Distributed event-triggered coordination for average consensus on weight-balanced digraphs

Cameron Nowzari, Jorge Cortés

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel distributed algorithm for multi-agent systems to achieve average consensus, meaning all agents agree on the average of their initial states. The key innovation is an "event-triggered" approach that significantly reduces communication and computation by only requiring agents to share information and update their control when necessary, rather than continuously. This makes the system more efficient and practical for real-world applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many multi-agent systems aim for "average consensus," where each agent in a network needs to converge to the average value of all initial states. Existing solutions often rely on agents continuously or periodically exchanging information and updating their control signals. While effective, this constant communication is highly inefficient, leading to excessive energy consumption, bandwidth usage, and processing load. This paper addresses this by developing a distributed strategy that intelligently triggers communication and control updates only when needed, significantly reducing the overhead while still guaranteeing consensus. The challenge is to design these triggers in a way that is provably correct, avoids "Zeno behavior" (infinite events in finite time), and works for a general class of communication networks (weight-balanced directed graphs).

Methods

The core of the paper is the design of a distributed "event-triggered communication and control law." This law dictates when an agent should broadcast its state to its neighbors and update its own control signal. The strategy is based on a Lyapunov-based approach, where a function is defined to measure the "disagreement" among agents. The triggers are designed to ensure this disagreement function monotonically decreases.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Event-Triggered Triggers: Instead of continuous updates, agents evaluate trigger conditions based on their own state and the last known states of their neighbors. If a trigger condition is met, the agent broadcasts its state and updates its control.
  • Lyapunov Function: A candidate Lyapunov function is used to analyze the system's stability and convergence. The triggers are designed to ensure this function decreases over time.
  • Weight-Balanced Digraphs: The algorithm is designed for networks where the communication topology is represented by a directed graph that is "weight-balanced" (in-degree equals out-degree for each node in a specific sense). This is a more general class than undirected graphs.
  • No Zeno Behavior Guarantee: A crucial part of the analysis is proving that the event-triggered nature of the algorithm does not lead to an infinite number of events in any finite time period. This is achieved through a combination of trigger design and a specific additional trigger to handle neighbor updates.
  • Periodic Implementation: The paper also proposes a practical "periodically checked" version where triggers are evaluated at discrete time intervals, further simplifying implementation in real-time systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation-based validation using synthetic network topologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Efficiency through Opportunism: The most significant insight is that intelligent, event-driven communication can achieve the same consensus goals as continuous communication but with vastly reduced overhead. This highlights the potential for significant energy and resource savings in networked systems.
  • Decentralized Decision-Making: The algorithm is fully distributed. Each agent makes its own decisions about when to communicate based on locally available information, without needing global knowledge of the network's parameters or topology.
  • Robustness to Asynchronicity: The event-triggered nature inherently leads to asynchronous communication and control updates among agents. The paper demonstrates that consensus can still be achieved despite this asynchronicity.
  • Zeno Behavior Avoidance is Non-Trivial: Proving the absence of Zeno behavior requires careful design of triggers, especially when considering updates from neighbors. The introduction of a specific "look-ahead" trigger is key to this guarantee.
  • Trade-off in Periodic Implementation: For the periodic version, there's a clear trade-off: a larger sampling period (less frequent checks) leads to less communication but slower convergence, while a smaller period improves convergence speed at the cost of more frequent checks.

Key Results

  • Exponential Convergence: The proposed event-triggered algorithm guarantees that all agents' states exponentially converge to the average of their initial states over weight-balanced, strongly connected digraphs.
  • No Zeno Behavior: The algorithm is proven to avoid Zeno behavior, meaning an infinite number of events will not occur in any finite time period.
  • Periodic Implementation Correctness: A periodic version of the algorithm is shown to achieve exponential convergence under a specific condition on the sampling period, which depends on network parameters like maximum out-degree and maximum edge weights.
  • Simulation Validation: Simulations demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm, showing faster convergence and significantly fewer events compared to a related existing method (Garcia et al., 2013) and a standard periodic consensus algorithm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weight-Balanced Digraphs: The current work is limited to weight-balanced digraphs. Extending the results to more general directed graphs is a natural next step.
  • Single Integrator Dynamics: The analysis is performed for single-integrator systems (ẋ = u). Future work could explore more complex agent dynamics.
  • Ideal Communication: The model assumes ideal communication channels (no delays, no packet loss). Incorporating these real-world imperfections is a significant area for future research.
  • Physical Sources of Error: Investigating scenarios with physical sources of error beyond communication issues is also suggested.
  • Distributed Optimization: Extending the framework to other coordination tasks, such as distributed convex optimization, is a promising direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel distributed event-triggered algorithmic solution to the multi-agent average consensus problem for networks whose communication topology is described by weight-balanced, strongly connected digraphs. The proposed event-triggered communication and control strategy does not rely on individual agents having continuous or periodic access to information about the state of their neighbors. In addition, it does not require the agents to have a priori knowledge of any global parameter to execute the algorithm. We show that, under the proposed law, events cannot be triggered an infinite number of times in any finite period (i.e., no Zeno behavior), and that the resulting network executions provably converge to the average of the initial agents’ states exponentially fast. We also provide weaker conditions on connectivity under which convergence is guaranteed when the communication topology is switching. Finally, we also propose and analyze a periodic implementation of our algorithm where the relevant triggering functions do not need to be evaluated continuously. Simulations illustrate our results and provide comparisons with other existing algorithms.
BibTeX
@article{nowzari2016distributed,
  author = {Cameron Nowzari and Jorge Cortés},
  title = {{Distributed event-triggered coordination for average consensus on weight-balanced digraphs}},
  journal = {Automatica},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1016/j.automatica.2016.01.069},
}
Figure