Discrete populations of isotype-switched memory B lymphocytes are maintained in murine spleen and bone marrow

René Riedel, Richard Addo, Marta Ferreira‐Gomes, Gitta Anne Heinz, Frederik Heinrich, Jannis Kummer, Victor Greiff, Daniel Schulz, Cora Klaeden, Rebecca Cornelis, Ulrike Menzel, Stefan Kröger, Ulrik Stervbo, Ralf Köhler, Claudia Haftmann, Silvia Kühnel, Katrin Lehmann, Patrick Maschmeyer, Mairi McGrath, Sandra Naundorf, Stefanie Hahne, Özen Sercan, Francesco Siracusa, Jonathan Stefanowski, Melanie Weber, Kerstin Westendorf, Jakob Zimmermann, Anja E. Hauser, Sai T. Reddy, Pawel Durek, Hyun‐Dong Chang, Mir‐Farzin Mashreghi, Andreas Radbruch

Abstract

At present, it is not clear how memory B lymphocytes are maintained over time, and whether only as circulating cells or also residing in particular tissues. Here we describe distinct populations of isotype-switched memory B lymphocytes (Bsm) of murine spleen and bone marrow, identified according to individual transcriptional signature and B cell receptor repertoire. A population of marginal zone-like cells is located exclusively in the spleen, while a population of quiescent Bsm is found only in the bone marrow. Three further resident populations, present in spleen and bone marrow, represent transitional and follicular B cells and B1 cells, respectively. A population representing 10-20% of spleen and bone marrow memory B cells is the only one qualifying as circulating. In the bone marrow, all cells individually dock onto VCAM1<sup>+</sup> stromal cells and, reminiscent of resident memory T and plasma cells, are void of activation, proliferation and mobility.

Introduction

Immunological memory is the cornerstone of adaptive immunity, allowing for rapid responses upon pathogen re-exposure. While tissue-resident memory T cells and long-lived plasma cells are well-characterized, memory B cells (Bsm) have traditionally been viewed as a uniform, circulating population. This study challenges that paradigm, demonstrating that Bsm are a diverse family of tissue-resident specialists. The majority of Bsm reside permanently in the spleen and bone marrow, where they occupy specialized niches to maintain long-term memory without active circulation.

Methods

Researchers utilized a multi-omic approach to characterize the Bsm landscape in mice:

  • Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq): Transcriptional profiling of individual cells via the 10x Genomics platform to identify unique signatures.
  • BCR Repertoire Analysis: Sequencing of paired heavy and light chains to compare Bsm populations across tissues and determine lineage relationships.
  • Confocal Microscopy: Spatial mapping of Bsm within tissue architecture to identify cellular "neighbors" and physical interactions.
  • Flow Cytometry (FACS): Quantification and sorting based on surface markers such as CD21/35, CD23, and CD49d.
  • Environmental Comparison: Analysis of Bsm in Specific Pathogen-Free (SPF) lab mice versus "pet shop" and feral mice to assess the impact of real-world pathogen exposure on memory storage.

Key Insights and Results

The study identified six distinct clusters of Bsm. Only Cluster III (10-20% of the total) exhibits characteristics of truly circulating cells. The remaining populations are tissue-resident, with unique "homes" in the spleen and bone marrow.

Tissue-Specific Reservoirs

The spleen hosts a unique "marginal zone-like" population (Cluster IV), while the bone marrow (BM) contains a population of highly mutated, deeply quiescent cells (Cluster V). BCR sequencing revealed minimal overlap between spleen and BM Bsm in the same individual, confirming these are distinct, non-mixing compartments rather than a single pool circulating through the blood.

The Bone Marrow Survival Niche

A critical finding is the "docking" mechanism in the bone marrow. Approximately 75% of BM Bsm are in direct contact with VCAM1<sup>+</sup> and fibronectin<sup>+</sup> stromal cells. This physical association suggests a specialized survival niche similar to that of long-lived plasma cells, providing the necessary signals for long-term maintenance.

Docking and surface markers of Bsm. (f) High co-localization of Bsm with VCAM-1 and fibronectin in the bone marrow. (g) Expression of adhesion markers CD29, CD49d, and CD49f on BM vs spleen Bsm.

Quiescence and Longevity

BM Bsm are characterized by deep quiescence; over 95% are in the G0 phase of the cell cycle. They are Ki-67 negative and resistant to cyclophosphamide, a drug targeting proliferating cells. This state of "waiting" is further validated by observations in feral mice, which possess significantly higher numbers of these resident BM Bsm compared to lab mice, reflecting a lifetime of accumulated immunological memory from natural infections.

Quiescence of bone marrow Bsm. Comparison of Ki-67 expression between spleen and bone marrow Bsm shows significantly lower proliferation in the bone marrow.

Discussion and Limitations

This research fundamentally redefines B cell memory as a highly organized, tissue-resident architecture rather than a fluid, purely circulating system. The bone marrow acts as a "high-security vault" for high-affinity, expert memory cells.

However, several questions remain for future study:

  • Functional Reactivation: The specific triggers that cause resident BM Bsm to mobilize and differentiate into plasma cells during a secondary infection are not yet fully understood.
  • Human Translation: While murine models provide a strong foundation, the extent and nature of the human BM Bsm niche require further validation.
  • Niche Competition: It remains unclear if Bsm compete with plasma cells or memory T cells for the same VCAM1<sup>+</sup> stromal docking sites in the bone marrow.

Understanding this architecture is crucial for designing better vaccines and understanding why some immune responses last decades while others fade.

Summary updated

Abstract

At present, it is not clear how memory B lymphocytes are maintained over time, and whether only as circulating cells or also residing in particular tissues. Here we describe distinct populations of isotype-switched memory B lymphocytes (Bsm) of murine spleen and bone marrow, identified according to individual transcriptional signature and B cell receptor repertoire. A population of marginal zone-like cells is located exclusively in the spleen, while a population of quiescent Bsm is found only in the bone marrow. Three further resident populations, present in spleen and bone marrow, represent transitional and follicular B cells and B1 cells, respectively. A population representing 10-20% of spleen and bone marrow memory B cells is the only one qualifying as circulating. In the bone marrow, all cells individually dock onto VCAM1<sup>+</sup> stromal cells and, reminiscent of resident memory T and plasma cells, are void of activation, proliferation and mobility.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{riedel2020discrete,
  author = {René Riedel and Richard Addo and Marta Ferreira‐Gomes and Gitta Anne Heinz and Frederik Heinrich and Jannis Kummer and Victor Greiff and Daniel Schulz and Cora Klaeden and Rebecca Cornelis and Ulrike Menzel and Stefan Kröger and Ulrik Stervbo and Ralf Köhler and Claudia Haftmann and Silvia Kühnel and Katrin Lehmann and Patrick Maschmeyer and Mairi McGrath and Sandra Naundorf and Stefanie Hahne and Özen Sercan and Francesco Siracusa and Jonathan Stefanowski and Melanie Weber and Kerstin Westendorf and Jakob Zimmermann and Anja E. Hauser and Sai T. Reddy and Pawel Durek and Hyun‐Dong Chang and Mir‐Farzin Mashreghi and Andreas Radbruch},
  title = {{Discrete populations of isotype-switched memory B lymphocytes are maintained in murine spleen and bone marrow}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-16464-6},
}
Figure