Dissecting the phenotypic heterogeneity in sensory features in Autism Spectrum Disorder: a factor mixture modelling approach

Julian Tillmann, Mirko Uljarević, Daisy Crawley, Guillaume Dumas, Eva Loth, Declan Murphy, Jan K. Buitelaar, Tony CharmanResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is characterized by significant phenotypic heterogeneity, particularly in sensory processing. Individuals may exhibit over-sensitivity to noise, under-reactivity to pain, or intense sensory-seeking behaviors. Understanding whether these differences represent distinct categories of individuals or a continuous spectrum of severity is crucial for clinical characterization and personalized intervention. This study employs Factor Mixture Modelling (FMM) to investigate the multidimensional nature of sensory processing in ASD.

Methods

The study analyzed data from 332 children and adults with ASD (ages 6–30, IQ 40–148) from the EU-AIMS Longitudinal European Autism Project (LEAP). Sensory features were assessed using the 38-item Short Sensory Profile (SSP).

Researchers utilized Factor Mixture Modelling (FMM), a hybrid statistical approach that simultaneously models categorical subgroups (latent classes) and continuous variation within those groups (factors). The team first validated the underlying factor structure of the SSP, comparing 5-, 6-, and 7-factor models. They then evaluated latent class models and compared the hybrid FMM against traditional categorical and dimensional models. Finally, they examined the relationship between identified sensory subgroups and clinical variables, including social communication symptoms, restricted and repetitive behaviors (RRBs), adaptive functioning, and symptoms of anxiety and ADHD.

Results

The analysis revealed that a "three-subgroup/seven-factor" FMM provided the best fit for the data, significantly outperforming purely dimensional or categorical models. For instance, the FMM's Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) was over 100 points lower than the best-fitting 7-factor solution alone.

Sensory Subgroups and Severity

The model identified three distinct subgroups based on a severity gradient rather than qualitatively different sensory strategies:

  • Severe (7.1%): Individuals with the highest level of sensory atypicality across all domains.
  • Moderate (15.8%): Individuals with intermediate sensory challenges.
  • Low (77.1%): The largest group, representing those with the least sensory impact.

Notably, even the "Low" group exhibited significantly more sensory atypicalities when compared to typically developing peers, suggesting that sensory features are a pervasive characteristic of the ASD phenotype.

Clinical Associations

Sensory severity was a strong predictor of broader clinical presentation. Participants in the "Severe" subgroup showed large effect size differences ($d > 0.8$) in social communication deficits and ritualistic behaviors compared to the "Low" group, even after controlling for age and IQ. Sensory subgroups were also differentiated by levels of adaptive functioning and symptoms of inattention and anxiety. Notably, a significant quadratic effect was found for anxiety, where scores increased sharply only at the highest levels of sensory impairment.

Discussion

These findings demonstrate that sensory features in ASD are best understood as a hybrid of distinct subgroups and continuous severity gradients. The identification of these subgroups provides a more nuanced map of the autism phenotype, showing that sensory challenges are deeply intertwined with core symptoms and co-occurring conditions like anxiety and ADHD.

Limitations

The study's findings are primarily based on the Short Sensory Profile (SSP), a parent-report measure. While widely used, parent reports can be subjective and the SSP may not fully capture all sensory-seeking behaviors. Additionally, the "Severe" subgroup was relatively small ($n=24$), which may limit the generalizability of findings for the most affected individuals. Future longitudinal research is needed to determine the stability of these sensory subgroups over time.

Conclusion

By identifying three homogeneous sensory subgroups, this research provides a platform for investigating the neurobiological and genetic underpinnings of altered sensory processing. These subgroups offer a more precise map for personalized clinical research and may eventually guide targeted interventions for individuals with ASD.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Heterogeneity in the phenotypic presentation of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is apparent in the profile and the severity of sensory features. Here we applied Factor Mixture Modelling (FMM) to test a multidimensional factor model of sensory processing in ASD. We aimed to identify homogeneous sensory subgroups in ASD that differ intrinsically in their severity along continuous factor scores. We also investigated sensory subgroups in relation to clinical variables: sex, age, IQ, social communication symptoms, restricted and repetitive behaviours, adaptive functioning and symptoms of anxiety and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder. Methods: 332 children and adults with ASD between the ages of 6 and 30 years with IQs varying between 40 and 148 were included. First, three different confirmatory factor models were fit to the 38 items of the Short Sensory Profile (SSP). Then, latent class models (with two-to-six subgroups) were evaluated. The best performing factor model, the 7-factor structure, was subsequently used in two FMMs that varied in the number of subgroups: a two-subgroup, seven-factor model and a three-subgroup, seven-factor model. Results: The ‘three-subgroup/seven-factor’ FMM was superior to all other models based on different fit criteria. Identified subgroups differed in sensory severity from severe, moderate to low. Accounting for the potential confounding effects of age and IQ, participants in these sensory subgroups had different levels of social-communicative symptoms, restricted and repetitive behaviours, adaptive functioning skills and symptoms of inattention and anxiety. Limitations: Results were derived using a single parent-report measure of sensory features, the SSP, which limits the generalisability of findings. Conclusion: Sensory features can be best described by three homogeneous sensory subgroups that differ in sensory severity gradients along seven continuous factor scores. Identified sensory subgroups were further differentiated by the severity of core and co-occurring symptoms, and level of adaptive functioning, providing novel evidence on the associated clinical correlates of sensory subgroups. These sensory subgroups provide a platform to further interrogate the neurobiological and genetic correlates of altered sensory processing in ASD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tillmann2020dissecting,
  author = {Julian Tillmann and Mirko Uljarević and Daisy Crawley and Guillaume Dumas and Eva Loth and Declan Murphy and Jan K. Buitelaar and Tony Charman},
  title = {{Dissecting the phenotypic heterogeneity in sensory features in Autism Spectrum Disorder: a factor mixture modelling approach}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-16052/v2},
}
Figure