Difference in Analgesic Effects of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation According to the Site of Pain

Nobuhiko Mori, Koichi Hosomi, Asaya Nishi, Dong Dong, Takufumi Yanagisawa, Hui Ming Khoo, Naoki Tani, Satoru Oshino, Youichi Saitoh, Haruhiko KishimaFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study performed a mini meta-analysis of three previous clinical trials to investigate if the effectiveness of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for neuropathic pain varies depending on the location of the pain. The findings suggest that rTMS is effective for upper limb neuropathic pain but not for lower limb or facial pain, highlighting the importance of pain site in treatment outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique that has shown promise in treating chronic pain, particularly neuropathic pain. While systematic reviews and guidelines generally support its efficacy, a large, rigorous clinical trial by the authors failed to show a significant overall positive outcome. This led to a hypothesis that the effectiveness of rTMS might be influenced by the specific location of the neuropathic pain. Previous research has often targeted the primary motor cortex (M1) contralateral to the painful side, but the precise somatotopic organization and its impact on analgesic effects across different body parts (face, upper limb, lower limb) remained unclear. This paper aims to address this gap by specifically examining whether rTMS efficacy differs based on pain site.

Methods

The researchers conducted a "mini meta-analysis," which involved re-analyzing data from three of their own previously published clinical trials. These trials included:

  1. A multicenter randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 64 participants.
  2. An investigator-initiated registration-directed RCT with 142 participants.
  3. An exploratory clinical trial with 22 participants investigating different stimulation parameters.

The primary efficacy endpoint extracted from each trial was the change in pain scale (Visual Analog Scale - VAS). They then performed a meta-analysis comparing active rTMS to sham stimulation for patients with pain in the face, upper limb, or lower limb. A random-effects model was used to calculate the standardized mean difference (SMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) for pain change. Heterogeneity between studies was assessed using the chi-squared test and I² statistic.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it utilized data from three previously conducted clinical trials by the same research group:

  • Hosomi et al., 2013 (N=64, split into two groups A and B for analysis)
  • Hosomi et al., 2020 (N=142)
  • Mori et al., 2021b (N=22)

These trials involved patients with various types of neuropathic pain, including those resulting from cerebral lesions, spinal lesions, postherpetic neuralgia, complex regional pain syndrome, and phantom limb pain.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Somatotopic Specificity: The most significant insight is that the analgesic effect of rTMS targeting the primary motor cortex (M1) is not uniform across all pain locations. This suggests that the brain's representation of different body parts in the motor cortex plays a crucial role in how effectively rTMS can alleviate pain.
  • Upper Limb Advantage: The study strongly indicates that rTMS is particularly effective for neuropathic pain in the upper limb. This could be due to a more precise and effective stimulation of the M1 hand area, which is well-defined and has been a common target in previous rTMS studies for pain.
  • Limited Efficacy for Face and Lower Limb: Conversely, the meta-analysis did not find significant analgesic effects of rTMS for neuropathic pain in the lower limb or face. This suggests that current rTMS protocols and targeting strategies for these areas may be less effective.
  • RMT Differences: The study also noted differences in resting motor thresholds (RMT) across stimulation sites, with the M1 foot area requiring higher stimulation intensity than the M1 hand or face areas. This could contribute to the differential efficacy, as stimulating deeper or less accessible cortical areas might be more challenging.

Key Results

The meta-analysis revealed the following key quantitative results:

  • Overall Population: rTMS did not show a statistically significant analgesic effect for the entire population (SMD = -0.33, 95% CI: -0.70 to 0.04, P = 0.08).
  • Upper Limb Pain: rTMS demonstrated a favorable analgesic effect for upper limb pain (SMD = -0.45, 95% CI: -0.77 to -0.13, P < 0.01).
  • Lower Limb Pain: rTMS did not produce significant pain relief for lower limb pain (SMD = 0.04, 95% CI: -0.33 to 0.41, P = 0.82).
  • Facial Pain: rTMS was also not effective for facial pain (SMD = -0.24, 95% CI: -1.59 to 1.12, P = 0.73).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Number of Studies: The primary limitation is the small number of studies included in this "mini meta-analysis," as it only used their own previous trials. This restricts the generalizability of the findings and makes sensitivity analyses difficult.
  • Selection Bias: Due to the reliance on their own data, there is an inherent selection bias.
  • Heterogeneity: While heterogeneity was low for upper and lower limb pain analyses, it was moderate for the overall population and facial pain. The authors attribute this to the small sample size for facial pain.
  • Tentative Conclusions: Given these limitations, the authors emphasize that their conclusions should be considered tentative.

Future work should focus on:

  • Rigorous Meta-Analyses: Conducting larger, more comprehensive meta-analyses that include studies from multiple independent research groups.
  • Prospective Clinical Trials: Designing future trials that specifically report site-specific pain results to allow for more robust comparisons.
  • Investigating Optimal Stimulation: Further research is needed to explore optimal stimulation sites and parameters for different pain locations, potentially including alternative coil types (e.g., H-coil, double-cone coil) that can stimulate deeper brain regions more effectively.
  • Understanding Mechanisms: Investigating the underlying neurophysiological mechanisms that might explain the differential efficacy of rTMS across pain sites.

Summary updated

Abstract

High-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) of the primary motor cortex for neuropathic pain has been shown to be effective, according to systematic reviews and therapeutic guidelines. However, our large, rigorous, investigator-initiated, registration-directed clinical trial failed to show a positive primary outcome, and its subgroup analysis suggested that the analgesic effect varied according to the site of pain. The aim of this study was to investigate the differences in analgesic effects of rTMS for neuropathic pain between different pain sites by reviewing our previous clinical trials. We included three clinical trials in this mini meta-analysis: a multicenter randomized controlled trial at seven hospitals (<i>N</i> = 64), an investigator-initiated registration-directed clinical trial at three hospitals (<i>N</i> = 142), and an exploratory clinical trial examining different stimulation parameters (<i>N</i> = 22). The primary efficacy endpoint (change in pain scale) was extracted for each patient group with pain in the face, upper limb, or lower limb, and a meta-analysis of the efficacy of active rTMS against sham stimulation was performed. Standardized mean difference (SMD) with 95% confidence interval (CI) was calculated for pain change using a random-effects model. The analgesic effect of rTMS for upper limb pain was favorable (SMD = -0.45, 95% CI: -0.77 to -0.13). In contrast, rTMS did not produce significant pain relief on lower limb pain (SMD = 0.04, 95% CI: -0.33 to 0.41) or face (SMD = -0.24, 95% CI: -1.59 to 1.12). In conclusion, these findings suggest that rTMS provides analgesic effects in patients with neuropathic pain in the upper limb, but not in the lower limb or face, under the conditions of previous clinical trials. Owing to the main limitation of small number of studies included, many aspects should be clarified by further research and high-quality studies in these patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mori2021difference,
  author = {Nobuhiko Mori and Koichi Hosomi and Asaya Nishi and Dong Dong and Takufumi Yanagisawa and Hui Ming Khoo and Naoki Tani and Satoru Oshino and Youichi Saitoh and Haruhiko Kishima},
  title = {{Difference in Analgesic Effects of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation According to the Site of Pain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2021.786225},
}
Figure