Long-Range Order Induced by Dissipation

Johannes Otterbach, Mikhail Lemeshko

Abstract

We propose a technique for engineering momentum-dependent dissipation in Bose-Einstein condensates with non-local interactions. The scheme relies on the use of momentum-dependent dark-states in close analogy to velocity-selective coherent population trapping. During the short-time dissipative dynamics, the system is driven into a particular finite-momentum phonon mode, which in real space corresponds to an ordered structure with non-local density-density correlations. Dissipation-induced ordering can be observed and studied in present-day experiments using cold atoms with dipole-dipole or off-resonant Rydberg interactions. Due to its dissipative nature, the ordering does not require artificial breaking of translational symmetry by an optical lattice or harmonic trap. This opens up a perspective of direct cooling of quantum gases into strongly-interacting phases.

Introduction: Dissipation as a Constructive Force

In the traditional study of quantum systems, dissipation is typically viewed as a detrimental process that destroys coherence and degrades delicate quantum phases. However, recent developments in open quantum systems suggest that dissipation can be engineered to drive a system toward a desired steady state. This paper explores a counter-intuitive application of this principle: using dissipation to create crystalline order in a Bose-Einstein Condensate (BEC).

While crystals in condensed matter typically form to minimize energy under conservative forces, or are artificially imposed in cold atom systems via optical lattices, the authors propose a method where order emerges spontaneously in free space. By filtering the momentum states of a BEC through engineered loss, the system is "cooled" into a long-range ordered structure.

Engineering the Dissipative Filter

The proposed experimental setup utilizes a BEC of atoms, such as Cesium ($^{133}\text{Cs}$), with a specific internal energy structure known as a $\Lambda$-type linkage. This involves two ground states, $|g\rangle$ and $|s\rangle$, coupled to an excited state $|e\rangle$ via laser fields with Rabi frequencies $\Omega_g$ and $\Omega_s$.

Internal level scheme and experimental setup for engineering momentum-dependent dissipation

To introduce the necessary interactions, the atoms are "Rydberg-dressed." By weakly coupling the ground state to a high-lying Rydberg state $|r\rangle$ with a detuning $\Delta_r$, a "soft-core" repulsive interaction is created. This interaction is characterized by a potential $V(r)$ that is nearly constant at short distances and falls off as $1/r^6$ beyond a cutoff radius $R_c$. Crucially, the Fourier transform of this potential, $\tilde{V}(k)$, exhibits a negative component, which leads to a "Roton minimum" in the excitation spectrum—a key precursor to spatial ordering.

The core of the technique is an adaptation of Velocity-Selective Coherent Population Trapping (VSCPT). By carefully choosing the laser parameters, the researchers engineer a momentum-dependent dissipation rate $\Gamma(k)$. In this scheme, atoms in a specific momentum state become "dark" to the light, meaning they cease to absorb or emit photons and are thus protected from decay.

The Mechanism of Spontaneous Ordering

The system's dynamics are governed by the competition between coherent interactions and incoherent dissipation. The engineered dissipation rate $\Gamma(k)$ is designed to have a minimum at the momentum corresponding to the Roton mode. As the system evolves, modes with high dissipation rates are rapidly depleted, while the "dark" phonon mode—the mode with the lowest $\Gamma(k)$—survives.

This process effectively acts as a filter. The system does not settle into a global ground state but is instead driven into a specific collective excitation mode. In real space, this mode corresponds to a periodic modulation of the density, representing a crystalline structure that emerges without the need for an external lattice to break translational symmetry.

Results: Emergence of Spatial Correlations

The researchers used numerical simulations to track the evolution of the pair correlation function $g^{(2)}(r,t)$, which measures the probability of finding two atoms at a distance $r$. Starting from a disordered BEC where $g^{(2)}(r,0) \approx 1$, the function develops pronounced oscillations over time.

Evolution of the pair correlation function g(r,t) at low and high temperatures, showing the emergence of spatial order

As shown in the figures, the peaks in $g^{(2)}(r,t)$ indicate the formation of a structured state with a characteristic spacing of approximately $1.5 R_c$. This ordering is robust across a range of temperatures. At low temperatures ($T \approx 0.1 T_c$), the order emerges directly. At higher temperatures ($T \approx 0.5 T_c$), the system initially exhibits bosonic bunching (a peak at $r=0$) before the dissipative filtering establishes the long-range periodic structure.

Experimental Feasibility and Outlook

The proposed timescales for the emergence of order are on the order of hundreds of microseconds, which is well within the experimental reach of modern Rydberg atom or dipolar gas laboratories. While the system has a finite lifetime due to the inherent atom loss associated with dissipation, there is a significant transient window where the crystalline order is stable and observable.

This work opens new avenues for "dissipative cooling" into strongly interacting phases. Beyond Rydberg atoms, the technique could be generalized to other systems with non-local interactions, such as polar molecules or atoms with large magnetic dipoles, potentially enabling the creation of exotic quantum phases through controlled dissipation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a technique for engineering momentum-dependent dissipation in Bose-Einstein condensates with non-local interactions. The scheme relies on the use of momentum-dependent dark-states in close analogy to velocity-selective coherent population trapping. During the short-time dissipative dynamics, the system is driven into a particular finite-momentum phonon mode, which in real space corresponds to an ordered structure with non-local density-density correlations. Dissipation-induced ordering can be observed and studied in present-day experiments using cold atoms with dipole-dipole or off-resonant Rydberg interactions. Due to its dissipative nature, the ordering does not require artificial breaking of translational symmetry by an opticallattice or harmonic trap. This opens up a perspective of direct cooling of quantum gases into strongly-interacting phases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{otterbach2014long,
  author = {Johannes Otterbach and Mikhail Lemeshko},
  title = {{Long-Range Order Induced by Dissipation}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.113.070401},
}
Figure