Do different methods of specimen extraction in laparoscopic low rectal cancer surgery affect loop ileostomy closure?

Haipeng Chen, Fei Huang, Ming Yang, Zhixun Zhao, Xu Guan, Zheng Liu, Zheng Jiang, Qian Liu, Zhaoxu Zheng, Xishan Wang

Abstract

Introduction: The aim of this study was to compare whether laparoscopic low rectal cancer surgery with three different specimen extraction methods affects loop ileostomy closure. Materials and methods: A consecutive series of patients with low rectal cancer who underwent laparoscopic low anterior resection plus protective loop ileostomy (LAR-PLI) were enrolled. Three main techniques—specimen extraction through auxiliary incision (EXAI), specimen extraction through stoma incision (EXSI), and specimen eversion and extra-abdominal resection (EVER)—were compared regarding postoperative outcomes and impact on loop ileostomy closure. Results: Among 254 patients, the EXAI group (n=104) had significantly longer operative times, more bleeding, and longer hospital stays for both the primary surgery and the subsequent stoma closure compared to the EXSI (n=104) and EVER (n=46) groups. The EXSI group showed the lowest complication rate. Conclusions: While all three techniques are feasible, EXAI offers no advantages in early recovery or stoma closure efficiency compared to EXSI and EVER.

Introduction

Laparoscopic low anterior resection (LAR) combined with a protective loop ileostomy (PLI) is a standard surgical intervention for low rectal cancer, designed to mitigate the risks of anastomotic leakage. A pivotal technical decision in LAR is the method of specimen extraction. Traditionally, an auxiliary abdominal incision (EXAI) is used. However, "incisionless" techniques, such as extraction through the planned stoma site (EXSI) or transanal eversion (EVER), have gained traction for reducing surgical trauma. While the immediate benefits of these techniques are documented, their long-term impact on the mandatory secondary surgery—loop ileostomy closure—remains under-investigated. This study evaluates whether the initial extraction method influences the perioperative outcomes of both the primary resection and the subsequent closure.

Materials and Methods

This retrospective study analyzed 254 consecutive patients who underwent laparoscopic LAR-PLI for low rectal cancer (≤ 7 cm from the anal verge) at the National Cancer Center/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, between 2015 and 2019.

Patients were divided into three cohorts based on the extraction technique:

  1. EXAI (n=104): Specimen removed via a separate 3–5 cm auxiliary incision.
  2. EXSI (n=104): Specimen removed through the site intended for the ileostomy.
  3. EVER (n=46): Specimen everted through the anus for extra-abdominal resection (a form of Natural Orifice Specimen Extraction, or NOSE).
Table 1 (Part 1): Baseline patient characteristics across the EXAI, EXSI, and EVER groups.

Baseline characteristics, including age, BMI, and tumor stage, were largely comparable across groups, ensuring a robust basis for comparison.

Results

Primary Surgery Outcomes

The EXAI group demonstrated significantly inferior perioperative outcomes compared to the EXSI and EVER groups. Specifically, EXAI was associated with:

  • Longer Operative Time: ~217 min vs. ~184 min (EXSI) and ~197 min (EVER) ($P < 0.001$).
  • Increased Blood Loss: Significantly higher intraoperative bleeding ($P < 0.001$).
  • Delayed Recovery: Longer times to first flatus, defecation, and oral intake ($P < 0.001$), leading to extended hospital stays ($P = 0.005$).

Notably, the EXSI group had the lowest primary complication rate (10.6%), compared to 27.9% in EXAI and 26.1% in EVER ($P = 0.005$).

Impact on Loop Ileostomy Closure

The choice of extraction method during the initial surgery significantly affected the difficulty of the stoma closure performed months later. The EXAI group required significantly longer operative times for closure (97.3 min) compared to EXSI (82.1 min) and EVER (83.4 min) ($P = 0.001$). Furthermore, post-closure hospital stays were longer for EXAI patients (7.0 days) than for EXSI (5.8 days) or EVER (6.1 days) ($P < 0.001$).

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that avoiding an auxiliary incision for specimen extraction provides benefits that extend beyond the initial recovery period. The EXSI and EVER techniques not only facilitate faster bowel function recovery and shorter primary hospital stays but also streamline the subsequent stoma closure procedure.

The EXSI technique appears particularly advantageous, offering the lowest complication rates. The higher complication rate in the EVER group may be linked to the more distal location of tumors in that cohort, necessitating lower anastomoses. While this study is limited by its retrospective design, it underscores the clinical value of "incisionless" extraction methods in improving the entire surgical journey for rectal cancer patients. Future prospective trials are warranted to validate these findings and explore long-term functional outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Introduction: The aim of this study was to compare whether laparoscopic low rectal cancer surgery with three different specimen extraction methods affects loop ileostomy closure. Materials and methods A consecutive series of patients with low rectal cancer who underwent laparoscopic low anterior resection plus protective loop ileostomy (LAR-PLI) were enrolled. Three main techniques, namely specimen extraction through auxiliary incision (EXAI), specimen extraction through stoma incision (EXSI), and specimen eversion and extra-abdominal resection (EVER), were employed. The postoperative outcomes of the three techniques and the impact on loop ileostomy closure were compared. Results In all, 254 patients were enrolled in this study: 104 (40.9%) in the EXAI group, 104 (40.9%) in the EXSI group, and 46 (18.1%) in the EVER group. For primary surgery, EXAI group had significantly longer operative time (P &lt; 0.001), more intraoperative bleeding (P &lt; 0.001), longer length of abdominal incision (P༜0.001), longer time to first flatus (P &lt; 0.001), longer time to first defecation (P &lt; 0.001), longer time to first eat (P &lt; 0.001), and longer postoperative hospital stays (P = 0.005) than the EXSI and EVER groups. The primary postoperative complication rate in the EXAI and EVER group was significantly higher than in the EXSI group (P = 0.005). In loop ileostomy closure, EXAI group had significantly longer operative time (P = 0.001), more bleeding volume and longer postoperative hospital stays (P &lt; 0.001) than the EXSI and EVER groups. Conclusions All three techniques of LAR-PLI for low rectal cancer were safe and feasible, but specimen extraction via EXAI had no advantages in terms of early postoperative recovery and loop ileostomy closure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023do,
  author = {Haipeng Chen and Fei Huang and Ming Yang and Zhixun Zhao and Xu Guan and Zheng Liu and Zheng Jiang and Qian Liu and Zhaoxu Zheng and Xishan Wang},
  title = {{Do different methods of specimen extraction in laparoscopic low rectal cancer surgery affect loop ileostomy closure?}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-2204166/v2},
}
Figure