Cultivating the Chinese market through destination loyalty: enhancing resilience in the Maldives

David Weaver, Chuanzhong Tang, Laura J. Lawton, Yang LiuTourism 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Market diversification is a critical strategy for tourism-dependent small island states to maintain sector resilience and destination life cycle stability. This study examines the destination loyalty of Chinese tourists in the Maldives through an online survey of 1,260 experienced travelers. Using hierarchical cluster analysis, the research identifies four distinct segments based on loyalty metrics. While overall loyalty is high, the study highlights that loyalty is influenced by cultural awareness and engagement with local landscapes. Crucially, it situates these findings within the context of "bilateral asymmetry," where state-level decisions can disrupt even the most loyal market segments.

Introduction: The Resilience Challenge

Small island developing states (SIDS) like the Maldives are often characterized by "hyper-dependency" on international tourism. This economic structure leaves them exceptionally vulnerable to external shocks, such as global financial crises or environmental disasters. Historically, the Maldives relied on mature European markets like the UK and Italy. However, as these markets reached a plateau, the nation strategically pivoted toward the burgeoning Chinese outbound market. By the mid-2010s, China accounted for nearly 30% of all arrivals.

Resilience in this context is not merely a matter of arrival numbers; it requires deep destination loyalty—the propensity for visitors to return and to recommend the destination to others. This paper seeks to segment the Chinese market to understand what drives this loyalty and identifies the risks inherent in relying on a market subject to state-level geopolitical control.

Methodology: Segmenting the Chinese Market

The researchers conducted an online survey of 1,260 Chinese adults who had previously visited the Maldives. Participants were recruited from a reputable China-based marketing panel of 2.6 million consumers. To analyze the data, the study employed hierarchical cluster analysis (Ward’s method) to group individuals based on three specific loyalty dimensions:

  1. Revisit Intention: "I will go to the Maldives again."
  2. Recommendation Intention: "I will recommend it to others."
  3. Catering Satisfaction: A culturally specific variable measuring how well the Maldives meets Chinese-specific needs, such as food, language services, and payment systems (e.g., UnionPay).

Results: Four Profiles of Loyalty

The analysis revealed that the Chinese market is far from monolithic, identifying four distinct clusters:

  • Highly Loyal (31.2%): This group scored highest across all loyalty metrics. They tend to be older, married, and have higher household incomes.
  • Loyal (37.1%): The largest segment, representing the "normative" visitor with consistently positive views.
  • Cater-Ambivalent (14.3%): While generally satisfied with their trip, these visitors felt the destination fell short in specific cultural catering, such as culinary variety or language support.
  • Revisit-Ambivalent (17.4%): These travelers are unlikely to return, often viewing the Maldives as a "bucket list" or one-time life event (e.g., a honeymoon) rather than a recurring vacation spot.

Quantitatively, the Maldives is performing well, with 68.3% of the sample falling into the "Loyal" or "Highly Loyal" categories, indicating successful market cultivation to date.

Discussion: Beyond the Resort Bubble

A significant finding was the positive correlation between loyalty and engagement with the local culture. Visitors who included the capital city, Male, in their itinerary showed higher loyalty levels than those who stayed exclusively within isolated resort bubbles. This suggests that exposure to the "vernacular cultural landscape" provides a more resilient visitor experience. Furthermore, loyalty was higher among tourists who were aware of the Maldives' status as an Islamic country, indicating that informed expectations lead to higher satisfaction.

Across all groups, the intention to recommend (4.22/5) was higher than the intention to revisit (4.04/5). For many Chinese travelers, the Maldives is viewed as an aspirational rite of passage, making word-of-mouth advocacy more critical for the Maldives than repeat business.

The Geopolitical Risk: Bilateral Asymmetry

Despite high consumer loyalty, the study warns of bilateral asymmetry. This concept describes a power imbalance where a large state (China) can use outbound tourism as a tool of economic statecraft. The authors cite the 2018 case of Palau, which was "punished" by the Chinese government via travel restrictions for its diplomatic ties to Taiwan. For small states like the Maldives, market diversification into China is a double-edged sword: it provides rapid growth but grants the Chinese state significant geopolitical leverage to "turn off the tap" regardless of individual tourist preferences.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Cultivating the Chinese market has been a successful resilience strategy for the Maldives, but it requires ongoing product development to address the needs of "Cater-Ambivalent" segments. To mitigate the risks of over-reliance on a single dominant market, the researchers suggest the Maldives should look toward India as the next strategic frontier. Future research should also explore the influence of Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) on Chinese social media platforms, which play a pivotal role in shaping destination image and driving the high recommendation intentions observed in this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Market diversification, one critical means by which tourism-dependent small island states can maintain sector resilience and destination life cycle stability, requires understanding of the destination loyalty of strategic new inbound markets such as China. An online survey of 1260 Chinese adults with previous travel experience to the Maldives identified positive proclivities with respect to revisitation and recommendation intentions as well as agreement that Chinese visitors were well catered for. Sample diversity, however, was demonstrated by cluster analysis, which revealed dominant ‘highly loyal’ (31.2%) and ‘loyal’ (37.1%) segments along with specialized clusters ambivalent about the catering (14.3%) or the revisitation intent (17.4%). Loyalty was strongly associated with older, married and higher income visitors who were aware that the Maldives is an Islamic country and who included the capital city of Male in their itinerary. Such information is invaluable for assisting target marketing and product development strategies, but situates in a context of bilateral asymmetry in which the Chinese government can destabilize small island tourism through decisions that curtail visitation by otherwise loyal residents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{weaver2019cultivating,
  author = {David Weaver and Chuanzhong Tang and Laura J. Lawton and Yang Liu},
  title = {{Cultivating the Chinese market through destination loyalty: enhancing resilience in the Maldives}},
  booktitle = {Tourism},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1080/14616688.2019.1623300},
}
Figure