TL;DR
This paper introduces two Nanopore MinION sequencing strategies—direct metatranscriptome RNA-seq and multiplex RT-PCR amplicon sequencing—for simultaneously identifying multiple viable foodborne pathogens. Both methods offer comparable accuracy and speed, with RT-PCR amplicons showing higher sensitivity and metatranscriptome sequencing excelling in read length and handling complex samples.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Ensuring food safety is a critical public health concern, with bacterial infections causing significant economic losses and health impacts. A major challenge in food safety is the accurate and rapid identification of viable pathogens, especially when multiple threats are present simultaneously. Traditional methods often struggle to distinguish between live and dead bacteria, leading to false positives. Furthermore, existing multiplex detection systems typically require custom assay development for each target pathogen, making them costly and time-consuming to adapt to the ever-changing landscape of foodborne threats. This paper aims to address this gap by developing and evaluating novel, adaptable, and sensitive methods for multiplex identification of viable pathogens in food.
Methods
The study focuses on two primary Nanopore MinION sequencing approaches:
- Direct Metatranscriptome RNA-seq: This method involves extracting total RNA directly from the sample, followed by library preparation and sequencing. The key innovation here is an optimized, universal RNA extraction and DNA digestion protocol designed to work for both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, simplifying the process. This approach leverages the fact that RNA, particularly mRNA, has a shorter half-life than DNA, making it a better indicator of active metabolism and thus viability.
- Multiplex RT-PCR Amplicon Sequencing: This strategy first uses multiplex reverse transcription PCR (RT-PCR) to amplify specific target genes from the RNA. The resulting amplicons are then prepared for library construction and sequenced. This method aims to increase sensitivity by focusing on amplified target regions.
Both methods were applied to a cocktail of three common foodborne pathogens: Escherichia coli O157:H7, Salmonella enteritidis, and Listeria monocytogenes. The study also involved comparing different bioinformatic pipelines (MEGAN, EPI2ME, MG-RAST) for analyzing the sequencing data and validating the results using Sanger sequencing and selective media.
Datasets
The study utilized a cocktail culture of three specific bacterial strains:
- Escherichia coli O157:H7 (ATCC 43895)
- Salmonella enteritidis (ATCC 13076)
- Listeria monocytogenes (ATCC 19115)
These bacteria were cultured in two different media:
- Brain Heart Infusion (BHI) broth
- Lettuce juice extract (LJE) as a food model
The study also used a negative control consisting of inactivated bacteria treated with sodium hypochlorite to assess the methods' ability to eliminate false positives from dead cells or DNA contamination. For comparative analysis, data from an Illumina iSeq 100 sequencing system was also used as a control.
Key Insights and Ideas
- RNA as a Viability Indicator: The study strongly reinforces the idea that mRNA (and by extension, total RNA) is a more reliable indicator of bacterial viability than DNA. DNA from dead cells can persist in food samples, leading to false positives with DNA-based detection methods. RNA's transient nature makes it a better marker for active metabolism.
- Universal Protocol for Diverse Bacteria: The development of an optimized, universal RNA extraction and library preparation protocol is a significant step towards a standardized approach for detecting a broad range of pathogens, regardless of their Gram stain.
- Nanopore's Versatility: The Nanopore MinION platform proves capable of handling both direct metatranscriptome RNA-seq and RT-PCR amplicon sequencing, showcasing its flexibility for different food safety applications.
- Bioinformatics is Crucial: The choice of bioinformatic pipeline significantly impacts the accuracy of pathogen identification. Removing rRNA mapping in MEGAN, for instance, dramatically improved the accuracy of metatranscriptomic analysis.
Key Results
- Accurate Multiplex Identification: Both direct metatranscriptome RNA-seq and multiplex RT-PCR amplicon sequencing successfully identified the three target pathogens in a mixed culture.
- Bioinformatic Pipeline Performance: MEGAN, when configured to exclude rRNA mapping, achieved the highest accuracy for metatranscriptomic data. EPI2ME demonstrated high accuracy for multiplex RT-PCR amplicon sequencing.
- Comparable Accuracy and Time: Both Nanopore sequencing strategies were found to be comparable in terms of accuracy and total turnaround time (approximately 6-7 hours from sample to result).
- Sensitivity vs. Read Length: Multiplex RT-PCR amplicon sequencing offered higher sensitivity, making it potentially better for samples with low bacterial loads. Direct metatranscriptome RNA-seq, however, excelled in providing longer read lengths, which can be advantageous for comprehensive transcriptome analysis and for dealing with complex microbial communities and non-bacterial RNA backgrounds.
- Elimination of False Positives: Negative controls with inactivated bacteria confirmed that both Nanopore methods effectively eliminated false positive identifications that could arise from DNA contamination.
Limitations and Future Work
- RNA Loss in Library Prep: A significant limitation noted for direct metatranscriptome RNA-seq is the substantial RNA loss observed during library preparation, which can reduce assay sensitivity. The authors suggest redesigning the library preparation protocol to minimize this loss.
- Primer Design for RT-PCR: Multiplex RT-PCR amplicon sequencing requires complex primer design and validation, and potential issues like primer interaction, non-specific amplification, and amplification bias need to be addressed.
- Database Completeness: The accuracy of bioinformatic analysis relies heavily on comprehensive databases. Further development in this area is needed.
- Cross-Domain Identification: For metatranscriptome sequencing, future work should focus on optimizing pipelines for identifying prokaryotes, eukaryotes, and viruses simultaneously, especially in complex sample matrices.
- Clinical Applications: The authors suggest that the information gained from this study could be valuable for future research in areas like predicting antibiotic resistance, elucidating host-pathogen interactions, and investigating microbial ecology.
Summary updated