high-speed train and local users (quasi-static users) in a single OFDMA system. For the train, we apply a two-hop architecture, under which, passengers communicate with base stations (BSs) via a mobile relay (MR) installed in the train cabin. With this architecture, all passengers in the train can be represented by the MR. Since the channels of the MR and local users vary differently, we consider allocating system resources (power and subcarriers) over two time-scales for them. We formulate the problem as a capacity optimization problem for the MR subject to the sum capacity constraint of local users. We treat the inter-carrier interference (ICI) at the MR as additive Gaussian noise and derive an explicit expression for the ICI using the two-path Doppler spread model. Then we discuss the optimization problem and propose an optimal power and subcarrier allocation (OPSA) policy. The capacity obtained using OPSA is compared with that of constant power and subcarrier allocation (CPSA) policies. Simulation results justify the optimality of the OPSA. Besides, by comparing the capacity bounds achieved by OPSA with and without ICI, we find that only in specific regions, where the gap between the capacity bounds is large, do practical ICI cancellation methods provide meaningful rate gain.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2014downlink,
  author = {Chuang Zhang and Pingyi Fan and Ke Xiong},
  title = {{Downlink resource allocation for the high-speed train and local users in OFDMA systems}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1412.7763},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1412.7763},
}
Figure