Dorsal anterior cingulate and ventromedial prefrontal cortex have inverse roles in both foraging and economic choice

Amitai Shenhav, Mark A. Straccia, Matthew Botvinick, Jonathan D. Cohen

Introduction

A central debate in neuroeconomics concerns whether the human brain employs specialized modules for different types of decisions or a general-purpose system for all value-based choices. A prominent theory, supported by a landmark 2012 study, suggested a functional division: the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) was thought to be specialized for "foraging" decisions (deciding whether to switch tasks or environments), while the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) was dedicated to "economic" choices (selecting between simultaneously presented options).

This paper challenges this specialization hypothesis. The authors argue that previous findings were confounded by a correlation between foraging value and choice difficulty. By expanding the range of choice values and costs, this study demonstrates that dACC and vmPFC activity actually reflects choice difficulty and ease, respectively, across both foraging and economic decision types.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers employed functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) on 31 participants who performed a novel two-stage decision task.

Figure 1: Experimental paradigm and behavioral results. (A) The two-stage task involving a foraging decision followed by an economic decision. (B) Beta estimates for various task parameters. (C) Psychometric curve showing the probability of choosing to forage as a function of the relative value of foraging (RVF).

As shown in Figure 1A, the task consisted of:

  1. Stage 1 (Foraging Decision): Participants were presented with a current reward offer and a "forage set" of potential alternatives. They decided whether to "engage" (stay with the current offer) or "forage" (pay a cost to switch to a new offer from the set).
  2. Stage 2 (Economic Decision): If participants chose to engage, they then made a standard economic choice between two reward-probability pairs.

To increase cognitive demand and ensure participants were actively integrating information, playing cards were used as stimuli. Crucially, the authors used a much wider range of reward values and costs than previous studies, allowing them to statistically decouple the value of foraging from the difficulty of the decision.

Key Insights: Difficulty vs. Specialization

The core finding of this study is that the dACC and vmPFC are not specialized for different types of decisions, but rather for different aspects of the decision process itself.

The dACC as a Difficulty Tracker

The dACC does not specifically track the value of foraging. Instead, its activity scales with choice difficulty or conflict. Activity in this region peaks when the competing options are nearly equal in value—the point of maximum indecision. By testing a broader range of foraging values, the authors showed that dACC activity actually decreases when foraging becomes extremely lucrative and therefore "easy." If the dACC were a dedicated foraging value tracker, its activity should have continued to rise with value.

The vmPFC as an Ease Tracker

The vmPFC acts as a functional mirror to the dACC. Its activity scales with choice ease, or "relative chosen value." When one option is clearly superior to the other, making the choice easy, vmPFC activity ramps up. This relationship held true for both the foraging and economic stages of the task.

Results and Quantitative Modeling

Behavioral data confirmed that participants' choices were sensitive to the manipulated values and costs (Figure 1B, 1C). Quantitative modeling of the fMRI data revealed that a model based on choice difficulty explained dACC activity significantly better than a model based on foraging value.

Furthermore, the authors were able to replicate the "foraging value" signal seen in earlier studies but demonstrated that it only appeared within a narrow, low-value window. Once higher values were included in the analysis, the signal reversed, confirming it was a byproduct of choice difficulty rather than a specialized foraging signal.

Conclusion

These results suggest a unity of mechanism in the prefrontal cortex for value-based decision-making. Rather than having evolved separate modules for sequential foraging and simultaneous choice, the brain appears to use a common computational framework where the dACC monitors conflict/difficulty and the vmPFC tracks the relative value of the chosen option.

While these findings clarify the roles of these regions, questions remain. For instance, the vmPFC is part of the "Default Mode Network," which is more active during periods of lower task focus; it is possible that "easy" choices allow for earlier task disengagement, contributing to the observed BOLD signal. Future research will need to further refine the definitions of "difficulty" and "conflict" and explore these mechanisms in more naturalistic, complex environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Recent research has highlighted a distinction between sequential foraging choices and traditional economic choices between simultaneously presented options. This was partly motivated by observations in Kolling et al. (2012) [KBMR] that these choice types are subserved by different circuits, with dorsal anterior cingulate (dACC) preferentially involved in foraging and ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) preferentially involved in economic choice. To support this account, KBMR used fMRI to scan human subjects making either a foraging choice (between exploiting a current offer or swapping for potentially better rewards) or an economic choice (between two reward-probability pairs). This study found that dACC better tracked values pertaining to foraging, while vmPFC better tracked values pertaining to economic choice. We recently showed that dACC’s role in these foraging choices is better described by the difficulty of choosing than by foraging value, when correcting for choice biases and testing a sufficiently broad set of foraging values (Shenhav et al., 2014). Here, we extend these findings in three ways. First, we replicate our original finding with a larger sample and a task modified to address remaining methodological gaps between our previous experiments and that of KBMR. Second, we show that dACC activity is best accounted for by choice difficulty alone (rather than in combination with foraging value) during both foraging and economic choices. Third, we show that patterns of vmPFC activity, inverted relative to dACC, also suggest a common function across both choice types. Overall, we conclude that both regions are similarly engaged by foraging-like and economic choice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shenhav2016dorsal,
  author = {Amitai Shenhav and Mark A. Straccia and Matthew Botvinick and Jonathan D. Cohen},
  title = {{Dorsal anterior cingulate and ventromedial prefrontal cortex have inverse roles in both foraging and economic choice}},
  booktitle = {Cognitive},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3758/s13415-016-0458-8},
}
Figure