Dominant RP in the Middle While Recessive in Both the N- and C-Terminals Due to RP1 Truncations: Confirmation, Refinement, and Questions

Junwen Wang, Xueshan Xiao, Shiqiang Li, Panfeng Wang, Wenmin Sun, Qingjiong ZhangFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

RP1 truncation variants, including frameshift, nonsense, and splicing, are a common cause of retinitis pigmentosa (RP). RP1 is a unique gene where truncations cause either autosomal dominant RP (adRP) or autosomal recessive RP (arRP) depending on the location of the variants. This study aims to clarify the boundaries between adRP and arRP caused by RP1 truncation variants based on a systemic analysis of 165 RP1 variants from our in-house exome-sequencing data of 7,092 individuals as well as a thorough review of 185 RP1 variants from published literature. In our cohort, potential pathogenic variants were detected in 16 families, including 11 new and five previously described families. Of the 16, seven families with adRP had heterozygous truncations in the middle portion, while nine families with either arRP (eight) or macular degeneration had biallelic variants in the N- and C-terminals, involving 10 known and seven novel variants. In the literature, 147 truncations in RP1 were reported to be responsible for either arRP (85) or adRP (58) or both (four). An overall evaluation of RP1 causative variants suggested three separate regions, i.e., the N-terminal from c.1 (p.1) to c.1837 (p.613), the middle portion from c.1981 (p.661) to c.2749 (p.917), and the C-terminal from c.2816 (p.939) to c.6471 (p.2157), where truncations in the middle portion were associated with adRP, while those in the N- and C-terminals were responsible for arRP. Heterozygous truncations alone in the N- and C- terminals were unlikely pathogenic. However, conflict reports with reverse situation were present for 13 variants, suggesting a complicated pathogenicity awaiting to be further elucidated. In addition, pathogenicity for homozygous truncations around c.5797 and thereafter might also need to be further clarified, so as for missense variants and for truncations located in the two gaps. Our data not only confirmed and refined the boundaries between dominant and recessive RP1 truncations but also revealed unsolved questions valuable for further investigation. These findings remind us that great care is needed in interpreting the results of RP1 variants in clinical gene testing as well as similar features may also be present in some other genes.

Introduction

The RP1 gene is a major player in Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP), a group of genetic disorders characterized by the progressive loss of retinal cells. Uniquely, RP1 exhibits a "position-dependent" inheritance pattern. Depending on where a truncation mutation (a "stop" signal that cuts the protein short) occurs along the gene sequence, the resulting disease can be either autosomal dominant (adRP) or autosomal recessive (arRP). This complexity creates significant challenges for clinical diagnosis and genetic counseling. This study seeks to resolve conflicting reports and define the exact "territories" of dominance and recessivity within the RP1 gene.

Methods

The researchers combined a massive internal dataset with a comprehensive meta-analysis of existing literature:

  • In-house Cohort: Exome sequencing was performed on 7,092 individuals with various eye conditions at the Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center, identifying 1,019 RP patients.
  • Literature Review: A systematic review of 185 previously reported RP1 variants was conducted using databases like PubMed and HGMD.
  • Validation: Potential pathogenic variants were filtered using population databases (gnomAD), evaluated with in silico prediction tools, and confirmed via Sanger sequencing and family segregation analysis.

The Three-Region "Sandwich" Model

The study confirms that RP1 is structured like a genetic "sandwich." The inheritance pattern is dictated by the mutation's location:

  • N-Terminal (p.1–p.613): Recessive.
  • Middle Portion (p.661–p.917): Dominant.
  • C-Terminal (p.939–p.2157): Recessive.
Distribution of RP1 truncation variants across the gene, highlighting the dominant (AD) middle region and recessive (AR) terminal regions.

The authors refined the upstream boundary of the dominant region to residue 661. A crucial takeaway for clinicians is that single (heterozygous) truncation mutations in the N- or C-terminals are almost never the primary cause of disease; they are likely benign carrier states unless a second mutation is found on the other allele.

Clinical Severity and Results

Analysis revealed that the inheritance pattern significantly impacts clinical outcomes. Patients with recessive RP1 (biallelic mutations) had a significantly earlier age of onset ($P = 2.76 \times 10^{-11}$) and worse visual acuity ($P = 1.75 \times 10^{-4}$) compared to those with the dominant form.

Comparison of clinical features between autosomal recessive (AR) and autosomal dominant (AD) RP1 patients, showing earlier onset and worse visual acuity in the AR group.

Key results include:

  • High Consistency: 91.9% (147/160) of analyzed truncation variants followed the proposed three-region model.
  • New Discoveries: The study identified seven novel pathogenic variants, expanding the known mutational spectrum of RP1.
  • Macular Involvement: Recessive mutations were more likely to involve the macula earlier and more severely than dominant mutations.

Discussion and Future Directions

The authors hypothesize that middle-region truncations are toxic because they produce a truncated protein that interferes with healthy proteins (a dominant-negative effect), whereas end-region truncations might lead to a total loss of protein that the body can tolerate in a single dose (haplosufficiency).

While the model is robust, 13 variants (about 8%) did not fit, suggesting some pathogenicity might be "point-dependent" rather than "region-dependent." Future research is needed to bridge the small "gaps" in the gene sequence where no mutations have been recorded and to perform functional studies to confirm the exact molecular mechanisms involved.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>RP1</i> truncation variants, including frameshift, nonsense, and splicing, are a common cause of retinitis pigmentosa (RP). <i>RP1</i> is a unique gene where truncations cause either autosomal dominant RP (adRP) or autosomal recessive RP (arRP) depending on the location of the variants. This study aims to clarify the boundaries between adRP and arRP caused by <i>RP1</i> truncation variants based on a systemic analysis of 165 <i>RP1</i> variants from our in-house exome-sequencing data of 7,092 individuals as well as a thorough review of 185 <i>RP1</i> variants from published literature. In our cohort, potential pathogenic variants were detected in 16 families, including 11 new and five previously described families. Of the 16, seven families with adRP had heterozygous truncations in the middle portion, while nine families with either arRP (eight) or macular degeneration had biallelic variants in the N- and C-terminals, involving 10 known and seven novel variants. In the literature, 147 truncations in <i>RP1</i> were reported to be responsible for either arRP (85) or adRP (58) or both (four). An overall evaluation of <i>RP1</i> causative variants suggested three separate regions, i.e., the N-terminal from c.1 (p.1) to c.1837 (p.613), the middle portion from c.1981 (p.661) to c.2749 (p.917), and the C-terminal from c.2816 (p.939) to c.6471 (p.2157), where truncations in the middle portion were associated with adRP, while those in the N- and C-terminals were responsible for arRP. Heterozygous truncations alone in the N- and C- terminals were unlikely pathogenic. However, conflict reports with reverse situation were present for 13 variants, suggesting a complicated pathogenicity awaiting to be further elucidated. In addition, pathogenicity for homozygous truncations around c.5797 and thereafter might also need to be further clarified, so as for missense variants and for truncations located in the two gaps. Our data not only confirmed and refined the boundaries between dominant and recessive <i>RP1</i> truncations but also revealed unsolved questions valuable for further investigation. These findings remind us that great care is needed in interpreting the results of <i>RP1</i> variants in clinical gene testing as well as similar features may also be present in some other genes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021dominant,
  author = {Junwen Wang and Xueshan Xiao and Shiqiang Li and Panfeng Wang and Wenmin Sun and Qingjiong Zhang},
  title = {{Dominant RP in the Middle While Recessive in Both the N- and C-Terminals Due to RP1 Truncations: Confirmation, Refinement, and Questions}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2021.634478},
}
Figure