Does Ad-Free Mean Less Data Collection? An Empirical Study of Platform Data Practices and User Expectations

Sepehr Mousavi, Abhisek Dash, Savvas Zannettou, Krishna P. Gummadi

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether "ad-free" subscription models on major online platforms actually lead to less data collection, as users expect. Their analysis of data exports from Instagram, Facebook, and X reveals that while some ad-related data is removed, platforms still collect data for advertising purposes. This creates a significant gap between user expectations of enhanced privacy and the reality of platform data practices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of "paid" ad-free subscription options on platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and X presents a new paradigm for users. Traditionally, these platforms offer free access in exchange for user data, primarily for targeted advertising. The ad-free model, by definition, removes advertising as a revenue source and, normatively, should reduce the justification for collecting data related to advertising. However, platforms might still collect user data under the guise of improving user experience and personalization. This creates a critical tension: do platforms genuinely reduce data collection when users pay for an ad-free experience, or do they continue to collect data for other purposes, potentially undermining user privacy expectations and GDPR principles like purpose limitation and data minimization? This paper aims to empirically investigate this question.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Platform Data Analysis: They utilized the GDPR's "Right of Access" (Article 15) to obtain Data Download Packages (DDPs) from three major platforms: Instagram, Facebook, and X. They created accounts, used them in the ad-based model, then switched to the ad-free subscription for a month, and finally returned to the ad-based model. DDPs were requested at each stage (initial ad-based, during ad-free, and post-ad-free) to capture data collection differences. They then systematically categorized files within these DDPs into "Ad-only," "Non-ad," and "Mixed" based on their relationship to advertising. A custom browser-based analyzer tool was developed to compare these DDPs and identify differences in file presence, content, and structure.
  2. User Survey: A survey was conducted with 255 participants recruited from Prolific. The survey aimed to understand:
  3. Normative Expectations: What participants believe platforms should do regarding data collection in ad-free models.
  4. Descriptive Expectations: What participants think platforms actually do regarding data collection in ad-free models.
  5. Influence on Choice: Whether continued data collection in ad-free models would affect their decision to subscribe.

Datasets

The primary "datasets" analyzed were the Data Download Packages (DDPs) obtained from Instagram, Facebook, and X. These are not traditional training datasets but rather user data exports provided by the platforms themselves under GDPR regulations. The study also involved a survey dataset of 255 participants from the Prolific platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Ad-Free" Illusion: The core insight is that "ad-free" doesn't necessarily mean "data-free" or even "less data collected for advertising." Platforms are adept at retaining or collecting data that can still be linked to advertising purposes, even when ads are not directly shown.
  • User Skepticism is Justified: Users are not naive. While a majority normatively expect less data collection in ad-free models, a significant portion descriptively believe platforms will continue collecting similar amounts of data, indicating a healthy skepticism towards platform practices.
  • Privacy Expectations vs. Platform Reality: There's a substantial disconnect between what users want (better privacy) and what they get (continued data collection for advertising). This undermines the value proposition of ad-free subscriptions for privacy-conscious users.
  • GDPR Compliance Questions: The findings raise serious questions about whether platforms are truly adhering to GDPR principles like purpose limitation and data minimization when they continue to collect advertising-related data in ad-free models.
  • "Consent or Pay" Model Tensions: This study adds to the ongoing debate around "consent or pay" models, highlighting how the perceived lack of privacy benefits in ad-free tiers could deter users from paying.

Key Results

  • Platform Data Practices:
    • Instagram and Facebook removed a portion of "Ad-only" files (57% and 42% respectively) when switching to ad-free, suggesting some reduction.
  • However, all three platforms (Instagram, Facebook, X) continued to retain or collect "Ad-only" or "Mixed" files that could be used for advertising purposes, even in the ad-free model.
  • For example, X continued to collect data for "lookalike audiences" even when ads weren't being shown.
  • "Non-ad" files were generally unaffected, as expected.
  • User Expectations:
    • Normative: 69% of participants believed platforms should collect less data in ad-free models.
  • Descriptive: Only 17% of participants believed platforms would actually collect less data.
  • Influence on Choice: 34% of participants stated that continued data collection at the same level would deter them from choosing an ad-free plan.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Accounts: The study used only two author-owned accounts per platform, which might not capture the full spectrum of user behaviors or data collection variations.
  • DDP Completeness: The analysis is limited by the information provided in the DDPs, whose completeness cannot be independently verified due to the proprietary nature of platform practices.
  • Platform Scope: While YouTube was analyzed, it was excluded due to insufficient ad-related data in its DDPs, limiting cross-platform comparisons.

Future work could involve analyzing a broader range of platforms and user accounts, exploring more sophisticated methods to infer data usage beyond DDPs, and investigating the specific technical mechanisms that allow for continued ad-related data collection in ad-free models. The authors also suggest a need for clearer regulatory guidance and better coordination between legal, engineering, and product teams within platforms to ensure genuine alignment with user expectations and privacy regulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online platforms increasingly offer "paid" ad-free subscriptions as an alternative to the traditional "free" ad-based model. The transition to ad-free models ostensibly removes advertising as a key justification for data processing under the GDPR. So, normatively, platforms should collect less user data. However, platforms may justify continued data collection as a means to provide an improved, personalized experience. This tension between privacy principles and platform incentives raises a critical underexplored question: do data collection practices vary between ad-free and ad-based subscription models? In this paper, we shed light on this important privacy issue by investigating the alignment between platform data collection practices and related user expectations. With respect to data collection process, our analyses of data exports from three major online platforms - Instagram, Facebook, and X - reveal that these platforms continue to retain or collect some ad-related data, even in ad-free subscriptions. With respect to user expectations, our survey among 255 participants on Prolific reveals that 69% of the participants normatively expect data collection to be reduced, indicating their expectation of improved digital privacy in an ad-free model. However, when asked what they think actually happens, 63% of these participants believed that platforms would still collect about the same amount of data, highlighting skepticism about platform practices. Our findings not only indicate a significant disconnect between data practices and normative user expectations, but also raise serious questions about platform compliance with core GDPR principles, such as purpose limitation, data minimization, and transparency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mousavi2026does,
  author = {Sepehr Mousavi and Abhisek Dash and Savvas Zannettou and Krishna P. Gummadi},
  title = {{Does Ad-Free Mean Less Data Collection? An Empirical Study of Platform Data Practices and User Expectations}},
  booktitle = {The Web Conference},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1145/3774904.3792558},
}

Loading related content...

Figure