Differential diagnosis of lung carcinoma with three-dimensional quantitative molecular vibrational imaging

Liang Gao, Ahmad A. Hammoudi, Fuhai Li, Michael J. Thrall, Philip T. Cagle, Yuanxin Chen, Jian Yang, Xiaofeng Xia, Yubo Fan, Yehia Massoud, Zhiyong Wang, Stephen T.c. WongJournal of Biomedical Optics 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel 3D imaging and analysis framework using Coherent Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering (CARS) microscopy to differentiate between lung carcinoma cell types. By moving beyond traditional 2D analysis to a 3D approach, they achieve over 97% accuracy in classifying non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) subtypes, offering a faster, label-free diagnostic tool that preserves tissue for further molecular testing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lung carcinoma is a leading cause of cancer death worldwide. Accurate classification of non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) subtypes is crucial for effective treatment, particularly with the rise of targeted therapies that rely on specific molecular markers. Current diagnostic methods, primarily relying on 2D histology (H&E staining) and sometimes immunohistochemistry, are time-consuming, require tissue processing, and can be insufficient for differentiating between NSCLC subtypes, especially in challenging cases. This often leads to insufficient tissue samples for subsequent molecular analysis, hindering personalized treatment. The paper addresses the need for a rapid, label-free, and minimally invasive diagnostic method that can accurately distinguish NSCLC cell types while preserving tissue integrity.

Methods

The core of this work is a 3D imaging and analysis pipeline built upon CARS microscopy. Here's a breakdown of the key components:

  • CARS Microscopy: This label-free technique uses intrinsic molecular vibrations to generate contrast, allowing for high-resolution imaging of unstained biological tissues. The setup involves two lasers to probe specific molecular vibrations, producing CARS emission.
  • 3D Image Acquisition: CARS microscopy's optical sectioning capability allows for the acquisition of a stack of 2D images at different depths (a "z-stack"). These stacks are then reconstructed into 3D volumes.
  • Supervoxel-based 3D Segmentation: To analyze the 3D volumes, the researchers employed a modified Simple Linear Iterative Clustering (SLIC) algorithm to create "supervoxels." These are small, localized image regions that group similar voxels, effectively segmenting the 3D data while adhering to natural image boundaries. This approach is an extension of 2D superpixel segmentation.
  • Feature Extraction: Once segmented, cell nuclei within the 3D volumes are fitted with ellipsoids. Features extracted from these ellipsoids include nuclear volume, major and minor axis lengths, and orientation relative to neighbors. The inclusion of entropy of information in the feature vector for clustering and the 3D nature of measurements are key innovations.
  • Machine Learning Classification: The extracted 3D features are used to train a machine learning classifier. A leave-one-out cross-validation approach was used for evaluation, where a classifier is trained on all but one sample and then tested on that excluded sample.

Datasets

The study utilized mouse models of lung cancer. Specifically:

  • Human lung cancer cell lines: A549 (adenocarcinoma) and NCI-H226 (squamous cell carcinoma) were injected into nude mice.
  • Normal lung tissues: Acquired from control mice.
  • Ex vivo tissue samples: CARS images were acquired from these fresh, unstained tissue samples derived from the cell lines grown in mouse models.

The paper does not introduce a new public benchmark dataset but rather uses these specific experimental models for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The power of 3D over 2D: The most significant insight is the dramatic improvement in classification accuracy when moving from 2D to 3D analysis. This highlights how 2D slices can introduce sampling errors and obscure true morphological differences between cell types.
  • 3D captures native cell state: Evaluating cells in 3D provides a more accurate representation of their native state, free from the artifacts introduced by 2D sectioning. This is crucial for understanding subtle morphological differences.
  • CARS as a label-free diagnostic tool: The study reinforces CARS microscopy's potential as a rapid, label-free method for in situ diagnosis, reducing the need for chemical stains and preserving tissue.
  • Supervoxel segmentation for robust analysis: The use of supervoxel-based segmentation in 3D is a key methodological advancement, enabling accurate adherence to nuclear boundaries and reducing computational load for subsequent analysis.
  • Mouse models as a viable proxy: The success of the 3D approach even on mouse models, which can be more challenging to differentiate than human tumors, suggests its strong potential for clinical translation.

Key Results

  • High Classification Accuracy: The 3D analysis framework achieved a true positive rate of 99.56% for adenocarcinoma and 97.78% for squamous cell carcinoma, with very low false positive rates (0.45% and 2.22%, respectively). This is a significant improvement over the 2D analysis.
  • Improved Feature Separation: Five out of eight disease-related features showed significantly better separation between cell types in 3D compared to 2D. Notably, features related to nuclear size and shape, which were poorly separated in 2D, showed clear distinctions in 3D.
  • Rapid Diagnosis: The entire diagnostic process, from image acquisition to classification, can be performed within minutes.
  • Minimal Tissue Consumption: The label-free nature of CARS and the 3D analysis require minimal tissue, preserving valuable samples for subsequent molecular testing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mouse Model vs. Human Tumors: The authors acknowledge that the use of mouse models, while effective, may not fully capture the heterogeneity of human lung tumors. They suggest that future work should focus on human samples to further validate the approach and address potential challenges arising from greater complexity.
  • Subtype Differentiation: While the study successfully differentiates between major NSCLC cell types (adenocarcinoma and squamous cell carcinoma), further research is needed to explore the differentiation of more granular subtypes, which are increasingly important for targeted therapies.
  • In Vivo Application: The paper mentions the potential for CARS-based microendoscopy for in vivo diagnosis. Future work could focus on translating this ex vivo system into a real-time in vivo diagnostic tool.
  • Broader Feature Set: While distance-related features did not show clear separation, exploring other morphological or molecular features within the 3D CARS framework could further enhance diagnostic capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The advent of molecularly targeted therapies requires effective identification of the various cell types of non-small cell lung carcinomas (NSCLC). Currently, cell type diagnosis is performed using small biopsies or cytology specimens that are often insufficient for molecular testing after morphologic analysis. Thus, the ability to rapidly recognize different cancer cell types, with minimal tissue consumption, would accelerate diagnosis and preserve tissue samples for subsequent molecular testing in targeted therapy. We report a label-free molecular vibrational imaging framework enabling three-dimensional (3-D) image acquisition and quantitative analysis of cellular structures for identification of NSCLC cell types. This diagnostic imaging system employs superpixel-based 3-D nuclear segmentation for extracting such disease-related features as nuclear shape, volume, and cell-cell distance. These features are used to characterize cancer cell types using machine learning. Using fresh unstained tissue samples derived from cell lines grown in a mouse model, the platform showed greater than 97% accuracy for diagnosis of NSCLC cell types within a few minutes. As an adjunct to subsequent histology tests, our novel system would allow fast delineation of cancer cell types with minimum tissue consumption, potentially facilitating on-the-spot diagnosis, while preserving specimens for additional tests. Furthermore, 3-D measurements of cellular structure permit evaluation closer to the native state of cells, creating an alternative to traditional 2-D histology specimen evaluation, potentially increasing accuracy in diagnosing cell type of lung carcinomas.
BibTeX
@article{gao2012differential,
  author = {Liang Gao and Ahmad A. Hammoudi and Fuhai Li and Michael J. Thrall and Philip T. Cagle and Yuanxin Chen and Jian Yang and Xiaofeng Xia and Yubo Fan and Yehia Massoud and Zhiyong Wang and Stephen T.C. Wong},
  title = {{Differential diagnosis of lung carcinoma with three-dimensional quantitative molecular vibrational imaging}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.17.6.066017},
}
Figure