Development of a method to investigate the influence of engine oil and its additives on combustion anomalies in hydrogen engines

Kevin Gschiel, Kevin Wilfling, Michael Schneider

Abstract

To counteract the anticipated consequences of climate change, significant efforts are required across all industries. The use of hydrogen in internal combustion engines can make a valuable contribution as a carbon-neutral bridging technology. One challenge in developing a suitable combustion process is the high ignition propensity of hydrogen, impacting combustion stability due to combustion anomalies. Avoiding such combustion phenomena is of utmost relevance to ensure a long-term stable engine operation. Oil entry into the combustion chamber can impact the occurrence of combustion anomalies. Therefore, a specific method for controlled oil entry into the combustion chamber has been developed, and this method is detailed in the following article.

Introduction: The Challenge of Hydrogen Combustion

Hydrogen is a promising carbon-neutral fuel for internal combustion engines, particularly for heavy-duty transport. However, hydrogen is highly sensitive due to its very low minimum ignition energy and wide ignition limits. This makes hydrogen engines prone to combustion anomalies, specifically pre-ignition (PI), where the fuel-air mixture ignites before the spark plug fires. These anomalies can range from mild misfires to severe knocking and early pre-ignition, which can lead to catastrophic engine failure due to extreme pressure spikes.

Cylinder pressure traces showing various combustion anomalies, including misfire, knocking, and pre-ignition (PI), compared to regular combustion.

The Role of Engine Oil in Pre-Ignition

One of the primary suspects triggering these anomalies is engine oil. Droplets can enter the combustion chamber via several pathways, including the piston rings (cylinder wall), turbocharger seals, valve stem seals, or crankcase ventilation. Once inside, these droplets can auto-ignite under the high temperatures and pressures of the compression stroke, acting like a "phantom spark plug."

Schematic of an internal combustion engine highlighting potential pathways for engine oil entry into the combustion chamber.

To design better engines and specialized lubricants, researchers need a way to precisely control how much oil enters the engine and then measure its specific impact. Until now, there hasn't been a standardized, validated method to do this across different engine platforms.

Methodology: Standardizing Oil Dosing

Researchers at the Graz University of Technology modified two different engines for hydrogen operation: a 2.0L 4-cylinder passenger car (PC) engine and a 12.8L 6-cylinder heavy-duty (HD) engine. They compared two methods for "dosing" oil into the intake manifold:

  1. Atomizer Aerosol Generator: This creates a fine mist of oil droplets using compressed air. While it produces very small droplets, the output is highly sensitive to the oil's temperature and viscosity.
  2. Peristaltic Dosing Pump: This doses liquid oil directly through a "dosing lance" into the intake manifold. This method proved to be more robust because the volume of oil delivered remains constant regardless of the oil's physical properties, making it ideal for comparing different lubricant formulations.

To verify that the oil actually reached the combustion chamber, the team used a Carbon Balance approach. Since hydrogen fuel contains no carbon, any carbon detected in the exhaust (as $CO_2$, $CO$, or $HC$) must have come from the engine oil. This allowed for real-time calculation of exact oil consumption.

Key Results and Insights

The study utilized two distinct oil formulations to validate the methods: Sample A (Magnesium-based) and Sample B (Calcium-based). Tests at specific operating points revealed significant differences:

  • Oil Chemistry Impact: There was a massive difference between the two test oils. On the PC engine, Sample A produced over 200 PI events per gram of oil, while Sample B produced almost none under the same conditions.
  • Consistency Across Engines: The trend held true for the heavy-duty engine as well. Despite different geometries and mixture formation strategies, Sample A remained significantly more prone to causing pre-ignition than Sample B.
  • Viscosity Independence: The peristaltic pump proved superior for comparative research, delivering consistent mass regardless of oil thickness.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research establishes a robust, standardized method for investigating how engine oil and its additives influence combustion stability in hydrogen engines. While the study clearly ranks the "danger" of different oil chemistries, future work is needed to explain the underlying chemical mechanisms. Proposed next steps include optical investigations to visualize droplet ignition and studying the influence of exhaust back pressure in turbocharged systems. This method provides a critical tool for screening and optimizing new oil additives specifically designed for the next generation of hydrogen-powered vehicles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract To counteract the anticipated consequences of climate change, significant efforts are required across all industries. The use of hydrogen in internal combustion engines can make a valuable contribution as a carbon-neutral bridging technology. One challenge in developing a suitable combustion process is the high ignition propensity of hydrogen, impacting combustion stability due to combustion anomalies. Avoiding such combustion phenomena is of utmost relevance to ensure a long-term stable engine operation. Oil entry into the combustion chamber can impact the occurrence of combustion anomalies. Therefore, a specific method for controlled oil entry into the combustion chamber has been developed, and this method is detailed in the following article.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gschiel2024development,
  author = {Kevin Gschiel and Kevin Wilfling and Michael Schneider},
  title = {{Development of a method to investigate the influence of engine oil and its additives on combustion anomalies in hydrogen engines}},
  booktitle = {Automotive},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s41104-024-00141-7},
}
Figure