Circuit mechanisms for chemical modulation of cortex-wide network interactions and exploration behavior

Thomas Pfeffer, Adrián Ponce‐Alvarez, Thomas Meindertsma, Christoffer J. Gahnstrom, Ruud L. van den Brink, Guido Nolte, Konstantinos Tsetsos, Andreas K. Engel, Gustavo Deco, Tobias H. Donner

TL;DR

This study reveals a surprising "double dissociation" in how catecholamines (like dopamine and noradrenaline) and acetylcholine affect brain-wide network activity in humans, depending on whether the brain is at rest or engaged in a task. Using computational modeling, the researchers pinpoint specific circuit mechanisms—changes in local excitation-inhibition balance and intracortical communication—that explain these distinct effects, and link catecholamine-driven changes to increased behavioral exploration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We know that neuromodulatory systems, like those involving catecholamines and acetylcholine, play crucial roles in cognition and behavior. However, influential theories often assign them distinct roles, while experimental evidence at the cellular level has shown similar effects (e.g., increasing neuronal "gain"). This creates a puzzle: if their basic cellular effects are similar, how do they achieve distinct cognitive functions? This paper aims to resolve this by investigating whether their effects diverge at a larger scale – cortex-wide network interactions – and to uncover the underlying circuit mechanisms. Specifically, they question how these systems, originating from the brainstem, can shape large-scale brain dynamics in context-dependent ways, and how these neural effects translate to behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Pharmacological Intervention & MEG: They administered atomoxetine (to boost catecholamines) and donepezil (to boost acetylcholine) to healthy human participants in a double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over design. While participants were under the influence of these drugs, their brain activity was recorded using magnetoencephalography (MEG) during two conditions: a resting state and a visual task.
  • Cortical Circuit Modeling: They developed computational models, starting with a simple two-node Wilson-Cowan model and progressing to a more complex 76-node whole-brain model. These models were used to simulate how changes in key circuit parameters (like background input, gain, and global coupling) could replicate the observed MEG data.
  • Behavioral Experiments: To test predictions from the modeling, they conducted two behavioral tasks: a perceptual task involving ambiguous visual stimuli and a value-based choice foraging task. These tasks were designed to probe behavioral exploration and decision-making.
  • Data Analysis: MEG data was processed to extract power envelope correlations between different brain regions across various frequency bands. Statistical analyses were used to compare drug effects between conditions and to identify significant differences. Behavioral data was analyzed using computational models to quantify parameters like decision noise and exploration.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Human Participants: 28 healthy participants for the MEG experiment and 29 participants for the value-based choice task.
  • MEG Recordings: Collected during rest and a visual task.
  • Behavioral Data: Collected from perceptual and value-based choice tasks.
  • Structural Connectome: Used in the cortex-wide model, estimated from diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) in previous studies.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on re-analyzing existing data and integrating it with novel modeling and experimental paradigms.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Context-Dependent Dissociation: The most striking finding is that catecholamines and acetylcholine have opposite effects on cortex-wide network interactions depending on whether the brain is at rest or engaged in a task. This challenges the notion of simple, context-independent roles for these neuromodulators.
  • Circuit Mechanisms Unveiled: Computational modeling revealed that the observed dissociation can be explained by differential effects on two key circuit properties: catecholamines primarily alter the local excitation-inhibition (E/I) balance, while acetylcholine primarily affects intracortical transmission (global coupling).
  • E/I Balance and Exploration: The model predicted that increased E/I balance (driven by catecholamines) would lead to increased behavioral exploration. This was experimentally confirmed in both perceptual and value-based decision-making tasks.
  • Model-Driven Hypothesis Generation: The study beautifully illustrates how computational modeling can bridge the gap between cellular-level observations and large-scale network dynamics and behavior, generating testable hypotheses.

Key Results

  • Catecholamines: Increased cortex-wide correlations during a visual task, but had no significant effect during rest.
  • Acetylcholine: Decreased cortex-wide correlations during rest, but had no significant effect during the visual task.
  • Modeling: A model with increased E/I balance successfully replicated the catecholaminergic effects, while a model with reduced global coupling and a smaller gain increase replicated the cholinergic effects.
  • Behavior: Atomoxetine (catecholamine boost) led to increased behavioral exploration in both a perceptual task (more alternations in perception) and a value-based choice task (increased decision noise).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The authors acknowledge that their models are simplifications of complex biological systems. For instance, the assumption of global and homogenous changes in background input during the task in the cortex-wide model is an oversimplification.
  • Synaptic Basis of Cholinergic Effects: While the study infers reduced intracortical communication under acetylcholine, the precise synaptic mechanisms remain to be fully elucidated, as there's evidence for acetylcholine also increasing synaptic efficacy in some contexts.
  • Locus of Catecholaminergic Noise: Future work is suggested to further constrain the exact locus of the catecholaminergic boost in internal noise.
  • Biomarker Development: The findings suggest that comparing rest and task states is crucial for understanding neuromodulatory effects, paving the way for developing non-invasive biomarkers for neuromodulatory system integrity in various brain disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Influential accounts postulate distinct roles of the catecholamine and acetylcholine neuromodulatory systems in cognition and behavior. But previous work found similar effects of these modulators on the response properties of individual cortical neurons. Here, we report a double dissociation between catecholamine and acetylcholine effects at the level of cortex-wide network interactions in humans. A pharmacological boost of catecholamine levels increased cortex-wide interactions during a visual task, but not rest. Conversely, an acetylcholine-boost decreased correlations during rest, but not task. Cortical circuit modeling explained this dissociation by differential changes in two circuit properties: the local excitation-inhibition balance (more strongly altered by catecholamines) and intracortical transmission (more strongly reduced by acetylcholine). The inferred catecholaminergic mechanism also predicted increased behavioral exploration, which we confirmed in human behavior during both a perceptual and value-based choice task. In sum, we identified specific circuit mechanisms for shaping cortex-wide network interactions and behavior by key neuromodulatory systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pfeffer2020circuit,
  author = {Thomas Pfeffer and Adrián Ponce‐Alvarez and Thomas Meindertsma and Christoffer J. Gahnstrom and Ruud L. van den Brink and Guido Nolte and Konstantinos Tsetsos and Andreas K. Engel and Gustavo Deco and Tobias H. Donner},
  title = {{Circuit mechanisms for chemical modulation of cortex-wide network interactions and exploration behavior}},
  booktitle = {Bristol},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.25.171199},
}
Figure