Dileptons from disoriented chiral condensates

Yuval Kluger, Volker Koch, J. Randrup, Xin-Nian Wang

Abstract: Disoriented chiral condensates (DCCs) or long-wavelength pionic oscillations and their interaction with the thermal environment can be a significant source of dileptons. We calculate the yield of such dilepton production within the linear $\sigma$ model, both in a quantum mean-field treatment and in a semiclassical approximation. We then illustrate the basic features of the dilepton spectrum in a schematic model. We find that dilepton yield with invariant mass near and below $2m_\pi$ due to the soft pion modes can be up to two orders of magnitude larger than the corresponding equilibrium yield.

Introduction: Probing Chiral Symmetry Restoration

In the extreme conditions of relativistic heavy-ion collisions, physicists aim to recreate the Quark-Gluon Plasma and observe the restoration of chiral symmetry—a state where the masses of quarks effectively vanish. As the system cools, it transitions back to a state of broken symmetry.

The "Baked Alaska" scenario suggests that during this cooling, certain regions of space might relax into a "misaligned" vacuum known as a Disoriented Chiral Condensate (DCC). In a DCC, the vacuum "points" in a pionic direction rather than the standard sigma direction. Detecting these regions is notoriously difficult because pions interact strongly and are easily obscured by the "noise" of the collision. This paper investigates whether dileptons (electron-positron pairs), which only interact electromagnetically, can serve as a cleaner "smoking gun" for DCC formation.

Theoretical Framework: The Linear Sigma Model

The authors employ the Linear Sigma Model, a standard theoretical framework for studying chiral symmetry, using three distinct computational approaches to ensure robust results:

  1. Quantal Mean-Field Treatment: A quantum mechanical approach accounting for Bose-Einstein statistics and medium-modified pion modes.
  2. Semi-Classical Approximation: A Vlasov-like treatment where the system is evolved using classical equations of motion to verify sensitivity to quantum approximations.
  3. Schematic Model: A simplified model incorporating Bjorken expansion to isolate how "soft" (low-momentum) DCC pions interact with the "hard" (high-momentum) thermal environment.

Key Insights: The $2m_\pi$ Threshold

Previous studies focused on "coherent" emission—dileptons coming directly from the oscillating DCC field. This paper finds that incoherent production (thermal pions annihilating with DCC pions) is a far more significant source.

The most striking feature is a sharp enhancement in the dilepton spectrum at an invariant mass ($M$) near $2m_\pi$ (approximately 270–300 MeV). This occurs because the DCC provides a large "reservoir" of low-momentum pions ready to annihilate. Additionally, the non-linear nature of the sigma model causes parametric resonances that contribute to "pion bremsstrahlung," further enriching the spectrum at low invariant masses.

Main Findings: Massive Yield Enhancement

The primary result of the study is the dramatic enhancement of the dilepton yield in the presence of a DCC. As shown in the figure below, the "quench" scenario—representing the rapid cooling and formation of a DCC—produces a signal significantly stronger than the standard thermal equilibrium background.

Dilepton yield enhancement in a quench scenario compared to thermal equilibrium.

In the quench scenario, the dilepton yield is 20 to 100 times larger than the equilibrium thermal yield near the $2m_\pi$ threshold. The enhancement is strongest for "slow-moving" dileptons (transverse momentum $q$ below 300 MeV), which helps distinguish the signal from standard thermal backgrounds. Both the quantal and semi-classical methods predict the same qualitative enhancement, though the quantal method yields a higher peak due to Bose enhancement factors.

Conclusion and Experimental Outlook

While the predicted signal is strong, the authors acknowledge significant experimental challenges. The signal at very low masses ($M < m_\pi$) may be buried under the background of $\pi^0$ Dalitz decays. Furthermore, detector simulations suggest that the signal might be "washed out" unless the apparatus can resolve very low-momentum pairs (down to $\sim 100$ MeV). Future work will need to integrate 3D hydrodynamics and include interactions with vector mesons (like the $\rho$ or $\omega$) to further refine the predicted dilepton signature near the chiral phase transition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Disoriented chiral condensates or long wavelength pionic oscillations and their interaction with the thermal environment can be a significant source of dileptons. We calculate the yield of such dilepton production within the linear \ensuremath{\sigma} model, both in a quantum mean-field treatment and in a semiclassical approximation. We then illustrate the basic features of the dilepton spectrum in a schematic model. We find that dilepton yield with invariant mass near and below ${2m}_{\ensuremath{\pi}}$ due to the soft pion modes can be up to two orders of magnitude larger than the corresponding equilibrium yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kluger1998dileptons,
  author = {Yuval Kluger and Volker Koch and J. Randrup and Xin-Nian Wang},
  title = {{Dileptons from disoriented chiral condensates}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevc.57.280},
}
Figure