Does income influence rational decisions?

Huai‐Chun Lo, Ming–Hsuan Yang, Cheng-Tsu Huang, Ching-Yuan ChienEkonomski 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study explores the impact of income on customer loyalty so as to verify whether consumer decision-making is bounded by rationality or not. The empirical findings show that income positively affects customer loyalty in choosing leisure parks. Specifically, high-income customers prefer to reduce the time cost of information collection. Therefore, they are more inclined to choose a specific resort or a leisure activity park of a particular brand rather than spend their time searching and planning for the most appropriate location of a leisure activity park. This result supports the notion that customers' consumption decisions are bounded by rationality, not for the purpose of making the optimal decision, but in order to pursue satisfying their own needs instead.

Introduction: The Bounded Rationality of Choice

Traditional economic models often hinge on the "rational economic man" hypothesis, assuming consumers meticulously gather perfect information to maximize utility. However, behavioral economics introduces the concept of "bounded rationality," suggesting that human decision-making is constrained by limited time, cognitive bandwidth, and information. Consumers often seek "satisficing" solutions—choices that are "good enough"—rather than optimal ones.

This research investigates how income levels specifically influence this bounded rationality within the context of Taiwan's leisure park industry. The central question is whether high-income earners are more likely to exhibit brand loyalty as a strategy to minimize the time cost associated with researching new options, thereby prioritizing efficiency over traditional utility maximization.

Methodology

The study employed a quantitative, survey-based approach:

  1. Survey Design: A 30-item questionnaire using a 5-point Likert scale was developed to measure consumer preferences, incentives, and loyalty.
  2. Factor Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) with Varimax rotation was used to distill responses into four core dimensions: Learning Incentive, Leisure Incentive, Travel Satisfaction, and Customer Loyalty.
  3. Regression Modeling: Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression tested the impact of personal and household income on customer loyalty, while controlling for incentives and satisfaction.
  4. Robustness Checks: The dataset was split by gender to ensure the income-loyalty relationship remained consistent across demographic groups.

Data Overview

The primary dataset consists of 326 valid questionnaires collected from urban residents in Taoyuan County, Taiwan, between January and February 2022. The sample covers a broad demographic range, providing a robust basis for analyzing the relationship between economic status and consumer behavior.

Demographic profile of the survey respondents.

Results: Income as a Driver of Loyalty

The empirical results confirm a statistically significant positive correlation between income and customer loyalty. Regression analysis revealed coefficients of $\beta = 0.293$ for personal income and $\beta = 0.274$ for household income (both significant at the 1% level).

Raw data trends further illustrate this link. As shown in the table below, respondents in the highest personal income bracket (>NT$2,000,000) showed a mean loyalty agreement of approximately 89%, whereas those in the lowest bracket (<NT$300,000) averaged around 82%.

Relationship between personal income and customer loyalty indicators.

Key insights from these findings include:

  • Time-Cost Efficiency: High-income earners face higher opportunity costs for their time. Loyalty serves as a cognitive shortcut (heuristic), allowing them to bypass complex decision-making processes.
  • Satisficing over Maximizing: The results support the theory of bounded rationality. Consumers do not always seek the absolute "best" deal; they often seek to minimize friction and information-gathering costs.
  • Baseline Requirements: While income drives loyalty, leisure incentives ($\beta = 0.394$) and travel satisfaction ($\beta = 0.203$) remain critical baseline factors for repeat visits.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study demonstrates that income significantly influences consumer rationality, with higher income leading to increased brand loyalty as a time-saving mechanism. While the study is limited by its localized sample size and reliance on self-reported data, it offers valuable insights for businesses. Operators targeting high-income demographics should focus on building brand habituation and reducing transaction friction rather than competing solely on price or features. Future research could expand this inquiry to other industries and geographic regions to test the universality of these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores the impact of income on customer loyalty so as to verify whether consumer decision-making is bounded by rationality or not. The empirical findings show that income positively affects customer loyalty in choosing leisure parks. Specifically, high-income customers prefer to reduce the time cost of information collection. Therefore, they are more inclined to choose a specific resort or a leisure activity park of a particular brand rather than spend their time searching and planning for the most appropriate location of a leisure activity park. This result supports the notion that customers' consumption decisions are bounded by rationality, not for the purpose of making the optimal decision, but in order to pursue satisfying their own needs instead.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lo2022does,
  author = {Huai‐Chun Lo and Ming–Hsuan Yang and Cheng-Tsu Huang and Ching-Yuan Chien},
  title = {{Does income influence rational decisions?}},
  booktitle = {Ekonomski},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5937/ekonhor2202195l},
}
Figure