Digital simulation of zero-temperature spontaneous symmetry breaking in a superconducting lattice processor

Chang-Kang Hu, Gaogang Xie, Kasper Poulsen, Yuxuan Zhou, Chu Ji, C. L. Liu, Rui Zhou, Haolan Yuan, Yuecheng Shen, Song Liu, N. T. Zinner, Dian Tan, Alan C. Santos, Dapeng Yu

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully simulated zero-temperature spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) using a 7-qubit superconducting processor arranged in a unique "Cayley tree" topology. By employing digitized adiabatic evolution, the team demonstrated the emergence of entangled magnetic phases using only the simplest possible interactions (nearest-neighbor), providing a new blueprint for studying complex condensed matter physics on near-term quantum hardware.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking (SSB) is a cornerstone of modern physics, explaining everything from why magnets work to how particles acquire mass via the Higgs mechanism. However, studying SSB in low-dimensional systems (like 1D or 2D lattices) is notoriously difficult.

According to the Mermin-Wagner theorem, long-range order in these systems is generally forbidden at finite temperatures unless the particles interact over long distances. While this restriction doesn't strictly apply at absolute zero, reaching "true" zero temperature is physically impossible for analog systems due to the third law of thermodynamics. This creates a gap: how can we experimentally study the pure, zero-temperature quantum dynamics of symmetry breaking without the "noise" of thermal fluctuations or the complexity of long-range interactions?

Methods

The authors tackle this using a Digitized Adiabatic Evolution (DAE) approach on a superconducting quantum processor.

  1. The Hardware: They used a 3D "flip-chip" processor featuring 7 qubits arranged in a Cayley tree—a branching structure where each "generation" of qubits connects to the next. This specific topology is key because it allows for complex phase transitions even with minimal connectivity.
  2. The Algorithm: Instead of a continuous analog sweep, they broke the evolution into discrete "blocks" using a first-order Suzuki-Trotter decomposition. They developed a new Digitized Adiabatic Theorem (ST-DAT) to calculate the minimum number of blocks ($M$) required to maintain high fidelity based on the system's energy gap.
  3. Optimization: To speed up the simulation and avoid errors, they used "Quantum Adiabatic Brachistochrone" functions—essentially finding the "fastest path" to evolve the system's state without leaving the ground state.
  4. Entanglement Witness: To prove the resulting phases were truly quantum, they measured the second-order Rényi entropy using randomized measurements. This acted as a "witness" to confirm the presence of genuine entanglement between different parts of the lattice.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the primary "dataset" consists of the raw measurement outcomes from the 7-qubit superconducting processor.

  • Experimental Data: Correlation functions and entropy measurements across various steps ($n=0$ to $n=5$) of the digital circuit.
  • Numerical Benchmarks: The researchers performed classical simulations of 7-qubit and 15-qubit systems to validate their experimental results and test the scalability of their "Digitized Adiabatic Theorem."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topology as a Shortcut: The Cayley tree structure is a "sweet spot" for quantum simulation. It is technically two-dimensional but has far fewer interactions than a standard square lattice, allowing the researchers to observe SSB with a very low "gate depth" (fewer operations).
  • Zero-Temp Mimicry: By using a digital gate-based approach, the researchers could simulate a cooling regime that is physically unattainable for analog quantum computers. They essentially "programmed" the zero-temperature environment.
  • Nearest-Neighbor Sufficiency: One of the most surprising findings was that SSB-induced transitions from classical antiferromagnetic (AFM) states to quantum ferromagnetic (FM) states occurred using only nearest-neighbor interactions. This is the shortest range of interaction possible, proving that complex magnetic orders don't always require long-range "spooky action."
  • Resilience to Noise: Even with current-generation hardware (which suffers from gate errors), the signature of the phase transition was visible after just two blocks of the digital circuit, showing the robustness of the adiabatic approach.

Key Results

  • Phase Formation: The team successfully observed the formation of both AFM and FM phases, evidenced by a "connected correlation function" that mapped the relationship between spins across the tree.
  • High Fidelity: Despite the presence of noise, the experimental similarity to theoretical ideals reached approximately 80% at the end of the evolution, with some intermediate steps hitting 90%.
  • Entanglement Confirmed: The Rényi entropy measurements showed a clear increase in quantum correlations, confirming that the observed magnetic order was a result of quantum entanglement rather than classical alignment.
  • Scalability: Numerical simulations showed that a 15-qubit system could be simulated with even fewer blocks than the 7-qubit system, suggesting the method remains efficient as the "computer" gets larger.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation acknowledged is gate fidelity. While 80% accuracy is impressive for a 7-qubit system, the accumulating errors from single and two-qubit gates will become a significant hurdle as they scale to larger, more complex lattices (like 2D square or zigzag lattices).

The authors suggest that the next steps involve:

  1. Error Mitigation: Applying advanced techniques to "clean" the noisy data from the gates.
  2. Complex Geometries: Moving beyond the Cayley tree to simulate more traditional condensed matter structures.
  3. Digital Quantum Annealing: Using this framework as a general-purpose optimizer for complex problems that can be mapped onto spin Hamiltonians.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum simulators are ideal platforms to investigate quantum phenomena that are inaccessible through conventional means, such as the limited resources of classical computers to address large quantum systems or due to constraints imposed by fundamental laws of nature. Here, through a digitized adiabatic evolution, we report an experimental simulation of antiferromagnetic (AFM) and ferromagnetic (FM) phase formation induced by spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) in a three-generation Cayley tree-like superconducting lattice. We develop a digital quantum annealing algorithm to mimic the system dynamics, and observe the emergence of signatures of SSB-induced phase transition through a connected correlation function. We demonstrate that the signature of phase transition from classical AFM to quantum FM happens in systems undergoing zero-temperature adiabatic evolution with only nearest-neighbor interacting systems, the shortest range of interaction possible. By harnessing properties of the bipartite Renyi entropy as an entanglement witness, we observe the formation of entangled quantum FM and AFM phases. Our results open perspectives for new advances in condensed matter physics and digitized quantum annealing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2025digital,
  author = {Chang-Kang Hu and Gaogang Xie and Kasper Poulsen and Yuxuan Zhou and Chu Ji and C. L. Liu and Rui Zhou and Haolan Yuan and Yuecheng Shen and Song Liu and N. T. Zinner and Dian Tan and Alan C. Santos and Dapeng Yu},
  title = {{Digital simulation of zero-temperature spontaneous symmetry breaking in a superconducting lattice processor}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-57812-8},
}
Figure