Divisive Faultlines and Knowledge Search in Technological Innovation Network: An Empirical Study of Global Biopharmaceutical Firms

Cheng Long, Meng Wang, Xuming Lou, Zifeng Chen, Yang YangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how "divisive faultlines" – divisions within innovation networks caused by uneven relationship strengths – impact knowledge search in the biopharmaceutical industry. The findings reveal that these faultlines can deepen knowledge exploration but have a more complex, inverted U-shaped effect on the breadth of knowledge sought. Structural holes within the network act as a crucial moderator, amplifying the positive effects on knowledge depth while flattening the inverted U-shape for knowledge breadth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The biopharmaceutical industry is a high-stakes, knowledge-intensive field where innovation is paramount. Firms increasingly rely on collaborative "technological innovation networks" to pool resources and expertise. However, these networks aren't monolithic; they often develop internal divisions or "divisive faultlines" due to varying strengths of relationships between member firms. This unevenness can lead to subgroups forming within the larger network. While it's understood that these faultlines influence network dynamics, their specific impact on how firms search for new knowledge – both in terms of depth (focus) and breadth (diversity) – and how network structures like "structural holes" (gaps between unconnected actors) mediate this relationship, remains underexplored, particularly at the meso-subgroup level. This paper aims to fill this gap by empirically examining these relationships.

Methods

The researchers constructed technological innovation networks based on joint patent applications from global biopharmaceutical firms. They then employed econometric modeling, specifically hierarchical regression analysis, to test their hypotheses. Key to their approach was operationalizing:

  • Divisive Faultlines (DF): Measured by the standard deviation of the strength of relationships within a firm's self-centered network over a five-year window. A higher standard deviation indicates more uneven relationship strengths and thus stronger faultlines.
  • Knowledge Search: Divided into two dimensions:
  • Depth of Knowledge Search (KSD): Measured by the average number of times companies reused knowledge in patent applications within a given year.
  • Breadth of Knowledge Search (KSB): Measured by the number of distinct International Patent Classification (IPC) categories (first four digits) used in a firm's patents within a given year.
  • Structural Holes (SH): Calculated using Burt's constraint index, which measures the degree to which a firm's network is constrained by its connections.
  • Control Variables: Included network size, network density, betweenness centrality, knowledge base, and technological R&D capability to account for other influencing factors.

The study used a lagged approach, with independent and moderating variables from years t-5 to t-1 predicting dependent variables in year t, to account for temporal dynamics.

Datasets

The study utilized patent data from the Derwent Innovations Index database for global biopharmaceutical firms from January 1, 2003, to December 31, 2018. The final sample comprised unbalanced panel data from 509 biopharmaceutical firms, covering 1798 observations. Patent data was chosen for its structured fields, providing quantifiable information on cooperation and innovation activities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Faultlines as a Double-Edged Sword: Divisive faultlines aren't inherently good or bad; their impact depends on the type of knowledge search. They can be beneficial for deepening understanding within existing domains but can hinder broad exploration if too extreme.
  • The Sweet Spot for Breadth: There appears to be an optimal level of divisive faultlines for maximizing the breadth of knowledge search. Too little or too much division can be detrimental.
  • Structural Holes as Connectors: Firms that bridge gaps in the network (occupy structural holes) are better positioned to leverage the positive aspects of faultlines, particularly for deepening knowledge. They act as conduits, facilitating information flow.
  • Flattening the Curve: Structural holes can moderate the inverted U-shaped relationship between faultlines and knowledge breadth, making the overall effect less pronounced. This suggests that while faultlines can create divisions, structural holes can help bridge them, leading to a more stable, albeit potentially less extreme, outcome.

Key Results

  • Depth of Knowledge Search: Divisive faultlines have a significant positive impact on the depth of knowledge search. As faultlines increase, firms tend to focus more intensely on existing knowledge within their subgroups, leading to deeper understanding.
  • Breadth of Knowledge Search: Divisive faultlines exhibit an inverted U-shaped effect on the breadth of knowledge search. Moderate faultlines are associated with a wider search for diverse knowledge, but extremely high faultlines lead to decreased breadth due to increased subgroup isolation and conflict.
  • Moderating Effect of Structural Holes:
    • Structural holes positively moderate the relationship between divisive faultlines and the depth of knowledge search. Firms with more structural holes can better amplify the positive impact of faultlines on knowledge depth.
  • Structural holes negatively moderate the inverted U-shaped relationship between divisive faultlines and the breadth of knowledge search. This means structural holes tend to flatten the curve, reducing the extreme highs and lows associated with faultlines and breadth.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Focus on Patent Data: The study primarily relies on patent data, which largely captures explicit knowledge. Tacit knowledge, crucial for innovation, is not directly measured. Future research could incorporate survey data to capture tacit knowledge.
  • Formation of Faultlines: The paper focuses on the impact of divisive faultlines, assuming their existence. Future work could explore the reasons for their formation, considering firm-level heterogeneity.
  • Tracking Drug Development: While the paper discusses the biopharmaceutical industry, future research could benefit from tracking the development of specific key drugs through patents to gain deeper insights into collaborative research outcomes.

The study's findings offer valuable theoretical and practical implications for biopharmaceutical firms seeking to enhance their knowledge search capabilities and promote sustainable development within complex innovation networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Divisive faultlines caused by the uneven distribution of relationship strength play an essential role in knowledge search in the technological innovation network, which serves as an important requirement for the technological innovation network's macro level to expand to the meso-subgroup level and promote its healthy development. Given that the biopharmaceutical industry, as a high-tech industry, plays a vital role in promoting healthy development, this paper uses the joint patent applications of global biopharmaceutical firms from 2003 to 2018 as a sample to construct a technological innovation network, to explore the relationship between divisive faultlines and knowledge search in the technological innovation network. We also study the moderating effect of structural holes in this relationship. The empirical results show that divisive faultlines significantly affect the depth of knowledge search in the technological innovation network. Divisive faultlines have an inverted U-shaped effect on the breadth of knowledge search in the technological innovation network. Structural holes positively moderate the relationship between divisive faultlines and depth of knowledge search but negatively moderate the inverted U-shaped relationship between divisive faultlines and breadth of knowledge search. This research reveals the relationship between divisive faultlines and the knowledge search in the technological innovation network. The research results provide a theoretical basis and management enlightenment to improve biopharmaceutical firms' knowledge search ability and promote healthy and sustainable development.
BibTeX
@article{long2021divisive,
  author = {Cheng Long and Meng Wang and Xuming Lou and Zifeng Chen and Yang Yang},
  title = {{Divisive Faultlines and Knowledge Search in Technological Innovation Network: An Empirical Study of Global Biopharmaceutical Firms}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18115614},
}
Figure