TL;DR
The BABAR experiment has measured branching fractions and asymmetries in the rare decays of B mesons into a kaon (or K*) and a lepton-lepton pair. While direct CP violation and lepton flavor asymmetries align with Standard Model predictions, unexpectedly large isospin asymmetries were observed in the low dilepton mass region, deviating from theoretical expectations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics describes fundamental particles and their interactions. However, there are phenomena not fully explained by the SM, hinting at the existence of new physics. Rare B meson decays, such as $B \to K^{(*)}l^+l^-$ (where $l$ is an electron or muon), are particularly sensitive probes for new physics. These decays are suppressed in the SM, occurring through loop diagrams involving virtual particles. Deviations from SM predictions in the rates or asymmetries of these decays could signal the presence of new, heavier particles or forces. This paper aims to precisely measure these decay properties to test the SM and search for such deviations, focusing on direct CP violation, lepton flavor universality, and isospin asymmetries.
Methods
The BABAR experiment utilized a large dataset of 384 million $B\bar{B}$ events collected at the PEP-II $e^+e^-$ collider. The analysis involved reconstructing various final states of the $B \to K^{(*)}l^+l^-$ decays, distinguishing between electron-positron ($e^+e^-$) and muon-antimuon ($\mu^+\mu^-$) pairs.
Key techniques employed include:
- Maximum Likelihood Fits: Unbinned maximum likelihood fits were used to extract signal and background yields from the $m_{ES}$ (energy distribution) distributions.
- Neural Networks (NNs): NNs were crucial for suppressing backgrounds, particularly from continuum and misidentified hadrons.
- Kinematic Variables: The $m_{ES}$ and $\Delta E$ variables were used to identify signal events.
- Isospin Asymmetry Calculation: The isospin asymmetry ($A_{K^{(*)}}$) was calculated by comparing the rates of neutral ($B^0$) and charged ($B^+$) B meson decays, taking into account their different lifetimes.
- Systematic Uncertainty Estimation: Extensive checks were performed to quantify systematic uncertainties, including variations in background parameterizations, NN selections, and efficiency measurements.
Datasets
The primary dataset used is the 384 million $B\bar{B}$ events collected by the BABAR detector at the PEP-II $e^+e^-$ collider. Simulated datasets were used for background characterization and efficiency estimations. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- SM Consistency for CP Violation and Lepton Flavor: The measurements of direct CP asymmetries and the ratio of branching fractions for muon and electron final states ($R_K^{(*)}$) are in excellent agreement with SM predictions. This suggests that the dominant contributions to these decays are well-understood within the SM framework.
- Unexpected Isospin Asymmetries: The most striking finding is the observation of significant negative isospin asymmetries in the low dilepton mass squared ($q^2$) region for both $B \to Kl^+l^-$ and $B \to K^*l^+l^-$ decays. These asymmetries are about 3.2$\sigma$ and 2.7$\sigma$ away from the SM expectation, respectively.
- Sensitivity of Rare Decays: This study highlights the power of rare B meson decays as probes for new physics. While some aspects align with the SM, the observed deviations in isospin asymmetry could point towards new physics contributions that are not dominant in other observables.
Key Results
- Branching Fractions: The total branching fractions for $B \to Kl^+l^-$ and $B \to K^*l^+l^-$ were measured to be $(0.394 \pm 0.073 \pm 0.020) \times 10^{-6}$ and $(1.11 \pm 0.18 \pm 0.07) \times 10^{-6}$, respectively. These results are consistent with previous measurements and SM predictions.
- Direct CP Asymmetries ($A_{CP}$): No evidence for direct CP violation was found, with results consistent with the SM expectation of negligible asymmetry.
- Lepton Flavor Asymmetries ($R_K^{(*)}$): The ratios of branching fractions for muon and electron final states ($R_K$ and $R_{K^*}$) were found to be consistent with the SM prediction of unity.
- Isospin Asymmetries ($A_{K^{(*)}}$):
- In the high and combined $q^2$ regions, the isospin asymmetries were consistent with zero.
- In the low $q^2$ region, a significant negative asymmetry was observed: $A_K = -0.64 \pm 0.15 \pm 0.03$ (3.9$\sigma$ difference from zero) and a similar trend for $A_{K^*}$.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistical Significance: While the isospin asymmetry results show a significant deviation from the SM, the authors acknowledge that the statistical significance (3.9$\sigma$ combined) is not at the discovery threshold.
- Systematic Uncertainties: Although efforts were made to control systematic uncertainties, they still contribute to the overall error and are crucial for interpreting the significance of the observed deviations.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that further studies with larger datasets or improved theoretical calculations are needed to confirm or refute these intriguing isospin asymmetry results. The authors also point out that these deviations could be a sign of new physics beyond the Standard Model, particularly in models with extended Higgs sectors or supersymmetry. The observed large negative isospin asymmetry is particularly unexpected in the SM, which predicts a small positive asymmetry in this region.
Summary updated