Deviations from normal bedtimes are associated with short-term increases in resting heart rate

Louis Faust, Keith Feldman, Stephen M. Mattingly, David Hachen, Nitesh V. ChawlaNpj Digit. Medicine 2020 · DOI · OpenReview

Introduction

While sleep duration is the standard focus of health guidelines, recent research suggests that bedtime regularity is equally vital for cardiovascular health. A study analyzing over 250,000 nights of wearable data reveals that deviating from one's normal bedtime by as little as 30 minutes—whether earlier or later—significantly increases resting heart rate (RHR) during sleep. Notably, late bedtimes cause elevations that persist well into the following day.

The Importance of Bedtime Consistency

Most sleep hygiene advice emphasizes the "7 to 9 hours" rule for duration. However, human physiology operates on a circadian rhythm that thrives on consistency. While irregular bedtimes have been linked to poor cognitive and metabolic outcomes, their immediate impact on cardiovascular biomarkers like RHR remained less understood.

RHR is a critical biomarker; even small, sustained increases are associated with higher risks of cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality. This study sought to quantify how deviations from an individual’s "normal" bedtime affect RHR and how long it takes for these levels to return to baseline.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a longitudinal observational approach through the NetHealth study at the University of Notre Dame.

  • Data Source: The study followed 557 college students over four years (2015–2019), collecting 255,736 nights of sleep data via Fitbit Charge HR wearables.
  • Modeling: Linear mixed effects models accounted for inter-person variability. To isolate the effect of bedtime from natural daily fluctuations, observations were nested under the absolute time of day.
  • Technical Rigor: An unsupervised approach using Variational Bayesian estimation of a Gaussian Mixture Model (BGMM) was employed to filter out naps. The models also adjusted for sex, caffeine/alcohol consumption, physical activity, and sleep duration.

Key Findings

The study yielded several surprising insights into how our bodies react to schedule shifts:

  1. The "Late" Penalty is Persistent: Going to bed late doesn't just affect RHR during sleep; the elevation persists throughout the following day, only converging with normal levels by early evening (around 6:00 PM).
  2. Early Bedtimes are Stressors Too: Surprisingly, going to bed significantly early (over 30 minutes) also spikes RHR during sleep. However, unlike late bedtimes, RHR typically returns to baseline by the end of the sleep session.
  3. Consistency Over Duration: Even if the recommended 8 hours of sleep are achieved, starting those hours two hours later than usual keeps the cardiovascular system in a heightened state of stress.
  4. The 30-Minute Threshold: Physiological impacts begin at a low threshold. Deviations as small as 30 minutes showed statistically significant increases in RHR.

Results and Analysis

The magnitude of RHR increase correlates with the degree of bedtime deviation. For late bedtimes, a 30–60 minute delay was associated with an average RHR increase of 0.57 bpm, while deviations of 3 hours or more saw an increase of 2.74 bpm. Similarly, going to bed 3 hours early resulted in a 2.67 bpm increase during sleep.

Resting heart rate (RHR) trajectories during sleep for earlier (a) and later (b) bedtimes compared to "on time" sleep.

As shown in the figure above, while early sleepers' heart rates converged to normal by the 7th hour of sleep, late sleepers' heart rates remained significantly elevated. This indicates that the body fails to "catch up" during the sleep session itself when bedtime is delayed.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study's cohort consisted of young, healthy college students, meaning the cardiovascular response might be even more pronounced in older adults or those with underlying conditions. Furthermore, as an observational study, it identifies correlations rather than definitive causality; external stressors (like academic deadlines) could simultaneously cause both late bedtimes and elevated heart rates.

Future research aims to incorporate Heart Rate Variability (HRV) to better understand the autonomic nervous system's role and investigate whether these short-term RHR spikes lead to long-term cardiovascular remodeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite proper sleep hygiene being critical to our health, guidelines for improving sleep habits often focus on only a single component, namely, sleep duration. Recent works, however, have brought to light the importance of another aspect of sleep: bedtime regularity, given its ties to cognitive and metabolic health outcomes. To further our understanding of this often-neglected component of sleep, the objective of this work was to investigate the association between bedtime regularity and resting heart rate (RHR): an important biomarker for cardiovascular health. Utilizing Fitbit Charge HRs to measure bedtimes, sleep and RHR, 255,736 nights of data were collected from a cohort of 557 college students. We observed that going to bed even 30 minutes later than one’s normal bedtime was associated with a significantly higher RHR throughout sleep (Coeff +0.18; 95% CI: +0.11, +0.26 bpm), persisting into the following day and converging with one’s normal RHR in the early evening. Bedtimes of at least 1 hour earlier were also associated with significantly higher RHRs throughout sleep; however, they converged with one’s normal rate by the end of the sleep session, not extending into the following day. These observations stress the importance of maintaining proper sleep habits, beyond sleep duration, as high variability in bedtimes may be detrimental to one’s cardiovascular health.
BibTeX
@article{faust2020deviations,
  author = {Louis Faust and Keith Feldman and Stephen M. Mattingly and David Hachen and Nitesh V. Chawla},
  title = {{Deviations from normal bedtimes are associated with short-term increases in resting heart rate}},
  journal = {Npj Digit. Medicine},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41746-020-0250-6},
}
Figure