Abstract
Modelling other agents' behaviors plays an important role in decision models for interactions among multiple agents. To optimise its own decisions, a subject agent needs to model what other agents act simultaneously in an uncertain environment. However, modelling insufficiency occurs when the agents are competitive and the subject agent can not get full knowledge about other agents. Even when the agents are collaborative, they may not share their true behaviors due to their privacy concerns. In this article, we investigate into diversifying behaviors of other agents in the subject agent's decision model prior to their interactions. Starting with prior knowledge about other agents' behaviors, we use a linear reduction technique to extract representative behavioral features from the known behaviors. We subsequently generate their new behaviors by expanding the features and propose two diversity measurements to select top-K behaviors. We demonstrate the performance of the new techniques in two well-studied problem domains. This research will contribute to intelligent systems dealing with unknown unknowns in an open artificial intelligence world.
Introduction
In multi-agent systems (MAS), a "subject agent" must predict the actions of others to optimize its own decision-making. However, agents frequently encounter modeling insufficiency. This occurs when the subject agent's library of hypothesized models for its peers is too narrow, failing to capture their actual behavior. This problem is exacerbated in competitive environments where opponents hide their strategies, or in collaborative settings where privacy concerns prevent agents from sharing their internal logic.
If the "true" behavior of another agent is not represented in the hypothesized set, the subject agent will likely make sub-optimal decisions. While much of the existing literature focuses on compressing model spaces to save on computation, this research addresses the inverse: how to expand and diversify the model space to ensure the true behavior of others is captured.
Methodology: The Diversification Pipeline
The authors propose a three-step pipeline integrated into the Interactive Dynamic Influence Diagram (I-DID) framework to generate and select a diverse set of behavioral models.
1. Eliciting Representative Behaviors
Instead of relying solely on raw prior knowledge, the process treats known behaviors as a matrix. The authors apply linear reduction (Gaussian elimination) to identify "pivot" behavior sequences. These sequences serve as linearly independent "features" that represent the core patterns of known behaviors, effectively stripping away redundant information.
2. Generating New Behaviors
The subject agent’s model of another agent is converted into a Dynamic Bayesian Network (DBN). By instantiating this DBN with the previously extracted features and randomizing initial beliefs, the system samples a large set of new potential "policy trees" (behavior models). This allows the agent to hypothesize a wide range of behaviors that are still grounded in the environment's structural constraints.
3. Top-K Diversity Selection
To maintain computational efficiency, the agent must select only the $K$ most useful models from the generated set. The authors introduce two metrics to measure diversity:
- MDP (Measurement of Diversity over Paths): Measures the differences between individual action sequences (paths) in a vertical sense.
- MDF (Measurement of Diversity with Frames): A more sophisticated metric that evaluates "frames" (sub-trees). This captures behavioral patterns over time in both horizontal and vertical dimensions, accounting for how an agent might react across all possible observations at a given time step.
Experimental Evaluation
The researchers evaluated their approach on two classic multi-agent decision-making benchmarks:
- Multiagent Tiger Problem: A standard benchmark involving high uncertainty where agents must decide whether to open doors or listen for a tiger ($|S|=2$).
- Multiagent UAV Problem: A complex domain where a "chaser" drone attempts to intercept a "fugitive" drone, involving a significantly larger state space ($|S|=81$) and complex interaction dynamics.
Key Insights and Results
The experiments demonstrated that diversifying the model space leads to more robust decision-making:
- Higher Rewards: In both benchmarks, the diversity-based algorithms (IDID-MDP and IDID-MDF) consistently achieved higher average rewards than the standard I-DID approach.
- Superiority of MDF: The IDID-MDF algorithm generally outperformed IDID-MDP, particularly in complex scenarios. This suggests that capturing holistic "behavioral patterns" (frames) is more valuable than simply capturing "action sequences" (paths).
- Reliability: IDID-MDF showed lower variance in performance, indicating it is a more reliable strategy when facing unknown behaviors. The experiments also confirmed a direct positive correlation between the diversity value of the model set and the actual rewards earned by the agent.
Limitations and Future Work
While the diversification approach improves decision quality, it introduces computational overhead. As the number of initial models increases, the time required to generate and solve for $K$ models grows significantly. Furthermore, the current model generates diversity prior to interaction. A major next step for this research is online adaptation—adjusting the diversity of the model set in real-time as the agent receives more data about the true behavior of its peers. Finally, future work will look at better defining "sound" behavior to ensure generated models remain realistic within the context of the environment.
Summary updated