Dictionnaire critique de l’utopie aux temps des Lumières, sous la direction de Bronislaw Baczko, Michel Porret, François Rosset

Péter BalázsStudi 2018 · DOI

The Dictionnaire critique de l’utopie aux temps des Lumières (Critical Dictionary of Utopia in the Enlightenment), edited by Bronislaw Baczko, Michel Porret, and François Rosset, represents a monumental achievement in the study of 18th-century intellectual history. Reviewed by Peter Balazs in the journal Studi Francesi, this 1,400-page volume synthesizes the contributions of over fifty specialists to redefine the utopian genre not as a collection of repetitive tropes, but as a sophisticated laboratory for social, political, and aesthetic experimentation.

Journal header for Studi Francesi

Redefining the Utopian Imaginary

Utopian literature of the Enlightenment has often been dismissed as monotonous or purely didactic. This dictionary challenges such characterizations by mapping the "utopian imaginary" across a vast landscape of literature, philosophy, and political theory. By structuring the work as an alphabetical thematic lexicon, the editors allow for a non-linear exploration of how "no-place" was used to interrogate real-world issues.

The scope of the dictionary is staggering, covering subjects ranging from social structures (slavery, gender, poverty) and physical spaces (architecture, urban planning) to abstract concepts like love, nature, and luxury. This breadth demonstrates that the "multiplicity and diversity" of utopian visions are their most defining traits.

Utopia as a Social Laboratory

One of the work's most significant insights is the portrayal of utopia as a rigorous testing ground for emerging social sciences. The Enlightenment utopia was not merely escapist fiction; it prefigured modern policy debates on demography, health (santé), and governance. The interdisciplinary nature of the entries highlights how utopian thought was inseparable from the era's aesthetic and philosophical shifts.

Published via OpenEdition Journals

A New Scholarly Standard

The project, which originated from the prestige of the Balzan Prize awarded to Bronislaw Baczko in 2011, has effectively established a new gold standard for Enlightenment studies. The contributors, including renowned scholars such as Didier Masseau and Antoine Lilti, provide original, in-depth essays that offer fresh perspectives on even well-trodden subjects like the "homme de lettres" or sexuality.

While the alphabetical organization is excellent for reference, it does present a certain fragmentation that might obscure the chronological evolution of ideas. Nevertheless, the Dictionnaire critique de l’utopie remains an essential resource for researchers, providing the "data" and thematic clusters necessary for future digital mappings of Enlightenment thought.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cet ouvrage volumineux, réunissant les études des meilleurs spécialistes de la pensée et de la littérature utopiques, fait le point critique sur les thématiques les plus importantes de l’imaginaire utopique dans la littérature, dans la philosophie, dans les conceptions politiques et dans l’esthétique des Lumières, période cruciale pour ce genre littéraire et pour ce mode de pensée. Rédigé par une bonne cinquantaine de chercheurs – dont Didier Masseau, Antoine Lilti, Jean-Michel Racault, Pierr...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balazs2018dictionnaire,
  author = {Péter Balázs},
  title = {{Dictionnaire critique de l’utopie aux temps des Lumières, sous la direction de Bronislaw Baczko, Michel Porret, François Rosset}},
  booktitle = {Studi},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.4000/studifrancesi.15323},
}
Figure