Abstract
This paper provides an introduction to recent work on the scaling and intermittency in forced Burgers turbulence. The mapping between Burgers' equation and the problem of a directed polymer in a random medium is used in order to study the fully developed turbulence in the limit of large dimensions. The stirring force corresponds to a quenched (spatio-temporal) random potential for the polymer, correlated on large distances. A replica symmetry breaking solution of the polymer problem provides the full probability distribution of the velocity difference $u(r)$ between points separated by a distance $r$ much smaller than the correlation length of the forcing. This exhibits a very strong intermittency which is related to regions of shock waves, in the fluid, and to the existence of metastable states in the directed polymer problem. We also mention some recent computations on the finite dimensional problem, based on various analytical approaches, as well as a conjecture on the relevance of Burgers equation for the description of the functional renormalisation group flow for the effective pinning potential of a manifold pinned by impurities.
Introduction: The Mystery of Intermittency
The central mystery of "fully developed turbulence" is why simple scaling laws fail. In 1941, Kolmogorov (K41) proposed that fluid velocity fluctuations should scale predictably with distance ($r^{1/3}$). However, real-world fluids exhibit intermittency: rare, intense bursts of activity that deviate from this smooth scaling.
Because the full Navier-Stokes equations are notoriously difficult to solve, physicists look for an "Ising model of turbulence"—a simpler system that still captures these complex statistics. This paper focuses on the forced Burgers equation. While it lacks the incompressibility of real fluids, it serves as a perfect laboratory for studying how nonlinearities and random forcing create "shocks" (discontinuities in velocity) that drive intermittency.
Methods: Mapping Turbulence to Directed Polymers
The paper employs a powerful "dictionary" to translate a fluid dynamics problem into a condensed matter problem through the following steps:
- Hopf-Cole Transformation: This mathematical trick maps the nonlinear Burgers equation onto a linear, Schrödinger-like equation.
- Directed Polymers in Random Media (DPRM): The transformed equation describes the partition function of a polymer string stretched through a landscape of random impurities. The fluid's velocity field is mathematically equivalent to the free energy gradient of this polymer.
- Replica Method & Symmetry Breaking (RSB): To handle the quenched disorder, Mézard uses the replica method from spin glass theory. In the limit of large dimensions ($d \to \infty$), he shows that the system undergoes "Replica Symmetry Breaking," meaning the polymer can be trapped in many competing metastable states.
Key Insights: Shocks as Metastability
The most profound insight is the physical meaning of the mapping. A "shock" in the fluid (where velocity jumps suddenly) corresponds exactly to a point where the directed polymer "jumps" from one metastable state to another in the random landscape.
Mézard demonstrates that a simple random force approximation fails because it cannot decouple small-scale fluctuations from large-scale structures. The success of the RSB method here is linked to the "Gumbel distribution" from extreme value statistics; the physics of the "best" path for a polymer is governed by the same math as the statistics of 100-year floods or record-breaking temperatures.
Key Results and Scaling Laws
The paper provides the full probability distribution function (PDF) for velocity differences $u(r)$ in the large-$d$ limit. It confirms that for distances $r$ much smaller than the forcing scale, the moments of velocity scale as $\langle u^p \rangle \sim r$ for $p > 1$. This is a significant departure from the K41 prediction of $r^{p/3}$.
This "bifractal" scaling spectrum, where exponents are equal to 1 for all $p > 1$, is a hallmark of extreme intermittency. It suggests that the statistics are dominated by the shocks rather than the smooth flow between them. The resulting solution describes a flow organized into "cells" of radial expansion separated by a network of $d-1$ dimensional shock waves.
Limitations and Future Work
While the exact solution holds for infinite dimensions, finite-dimensional cases (like $d=1$ or $d=3$) are more subtle. For instance, in $d=1$, the "right tail" of the probability distribution behaves as $\exp(-u^3)$, a feature not seen in the large-$d$ limit. Furthermore, while decaying turbulence is well-understood, forced turbulence remains a more complex problem for the left tail of the distribution.
The author suggests an exciting future direction: using Burgers-like equations to describe the "flow" of effective potentials in the functional renormalization group, potentially unifying turbulence theory with the physics of pinned manifolds, such as magnetic domain walls.
Summary updated