Introduction
In classical Law and Economics, legal rules are typically viewed as opportunity structures. Under this framework, rational agents are expected to exploit new, profitable legal remedies as soon as they become available. However, empirical evidence often suggests a different reality: new legal innovations frequently undergo an "incubation period," sitting underutilized for years before gaining widespread popularity. This paper investigates the mechanisms behind this delay, using the introduction of class actions in Israel as a primary case study. The central question is whether the diffusion of legal innovation is driven by rational Bayesian updating—where lawyers wait for more data on profitability—or by social influence and peer imitation.
Methodology and Data
The researchers approached the legal market through the lens of diffusion models commonly used in marketing and sociology. To isolate the drivers of adoption, they analyzed two distinct dependent variables:
- Market Entry: Defined as the day a law firm files its first class action.
- Market Participation: Defined as any subsequent filings by the same firm.
The study employed linear probability models with law firm fixed effects to distinguish between social factors (market-wide behavior) and individual factors (a firm's own history). A critical distinction was made between "success" (the binary outcome of receiving a fee) and "profitability" (the actual magnitude of the fee awarded).
The analysis is based on a comprehensive, hand-coded dataset of 2,057 class action suits filed in Israel between April 2006 and August 2012. This dataset includes 470 unique law firms and tracks over 200 variables per case, including motions and hearing protocols, providing a granular view of the litigation lifecycle beyond final rulings.
Key Findings: The Legal S-Curve
The study found that legal innovations diffuse in a manner strikingly similar to new technologies, following a classic "S-curve." In the Israeli context, the adoption of class actions started slowly with a small group of "innovators." A significant tipping point occurred approximately 1,000 days after the law's passage, after which filings grew exponentially, reaching over 1,200 lawsuits per year by 2012.
Social vs. Individual Learning
The drivers of adoption differ based on a firm's experience level:
- First-time Entrants: The decision to enter the market is primarily driven by social signals. Firms monitor the total number of cases filed by others and the overall success rate of those cases.
- Repeat Players: Once a firm has entered the market, its subsequent participation is influenced by both social signals and its own internal track record. A firm that experiences success in its initial filing is significantly more likely to continue participating in the market.
The Power of the Binary Signal
Interestingly, the research suggests that law firms are more responsive to the rate of success (whether a fee was awarded at all) than to the magnitude of success (the size of the fee). As the market matured, this success rate stabilized at approximately 30%. When controlling for the success rate, the mean fee size sometimes showed a negative correlation with market entry. This suggests that firms prioritize the binary "win/loss" signal, which may be easier to observe and interpret than complex profit calculations.
Discussion: Imitation and Firm Dynamics
The authors highlight the role of "herding" or imitation. Because many firms entered the market before a significant number of cases had reached final adjudication, they were likely mimicking the filing behavior of their peers under the assumption that those peers had conducted sufficient due diligence.
Furthermore, the data reveals that small firms are the primary drivers of this innovation. Approximately 64.8% of class actions were filed by single-lawyer offices, suggesting that smaller, more agile firms are better positioned to act as innovators in new legal niches compared to larger, more risk-averse institutions.
Conclusion
The diffusion of the 2006 Israeli class action law demonstrates that "law on the books" does not immediately translate into "law in practice." Instead, legal remedies spread through a social process of imitation and learning. For legislators and policy-makers, this implies that the effectiveness of a new law cannot be judged immediately upon its enactment; rather, its impact will depend on the social dynamics and information signals within the legal profession. Future research may explore whether these patterns hold across different legal cultures or substantive areas of law, and identify the factors that eventually lead to market saturation.
Summary updated