Does China's overseas lending favors One Belt One Road countries?

Yifei Zhang, Heyang FangMunich Personal RePEc Archive (Munich University) 2019

Abstract

The One Belt One Road (OBOR) initiative is found to promote China’s overseas lending in the belt road countries, especially for countries along the continental route. Such effect strengthens and persists for at least three years. Our findings show that launching a national strategy could be a decisive determinant of one country’s outbound loans.

Introduction

In recent decades, China has transitioned from a developing nation into a dominant global creditor. Unlike traditional lending from developed nations, which often seeks higher marginal returns in emerging markets, Chinese overseas lending is frequently characterized by its opacity and the heavy involvement of state-owned entities. This has led to a significant debate: Is China’s outbound lending driven by pure economic logic, or is it a tool of national strategy?

This paper investigates the impact of the "One Belt One Road" (OBOR) initiative, launched in late 2013, on China's lending patterns. By analyzing a comprehensive dataset that accounts for "hidden debts," we provide empirical evidence that OBOR serves as a massive financial catalyst, nearly doubling lending to participating nations.

Methodology and Data

To establish a causal relationship between the OBOR initiative and lending volumes, we employ a Difference-in-Differences (DD) strategy. The study compares a treatment group of 51 countries that joined the initiative against a control group of 54 non-OBOR recipient countries. The "shock" is defined as the late 2013 announcement of the initiative by President Xi Jinping.

The analysis utilizes a sample of 105 recipient countries from 2010 to 2017. A critical component of this research is the use of the Horn et al. (2019) dataset. This dataset is particularly robust as it cross-references debtor reporting systems with Bank for International Settlements (BIS) data to mitigate the "hidden debt" problem—loans that often bypass traditional reporting systems.

To ensure the validity of our findings, we incorporate country and year fixed effects, controlling for variables such as GDP, population, and exchange rates. Furthermore, we implement a time-varying DD model to track the specific year each country signed an OBOR agreement, helping to rule out reverse causality—the possibility that loans were used as an inducement to join rather than a result of joining.

Key Findings

1. The OBOR Catalyst

Our results indicate a significant shift in lending following the initiative's launch. On average, China’s overseas lending to OBOR-participating countries increased by approximately 98%. The "parallel trend test" confirmed that prior to 2013, there were no significant differences in lending trends between the treatment and control groups, suggesting that the OBOR announcement was the primary driver of this change.

2. The Signaling Effect

The data suggests that a national strategy like OBOR acts as a powerful "positive signal" from the central government. This signal encourages state-owned commercial and policy banks to align their lending portfolios with Beijing’s foreign policy objectives. In this context, the strategic alignment of financial institutions may take precedence over traditional profit maximization.

3. Land Over Sea: Geographic Preferences

A distinct preference emerged within the initiative: the "Economic Belt" (land-based routes through Central Asia and Europe) received significantly more lending growth than the "Maritime Silk Road" (sea routes). Specifically, lending to "land belt" countries was roughly 1.3 times higher in the post-strategy years. This disparity likely reflects the capital-intensive nature of land-based infrastructure, such as railways and pipelines, compared to maritime port projects.

4. Persistence of Impact

The "OBOR effect" is not a fleeting spike. Our analysis shows that the increase in lending strengthens and persists for at least three years after a country joins the initiative. This indicates a sustained, long-term commitment to these bilateral economic corridors.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The One Belt One Road initiative has fundamentally reshaped China's overseas lending landscape. By demonstrating a near-doubling of lending to participating nations, this study highlights how national strategy can dictate global financial flows.

While this research establishes a clear causal link regarding lending volume, several areas remain for future investigation. The specific terms of these loans—such as interest rates and collateral—require further scrutiny to determine if OBOR countries receive concessional terms. Additionally, the long-term implications for debt sustainability in recipient countries and the distinct motivations of policy banks versus commercial banks remain critical topics for the ongoing discourse on global finance.

Summary updated

Abstract

The One Belt One Road initiative is found to promote China’s overseas lending in the belt road countries, especially for countries along the continental route. Such effect strengthens and persists for at least three years. Our findings show that launching a national strategy could be a decisive determinant of one country’s outbound loans.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019does,
  author = {Yifei Zhang and Heyang Fang},
  title = {{Does China's overseas lending favors One Belt One Road countries?}},
  booktitle = {Munich Personal RePEc Archive (Munich University)},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure