This blog post summarizes the abstract "Devolatilization of halogens in sediments and metasediments, New Caledonia," presented at the Goldschmidt 2024 conference.
TL;DR
Researchers tracked how halogens (F, Cl, Br, I) are redistributed and released as marine sediments are dragged into the Earth's interior via subduction zones. By analyzing metamorphic rocks from New Caledonia, the study reveals that chlorine concentrations in key minerals decrease as pressure and temperature rise, providing critical data for modeling the Earth's global volatile cycles.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Subduction zones act as the Earth’s primary recycling system, carrying water and volatile elements from the surface into the deep mantle. Among these volatiles, halogens (Fluorine, Chlorine, Bromine, and Iodine) are of particular interest because they influence the melting point of the mantle, the chemistry of volcanic eruptions, and the long-term evolution of our atmosphere and oceans.
While we know marine sediments are massive reservoirs for these elements—trapped in pore waters, organic matter, and minerals—we don't fully understand the "devolatilization" process. That is, how much of these halogens stay locked in the rock as it transforms under high pressure and temperature (metamorphism), and how much is released back toward the surface in fluids? This study seeks to quantify that transition by looking at a "fossil" subduction zone in New Caledonia.
Methods
The research team analyzed 35 metasediment samples representing a metamorphic gradient—from low-grade (prehnite-pumpellyite) to high-grade (eclogite) facies. To get a complete picture of halogen behavior, they combined three distinct analytical techniques:
- Electron Microprobe Analysis (EPMA): Used for in-situ analysis to determine the concentration of halogens within specific mineral grains in polished rock sections.
- Combustion Ion Chromatography (CIC): Employed to measure bulk halogen content.
- Noble Gas Method: A highly sensitive, specialized technique used specifically to measure the trace amounts of Bromine (Br) and Iodine (I), which are often too low for standard probes to detect accurately.
Datasets
The primary dataset consists of geochemical measurements from 35 metasediment samples collected from New Caledonia. These samples serve as a natural laboratory because they preserve a record of prograde metamorphism (the process of being buried and heated) across different "facies" or metamorphic stages.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Mineral-Specific Hosting: Chlorine isn't distributed evenly. In the "blueschist" stage (moderate depth), it is primarily hosted in phengite (a type of mica) and glaucophane (an amphibole).
- The "Leaky" Conveyor Belt: As the rocks move from blueschist to the deeper, hotter eclogite stage, the chlorine concentration in these minerals drops significantly. For example, phengite Cl levels drop from an average of 136 ppm to 83 ppm. This suggests that as the rock gets deeper, it "sweats out" chlorine into fluids that likely migrate back toward the Earth's surface.
- Clay Minerals as Initial Reservoirs: The study found that the lowest-grade rocks (the least metamorphosed) had the highest chlorine concentrations in clay minerals (up to 680 ppm), highlighting that clays are the primary vehicles bringing chlorine into the subduction zone before they break down.
Key Results
The quantitative findings show a clear downward trend in chlorine (Cl) retention as metamorphic grade increases:
| Mineral | Blueschist Facies (Avg Cl) | Eclogite Facies (Avg Cl) |
|---|---|---|
| Phengite | 136 ppm | 83 ppm |
| Glaucophane | 88 ppm | 64 ppm |
| Lawsonite | N/A | 47 ppm |
| Jadeite | N/A | 86 ppm |
In the lowest-grade rocks, clay minerals dominated the budget with 680 ppm Cl, while talc held roughly 50 ppm. These results confirm that prograde metamorphism leads to a systematic decrease in the halogen-carrying capacity of the subducting slab.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors note that this is an ongoing investigation with a few missing pieces:
- Apatite Data: Apatite is a major "sink" for halogens, but measurements for these samples are still pending. The final distribution model for chlorine cannot be completed until this data is integrated.
- Bulk vs. Mineral Models: The next step is to reconcile the mineral-specific data (what's inside the crystals) with bulk rock halogen data to see if the "mass balance" adds up.
- Refining Recycling Models: The ultimate goal is to use these New Caledonia findings to refine global models of how volatiles are recycled between the Earth's interior and the exterior environment.
Summary updated