Disk Wind Feedback from High-mass Protostars. III. Synthetic CO Line Emission

Duo Xu, Jonathan C. Tan, Jan E. Staff, Jon P. Ramsey, Yichen Zhang, Kei Tanaka

Abstract

To test theoretical models of massive star formation it is important to compare their predictions with observed systems. To this end, we conduct CO molecular line radiative transfer post-processing of 3D magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of various stages in the evolutionary sequence of a massive protostellar core, including its infall envelope and disk wind outflow. Synthetic position-position-velocity (PPV) cubes of various transitions of CO, 13CO, and C18O emission are generated. We also carry out simulated Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of this emission. We compare the mass, momentum and kinetic energy estimates obtained from molecular lines to the true values, finding that the mass and momentum estimates can have uncertainties of up to a factor of four. However, the kinetic energy estimated from molecular lines is more significantly underestimated. Additionally, we compare the mass outflow rate and momentum outflow rate obtained from the synthetic spectra with the true values. Finally, we compare the synthetic spectra with real examples of ALMA-observed protostars and determine the best fitting protostellar masses and outflow inclination angles. We then calculate the mass outflow rate and momentum outflow rate for these sources, finding that both rates agree with theoretical protostellar evolutionary tracks.

Introduction

High-mass stars are the primary drivers of galactic evolution, yet their formation remains poorly understood due to the dense, opaque environments in which they are born. One of the most effective ways to study these protostars is through their outflows—powerful jets of gas launched from the accretion disk. Astronomers typically use molecular line emission, particularly from Carbon Monoxide (CO), to estimate the mass, momentum, and energy injected by these outflows into the interstellar medium.

However, a significant gap exists between the physical reality of these outflows and what is captured by radio telescopes. Observational limitations, such as the difficulty in distinguishing slow-moving outflow gas from the surrounding molecular cloud and the "missing flux" problem in interferometric observations, lead to biased estimates. This study addresses these biases by creating "synthetic" observations from 3D magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations and comparing them to "ground truth" data.

Methodology

The research utilizes a multi-stage modeling pipeline to bridge theory and observation. First, 3D MHD simulations were performed using the ZEUS-MP code, following the evolution of a 60-solar-mass core into a protostar ranging from 1 to 24 $M_\odot$ based on the Turbulent Core Accretion (TCA) model.

Next, the RADMC-3D radiative transfer code was used to calculate dust temperatures and simulate the emission of various CO isotopologues ($^{12}$CO, $^{13}$CO, and C$^{18}$O) across multiple rotational transitions. These synthetic images were then processed through the CASA simalma tool to mimic observations from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), accounting for realistic beam sizes, noise, and interferometric filtering.

Evolution of synthetic CO outflow maps as a function of protostellar mass.

Finally, the team compared the properties derived from these synthetic spectra with the true values in the original simulations and performed $\chi^2$ fitting to match the models with real ALMA data from three massive protostellar sources: G35.20-0.74N, G45.47+0.05, and G338.88-1.26.

Key Insights and Results

The comparison between synthetic observations and simulation data revealed several critical insights into the biases of current observational methods.

The "Iceberg" Effect and Energy Underestimation

A major finding is the "Iceberg" effect: a significant portion of the outflow mass (up to 10 times) is hidden at low velocities ($< 3$ km/s), where it becomes indistinguishable from the ambient molecular cloud. While mass and momentum are typically underestimated by a factor of four, kinetic energy is underestimated even more severely. This is because high-velocity gas, which carries the bulk of the kinetic energy ($E_k = 1/2 mv^2$), is often too faint to detect or its velocity is projected away from the observer's line of sight.

Isotopologue Sensitivity and Interferometry Bias

The study highlights that $^{13}$CO is a more reliable tracer than $^{12}$CO. Because $^{12}$CO is often optically thick (opaque), it only reveals the surface of the outflow. In contrast, $^{13}$CO is more optically thin, providing a more accurate probe of the total gas mass. Furthermore, ALMA’s interferometric nature naturally filters out large-scale, smooth emission, leading to a "missing flux" that further suppresses observed mass and momentum by approximately 25%.

Synthetic spectra for various CO isotopologues, showing the effects of protostellar mass and inclination angle.

Correction Factors and Theoretical Validation

To reconcile observations with reality, the authors propose significant correction factors. To find the true mass outflow rate from ALMA CO observations, the observed value should be multiplied by approximately 10. For the momentum outflow rate, the correction factor is roughly 200. Applying these factors to real ALMA sources brought their observed properties into excellent agreement with theoretical protostellar evolutionary tracks.

Conclusion

This work provides a vital link between complex MHD simulations and observational astronomy. By quantifying the inherent biases in molecular line observations, the authors have developed correction factors that allow for a more accurate assessment of high-mass star formation. While the current simulations are idealized and do not account for the clumpy nature of real molecular clouds or foreground contamination, they set the stage for more comprehensive future models. Incorporating full Photo-Dissociation Region (PDR) modeling and varying initial core environments will further refine these essential tools for understanding the birth of the galaxy's most massive stars.

Summary updated

Abstract

To test theoretical models of massive star formation it is important to compare their predictions with observed systems. To this end, we conduct CO molecular line radiative transfer post-processing of 3D magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of various stages in the evolutionary sequence of a massive protostellar core, including its infall envelope and disk wind outflow. Synthetic position-position-velocity (PPV) cubes of various transitions of CO, 13CO, and C18O emission are generated. We also carry out simulated Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of this emission. We compare the mass, momentum and kinetic energy estimates obtained from molecular lines to the true values, finding that the mass and momentum estimates can have uncertainties of up to a factor of four. However, the kinetic energy estimated from molecular lines is more significantly underestimated. Additionally, we compare the mass outflow rate and momentum outflow rate obtained from the synthetic spectra with the true values. Finally, we compare the synthetic spectra with real examples of ALMA-observed protostars and determine the best fitting protostellar masses and outflow inclination angles. We then calculate the mass outflow rate and momentum outflow rate for these sources, finding that both rates agree with theoretical protostellar evolutionary tracks.
BibTeX
@article{xu2024disk,
  author = {Duo Xu and Jonathan C. Tan and Jan E. Staff and Jon P. Ramsey and Yichen Zhang and Kei Tanaka},
  title = {{Disk Wind Feedback from High-mass Protostars. III. Synthetic CO Line Emission}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad3211},
}
Figure